Showing posts with label covid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label covid. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 2, 2020

Youtube: Covid Conspiracy Theories

 The Case:

YouTube since its creation in 2005 has been rising in popularity not just in the U.S. but on an international level as well. With the general use of social media also on a steep increase since the early 2000’s they have become a host for a wide range of ethical debates surrounding topics such as privacy, ownership, usage, governmental control and many others. This case focuses specifically on the ethicality of conspiracy theorists using the massive platform during the global pandemic to promote radical misinformation surrounding Coronavirus.  Censorship and the First Amendment are terms often used together during debates such as this. The topic of what is and what is not covered by free speech in the United States has been part of heated debates and has been seen in various court cases. YouTube, a privately owned company, was deemed “not a public forum with guaranteed free speech” as of February of this year in a case ruled by San Francisco's Ninth Circuit appeals court (BBC). The court case was initiated by PragerU, a right-winged YouTube channel after YouTube censored its content. This leads into the concerning issue of the rapid widespread misinformation surrounding the coronavirus perpetuated by conspiracy theorists such as Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a notorious proponent of the anti-vaccination movement. 

After an interview between Patrick Bet-David, a popular financial YouTuber and Robert F. Kenedy, went viral on YouTube and in only two days gained over half a million views. Not only was the video monetized (limited ads) it also featured a catchy title promoting the “exclusive” interview and a link to his merchandise easily accessible in the description. The interview consisted of three separate videos, one of which was later removed by YouTube for violating its medical misinformation policies but not before over a million people had viewed it. Despite attempts from YouTube to censor and prevent the spread of misinformation, many health experts are concerned that this type of misinformation could still yield intensly dangerous outcomes even if content has been removed.

The Coronavirus outbreak was first declared a national emergency by President Trump March 13, 2020 and almost immediately conspiracy theories began to flood the internet and spread across social media platforms. Thus, as  2020 began so did the birth of coronavirus conspiracy theories. These original conspiracies claimed that billionaire Bill Gates created the virus, patented it, and would use vaccines to control people. These began floating around the internet when one went viral as soon as March 19, 2020 when a website called Biohackinfo.com falsely stated that Gates was intending to use a vaccine as a way to monitor people via microchip (Nature). Two days after a YouTube video surrounding this gained nearly two million views before being removed. This was the first warning sign that in addition to worrying about the Coronavirus itself, we may also have to fear the dangerous nature of this information. The reason it is such a concern not only for the platforms like YouTube but for researchers and health experts as well is because of the influence this medical misinformation has on people's actions and beliefs combined with the fact controlling and preventing the spread of misinformation is increasingly difficult. Within minutes a video can gain millions of views and according to a study from researchers at King’s College London those who get their news primarily from social media are much more likely to believe in these outlandish theories and additionally, break the rules of lockdown. It also showed that YouTube viewers are more likely to buy into COVID-19 conspiracies than people who get their news through other social media platforms. The research focused on potential public health risks posed by online conspiracy theories surrounding the pandemic. The research surveyed 2,254 people who live in the UK ages 16-70 in May of this year.  They asked participants if they believed in several different conspiracy theories. Some of the conspiracy theories include: that there is no hard evidence of a coronavirus and coronavirus is linked to 5G.  YouTube was found to be the most associated with these conspiracy beliefs (Business Insider).  

Since February, YouTube has reported that they have removed over 200,000 videos on the topic of dangerous and misleading information about coronavirus (Reuters). With the rise of misinformation spreading across social media these large companies have been more too quick to get involved to stop this. Labels, warnings, and links to quality news sources and public health organizers have been added to content throughout platforms such as YouTube, Facebook, Google, Twitter and Instagram. Lucky for the most part, ridiculous conspiracy theories have been managed and limited in popularity. In February of this year a number of these outrageous theories spread on YouTube, but more recently a hit video entitled “Plandemic” became popular which alleges that a cabal of elites is using the pandemic as a cover to profiteer and entrench their power. The video was quickly adopted and believed by groups like anti-vaccinators and the QAnon conspiracy group. The video features discredited scientist Dr. Judy Mikovis who became the star of coronavirus misinformation. Uploads of the “Plandemic” have over 8 million views across varying social media platforms. YouTube alone is the source of 7.1 million of those views before it was removed. Erin Gallagher, a social media researcher explains that, “The video spread from YouTube to Facebook thanks to highly active QAnon and conspiracy-related Facebook groups with tens of thousands of members which caused a massive cascade” (Verge). 

According to a BBC article the study published in the journal of Psychology Medicine found that, “There was a strong positive relationship between use of social media platforms as sources of knowledge about Covid-19 and holding one or more conspiracy beliefs," the study finds. "YouTube had the strongest association with conspiracy beliefs, followed by Facebook.” Interestingly, the research also found that those who left their homes with possible symptoms of COVID-19 were more than twice to three times as likely  than those who did not rely on Facebook and/or Youtube for news updates regarding the virus. A point emphasized from the study was that they held the opinion that social media companies like Facebook and Youtube need to do more to control this spread of false information. A spokesperson from Facebook said, “We have removed hundreds of thousands of Covid-19-related misinformation that could lead to imminent harm including posts…” (BBC). The opportunity for individuals to reach the masses with just a few clicks of a button is being abused by conspiracy theorists and are taking advantage of vulnerable audiences. 


Stakeholders:

With such a dense and complex case there are a variety of key stakeholders and decision makers at play. Stakeholders are those who may be affected or can affect company decisions. Firstly, the founders of the platform Chad Hurley, Steve Chen, and Jawed Karim, former PayPal employees. Google and it’s management are also important to mention as YouTube was bought by Google in 2006, just one year after it’s creation. YouTube has since operated as one of Google’s subsidiaries. This generally includes employees of Youtube (LLC) which is made up of managers, administrators, and other employees. 

Next, and arguably most important is the platform and internet users and creators. Copyright owners are also involved in this category in either the form of owners of copyrighted videos or music. Society and the platform audience are also part of those who may affect or be affected by YouTube decisions. 

Although YouTube is privately owned, the government is another thing to mention when discussing the topic. As mentioned previously, governmental and policy intervention is always at play or at least a topic of debate. This being said, other social media platforms and their owners and stakeholders can also be linked to those of YouTube not only because of how policies may impact YouTube as well, but the competitive aspect of business as well. 


Individualism: 

Individualism argues that the sole goal of business is centered around profit, thus meaning that the concern of business people is to maximize profits for the owner(s) and/or stockholders. When looking at the case from this perspective we would look at the way in which the conspiracy theorists are in a way stealing potential profit from YouTube. This is seen through the damage of the platform's reputation, combined with the need to spend more money on resources to control content coupled with any marketing and public statements from the company.  Milton Friedman, renowned Economist argues that the only social responsibility of business is to increase profits, “so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition, without deception or fraud” (DesJardins 54).  Friedman also views business should operate considering their desires which as a general desire is to make money and as much of it as possible. 

Applying this concept to the case we can see where an ethical argument arises, especially surrounding the principle that although business should maximize profits, it must do so in accordance with the law and free of deception. The key  conspiracy theorists involved in the case are clearly motivated by the desire of profit but in attempting to achieve this they use YouTube to spread deception. YouTube thus has the obligation to take this into consideration as they are going against the set terms and conditions of the site. Could YouTube ignore the problem based on a desire to maximize profits, of course, however when an ethical line is crossed it is their responsibility to consider this in alliance with individualism. While individualism is centered around personal and business profit it also clarifies that business must operate within the law. As seen with Tibor Machan’s individualism, business people can have other goals and they can be prioritized over the primary goal which is profit-maximizing. It is also important to consider that in the long run YouTube may actually zacheince the goal of maximizing profits through an indirect goal of creating a safe and reliable community of creators. 


Utilitarianism

When considering this case from a utilitarianism perspective it is inherently unethical because the goal is to maximize happiness in yourself and others. The spread of dangerous information to millions of vulnerable people throughout the world goes directly against this ideology. When looking at how YouTube addressed the situation it gets more complicated. There is a difficult balance between what is and what is not considered free speech and what type of content opposes the terms and conditions of the platform. YouTube in this case for the most part does align ethically with this perspective in the way that they are trying to ensure maximum happiness free of negative and dangerous content. 

According to John Stuart Mill on this ethical perspective happiness and pleasure are the only things of intrinsic value and in terms of morally there is no difference between individual happiness and that of others. Another important component of utilitarianism is that, “...we can determine the ethical significance of any action by looking at the consequences of that act...with the policy of “maximizing the overall good” or, in a slightly different version, of producing “the greatest good for the greatest number” (DesJardins 29). This is largely where the utilitarian perspective really aligns with the case because this is exactly how YouTube is reacting to the situation. The greatest good for the greatest number is exactly what is happening, as YouTube seems to prioritize how the negative content is impacting a large amount of people rather than focusing on how it may be affecting the few who are generating the content. 


Kantianism

A katianism perspective of this case would see YouTube as acting in line with the  kantian ethical principles, especially based on its emphasis on acting rationally. With the spike in Coronavirus cases and the connection between YouTube conspiracy viewers and those breaking quarantine restrictions, there is truly only one rational action which is to control and prevent the misinformation from being spread. 

More importantly YouTube, unlike many other big corporations, do not consider themselves exempt from rules. Infact, they actually hold themselves accountable in this case. It is not as if the government or other forces are instructing the company to remove the misinformation. Rather, YouTube has taken preventative measures such as adding warning labels to all coronavirus related content. These measures are in addition to their previous efforts to regulate, control, monitor, and remove content that goes against the terms of posting information. Another major principal of kantianism is to help individuals make rational decisions as well. So, not only is YouTube themselves acting both rational and consistent, they are attempting to help others do so as well. This is being done through the use of warnings and additionally providing reliable links to verified information. By engaging in these actions they are encouraging the platform audiences to be aware of potential misinformation and guiding them to factually accurate information on the virus and vaccines. 

The various different ways YouTube is attempting to control the content also aligns with respecting individual needs and differences. Because of the fact that a vast majority of the population with varying backgrounds and education levels has access to this free and easy to access information they are using not just one method of counteracting misformation.


Virtue Theory

The major concern embedded within virtue theory is how businesses are acting in the situation and not necessarily how it turns out. Whereas individualism focuses on the end goal of profit making there is less of an emphasis on final results and more so on character and actions. Virtue ethics, which is based on Aristotle's ethics looks at character traits and virtue that constitute a good and full human life (DesJardins 41). In this regard, looking at the case considering the ethical perspective of the virtue theory it seems that again YouTube does align ethically here for the most part. Just like with kantianism, rationality is a contributing aspect of the theory which states that people exercise rationality in order to function well and as a result live good lives. Once again we can see how YouTube complies with this in how they responded by deeming most of this harmful content against the rules of the platform. 

Virtue ethics is also based on the principle that those who function well and as a result live good lives will also lead happy lives. If these are all in line then one who lives a good life also functions well and is therefore happy. YouTube in this case demonstrates a skill in functioning both efficiently and functionally. Thus, according to virtue ethics the rest must also be true. YouTube since February has successfully removed over 200,000 of these videos which is an indicator of functioning well. Monitoring content on the abyss of the internet is not an easy task but they seem to be using their resources to engage in both rational and funcional means of removal. As explained with the Doctrine of the Mean there needs to be a balance  between extremes. If we apply this to the case YouTube does try and find a balance between allowing creators to continue to make content even if it is questionable while also removing those videos they deem to cross the line.  


Justified Ethics Evaluation: 

Although I am a firm believer in freedom of speech and the importance of having a platform where one is able to voice their opinions and share content, I also think YouTube is doing the correct things by censoring this type of misinformation. Coronavirus is a very serious problem and far too many people are being influenced by these conspiracy theories. As the study showed, especially those influenced by content found on YouTube they are more likely to violate the rules of lockdown. In the current age of mass media it is a near impossible task to monitor the content that spreads and once it's put on the internet it's there for good even if it has been removed by YouTube. 

I believe that the government should also take a more active role in counteracting the spread of this information. The more people that buy into this fake news, the worse off this country as a whole is. While I do believe that having a platform to be creative is important this is more so an issue of safety than freedom of speech 

I am overall impressed with the action taken on behalf of YouTube to combat the spread of this type of information. As previously discussed the conspiracy theorist and other creators who are hosting the content have sneaky, clever, and catchy ways of disguising the conspiracies as fact. With the existing YouTube algorithm and team which monitors the content they were able to successfully identify and remove many of the videos. The problem of the viral and lasting nature of the internet continues to exist and is making the job of YouTube and similar social media sites even harder especially at a time where doing so is much more vital. 


Action Plan:

Although YouTube has taken several steps to address the issues plaguing the platform, they are still lacking in several areas. The company successfully and most importantly has acknowledged and addressed the problem through various interviews and press statements. They have also additionally taken steps to remove and prevent misinformation. Since the increase in both coronavirus cases and the conspiracies that follow YouTube has announced its plans to further restrict and monitor the content. So, while these are good primary steps YouTube needs to not only give broad ways they are planning to change, but rather give specific steps and perhaps even alter their current business model. YouTube is known for its wide range of content and is often praised for the creation of a space that allows people to be creative and express their beliefs, opinions and passions. However, what is up for debate here is what the line needs to be drawn. 

Youtube's current mission statement is as follows,  “Our mission is to give everyone a voice and show them the world. We believe that everyone deserves to have a voice, and that the world is a better place when we listen, share and build community through our stories.” (YouTube). They also cite four freedoms that define who they are: freedom of expression, freedom of information, freedom of opportunity, and freedom to belong. While these are great business ethics and principles it does somewhat contradict the inherent nature of this case. One could argue that the conspiracy videos are in fact complying with YouTube’s business model. 

YouTube is a very profitable business however this type of negative news surrounding the company may be hurting them by deterring audience members while simultaneously encouraging groups with malicious intent to swarm the platform. In order for them to not only remain profitable but increase profits and favorable public opinions centered around good ethics they should adhere to some of the following guidelines. 

Redefine their values and change how they address the problem: 

  1. Define freedom - while this is a primary principle of YouTube, it seems as though a few too many people have pushed the limits of what this means. We see the discussion of freedom of speech a frequent topic of debate and this is just that. There will always be people who wish to do harm but if YouTube wants to extinguish that they need to be more clear in who they are and what they believe in.

  2. Creativity and media - this is one area that seems to be missing in the case despite YouTube being a major part of that. As an extremely influential media company they should use this to their advantage and engage in creative problem solving with their own platform. Yes, they are removing videos and adding warning labels, but they have not addressed the issue in their own creative platform. If their audience are those who use social media, specifically YouTube then perhaps that is the most effective way to get their attention.

  3. Audience - in business understanding one’s audience and consumer market is an essential component to profit making. It seems that in this case YouTube needs to focus on not the huge and diverse audience base but on the ones who are most likely to believe, watch, engage, and create the misinformation. This may also aid in a more financially efficient plan. 

In order to restore the company to better public opinion, ethics and profits it is important to have a strong action plan. As an active user of both YouTube and similar social media platforms I have noticed the warning labels on content related to COVID-19. I think another thing they may need to do is make stricter policies on misinformation. As we saw with the interview featuring David-Bet, only one of the three videos were removed because it did not technically violate their policies. At least temporarily conspiracies about coronavirus should be banned if they are being disguised as the truth. With this type of content, including fake news in general it is often believed because it looks believable and it is posted on reliable (or seemingly reliable) websites. Many of us depend on YouTube as a source of learning and with misinformation sprinkled in this is problematic. 

Youtube itself should post its own content that is creatively marketed to inform people of correct information about the virus and deter people from falling into the trap of believing conspiracies. While it's true that these videos can get a lot of views and generate both money and traffic towards YouTube in the long run they will be more financially benefited by building a source and audience base centered around the truth. 

The actions taken thus far by YouTube are great first steps, but with the expanding problem it is clear that more needs to be done. Nowadays image and reputation can make or break a company and a controversy like this definitely impacts public opinion. With some more focus on the problem YouTube should have no problem restoring both its reputation and financial. 


As depicted and explained throughout the case YouTube has taken extra precautions in monitoring the content that conflicts with their community guidelines.



The conspiracy video "Plandemic" produced by Mikki Willis, promoted and spread dangerous misinformation to millions of people before it was removed. 


Bibliography:

Ball, P., & Maxmen, A. (2020, May 27). The Epic Battle Against Coronavirus

Misinformation and Conspiracy Theories. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01452-z


Culliford, E., & Dave, P. (2020, October 14). YouTube Bans Coronavirus Vaccine

Misinformation. https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-youtube-int/youtube-bans-coronavirus-vaccine-misinformation-idUSKBN26Z21R


DesJardins, Joseph.An Introduction to Business Ethics.New York City:

The McGraw Hill Companies Inc, 2014


Easton, M. (2020, June 18). Coronavirus: Social media 'spreading virus conspiracy

theories'. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-53085640


Hamilton, I. (2020, June 19). People Who believe wild coronavirus conspiracy theories

rely on YouTube for most of their information on the pandemic. https://www.businessinsider.com/youtube-coronavirus-conspiracy-theories-2020-6


Newton, C. (2020, May 12). How the 'Plandemic' video hoax went viral. https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/12/21254184/how-plandemic-went-viral-facebook-youtube


QAnon: YouTube moves to purge 'harmful conspiracy theories'. (2020, October 15).

https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54562802 




Monday, November 30, 2020

Wells Pharmacy Network: Unapproved COVID19 Treatment (2020)

Wells Pharmacy Network is a compounding pharmacy that specializes in wellness, anti-aging, weight management, urology, sexual health, thyroid and adrenal health, and veterinary compounding solutions. They claim that “patient safety is [their] priority and [their] commitment to the quality of the preparations [they] compound is the most important thing [they] do each and every day” [11]. Looking into the history of the Wells Pharmacy Network, one would see that this a very far-fetched claim. They have had several scandals in the past decade including unsanitary conditions, misbranded drugs, recalled products, and several FTC violations. The most recent wrongdoing of the compounding pharmacy is Quad Immune. Quad Immune is “a combination of 4 products clinically demonstrated effects on the immune system” [6]. Wells Pharmacy Network has advertised Quad Immune as a treatment for COVID19. This sounds all well and good until you find out that their big ticket item, Thymosin alpha 1 “has not been approved by FDA, nor has it been proven safe or effective for treating COVID-19” [5]. 

This case will be looked at through the four different ethical lenses, Individualism, Utilitarianism, Kantianism, and Virtue Theory. According to Individualism, the actions were unethical as they broke the FTC. Then a utilitarian would argue that more harm was done in the case than maximizing happiness. A Kantian will argue that the company’s actions were impermissible because they were not loyal or honest to their patients. And according to Virtue Theory, this case is unethical because Wells Pharmacy Network did not satisfy any of the four characteristics: courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. Based on these ethical theories, I would suggest that the company needs to fix all of the problems they have had over the past several years to repair their image and their relationship with their patients. 


Company Background:

In the summer of 2012, Franck's Compounding Lab of Franck's Pharmacy in Ocala, Florida was closed in the wake of The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) warning “urging physicians not to use sterile products made by Franck's Pharmacy. The warning was issued after the CDC traced a rare fungal eye infection back to the pharmacy” [4]. The drug that was giving patients fungal infections in their eyes was called Brilliant Blue G, or BBG, which was never approved by the FDA. “Investigations by numerous state, county and federal health agencies concluded that Franck’s BBG was adulterated and not sterile and that the defendants had violated numerous federal rules and regulations” [7]. “The FDA investigators observed numerous instances of unsanitary and inappropriate practices by compounding technicians who left and re-entered clean rooms without changing lab coats, who were touching non-sterile items while wearing their sterile gloves and then returned to compounding activities” [7]. This was the last of many scandals from Franck’s Pharmacy. 

The connection from Wells Pharmacy Network to Franck’s Pharmacy is that “Franck’s Compounding Lab, which was one of the largest compounding labs in the country, was bought by Wells Pharmacy Network” [4]. Wells Pharmacy Network inherited these problems while knowing about them. Obviously problems would arise from this. For example, from the summer of 2013 to the summer of 2014, the FDA conducted their scheduled inspections of the Wells Pharmacy Network compounding facilities. During these investigations the FDA found many violations like “serious deficiencies in [their] practices for producing sterile drug products, which could lead to contamination of the products, which put patients at risk,” “invalid prescriptions for individually-identified patients for a portion of the drug products you produce,” [9] and many others.

Two years later in 2016, a major recall of 616 recently produced products at the time. The recall was prompted by another concern about sterility from the FDA. The FDA did not force the recall meaning Wells Pharmacy made the call themselves. In the recall announcement The compounding lab claimed that "no vial or portion of any lot of these medications has been found to be nonsterile" [3] and gave the excuse that their facilities were “undergoing an expansion and enhancement and the FDA would have preferred that we stop production during construction” [3]. Some of the dots do not connect because why would a compounding pharmacy still be producing drugs in areas of construction in the first place. In addition, why would the company recall products that they have claimed to not be nonsterile. It seems as though they are trying to cover their tracks by being misleading in their recall. 

COVID19 Scandal:

After all of these scandals and more, Wells Pharmacy Network had their most recent scandal involved with the COVID19 pandemic. Wells is known for wellness, anti-aging, weight management, urology, sexual health, thyroid and adrenal health, and veterinary compounded pharmaceuticals. So it seems like viruses like influenza and SARS are not in their field of research, or expertise. It's odd to see them develop a treatment/cure for COVID19 right in time for the summer of 2020, right when the US was months into a quarantine/lockdown because of the COVID19 pandemic. 

Image from Wells Pharmacy Network website.

This is when Wells Pharmacy came out with their brand new product called Quad Immune. Quad Immune was announced by a doctor that did not even work on developing the product. This doctor is Dr. Gordon Crozier, “a board-certified physician, speaker, lecturer, and best-selling author” [6]. For the online webinar announcement for the product, Dr. Crozier discussed “that there has never been a better time to optimize you and your patient’s immune system.” [6]. No better time to advertise a “treatment” for a virus, than during a worldwide pandemic. Quad Immune consists of  the four drugs, “Thymosin alpha 1, Zinc, Vitamin D, and Vitamin B Complex with Vitamin C. Quad Immune supports the human immune response against viral infections, and Thymosin alpha 1 has been shown in studies to help regulate pro-inflammatory cytokine storms” [6]. Wells Pharmacy Network’s product catalog for 2020 explains the four substances included in the Quad Immune package. 

Image from the official 2020 catelog.

The Thymosin Alpha 1 (TA1) injection is the main drug in Quad Immune. The catalog states “studies have demonstrated improvements in immune system cell subsets and the potential of TA1 for the treatment of a range of diseases. Thus, Thymosin Alpha 1, due to the immune stimulating effects exhibited by TA1, may have utility for the treatment of age or disease related immune suppression” [11]. The biggest problem with these claims about the TA1 injection is that it has never been approved by the FDA to treat any illness, disease, or virus. On the bottom of the Thymosin Alpha 1 injection page to the catalog the fine print says that “This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease” [11], meaning that everything they have claimed about the injection has not even been proven. So in the official catalog, they are advertising unapproved information that could be very harmful. 

The thymosin alpha-1 injection.

If one were to look into thymosin alpha 1, they would find the several side effects that can happen even if someone uses the injection as instructed. Thymosin alpha 1’s generic brand name is Zadaxin. Zadaxin has been prescribed to patients in order to treat hepatitis B. These same patients have experienced common side effects such as “redness and discomfort at the injection site, muscle atrophy, multiple joint aches and pains, and swelling and rash of the hand” [8]. Along with the studies showing thymosin alpha 1 improving the immune system’s functions, there is also a mechanism of the injection that has done the opposite. In some studies, the drug has shown to have “a feed-back dampening effect on the immune system, leading to increases in regulatory T cells and a decrease in the production of inflammatory cytokines” [10]. From the several studies testing the injection, there is not much certainty in what its true functions are. This is why the drug has yet to be approved by the FDA.

Wells Pharmacy Network was not the only company making these claims about TA1. There were “more than 30 medical practices and compounding pharmacies across more than a dozen states that have made unproven claims about this drug on their websites and on social media” [2] including Wells Pharmacy Network. The majority of these 30 companies promoting thymosin alpha-1 as a treatment for COVID19 “do not specialize in infectious diseases, but rather focus on plastic surgery or promote ‘wellness,’ ‘anti-aging’ and ‘regenerative’ medicine” [5] just like Wells. It seems like these companies are making claims that they are not qualified enough to make. The problems with this widespread advertisement all across the country during a worldwide pandemic is that every one of their patients are worried and anxious about the coronavirus and will most likely try anything to keep themselves safe. They will put their trust into these companies that look like they know what they are talking about and be manipulated to purchase some drug that could possibly harm them. It also“can make it even more difficult for patients to figure out whom or what to believe, especially if the information is coming from doctors” [2]. On top of putting their health at risk, buying thymosin alpha 1 could also put their wallets at risk since ‘the cost of the drug can run up to $400 for a month's supply, all out of pocket” [2]. Social media has made advertising a lot easier as well for these companies. In April 2020, Wells Pharmacy Network “promoted thymosin alpha-1 on Facebook along with the hashtags "#coronavirus" and "#covid" [2] in order to reach a wider audience and make more money off of their misinformation.  

Because thymosin alpha-1 is not approved by the FDA, it's “unavailable through pharmaceutical companies in the U.S. Instead, it's reaching consumers through an alternative source: compounding pharmacies” [2].  A compounding pharmacy creates custom medications from base ingredients for patients. Rather than providing a pre-mixed formula, the compounding pharmacist begins with base drugs, combining and preparing them to fit the individual patient's needs. Compounding comes with its own problems, however. Even though the base ingredients are from the FDA they do “not test or evaluate drugs made in those pharmacies. So even though those drugs may be legally prescribed, they are never considered FDA approved" [2]. “The medications used in compounding formulas, when broken down, are virtually identical from a chemical perspective. The only real difference is that compounding pharmacies combine the ingredients in-house to meet the individual patient’s needs” [1]. According to many experts in the field, compounding pharmacies are “largely unregulated” [7] and frequently run into scandals like these. 


Ethical Theory Analysis: 

Stakeholders:

The main stakeholders in this case are the patients and employees of  Wells Pharmacy Network, the FDA and FTC and Wells Pharmacy Network as a whole. The patients are the ones who are getting put in harm's way so they are the ones who have the most to lose in this terrible situation. Next is the employees and Wells Pharmacy Network itself because if this scandal gets really big, they could lose money, customers, and/or their jobs. And lastly the FDA and FTC need to be worried about this situation and other situations like this because the health and safety of the patients and the responsibility of keeping compounding companies like Wells Pharmacy Network in check is all on their shoulders. If they drop the ball like this more they could lose reliability. 


Individualism:

The theory of individualism states that the only goal a business has is to maximize their profits for themselves and their shareholders, but to do it within the law. The only direct goal of any business is to profit, but there's still an obligation to be lawful in their practices. 

Wells Pharmacy Network was trying to make themselves look better by saying they had the drug that would make one immune to the coronavirus. They were hoping they could make a profit off of this misinformation, and probably did so,  but this was an illegal action. These kinds of actions violate the Federal Trade Commission Act, also known as the FTC Act. Under this Act, the FTC is empowered to prevent unfair methods or practices that affect commerce; seek monetary relief and other relief to consumers that were harmed or injured; enforce rules against acts or practices that are unfair or deceptive, and establish requirements designed to prevent such acts or practices; conduct investigations relating to the organization, business, practices, and management of entities engaged in any type of commerce; and make reports and legislative recommendations to Congress and the public [FTC Act]. Wells Pharmacy Network Violated this act by using misinformation about the TA1 injection to promote its sale. This action is deceitful and unfair to the customers and patients of the compounding pharmacy, so Wells has broken this fundamental law of the FTC. This is an unethical and impermissible action in an individualism sense even if they were trying to maximize their profits from the drug. 


Utilitarianism: 

In utilitarian theory, an action is deemed ethical if it promotes happiness to the maximum number of people. Happiness is the only thing  that has intrinsic value and should be brought out to all stakeholders and doing so impartially for the long run. On the other hand, if an action does not bring the most amount of happiness or even harms any of the stakeholders, it is considered impermissible to a utilitarian. 

Wells pharmacy was probably very happy that they could fool a few customers into buying the immunity from covid, making themselves a little bit of money in the short run, but in the long run the customers are going to be unhappy with them when they find out it was all just a ruse. So in the long run, this scandal could cause Wells Pharmacy Network to lose business or even get shut down for good. The worst part of the compounding pharmacy’s actions is that it put the recipients of the TA1 injection at risk. Several studies have shown no definitive pros to using thymosin alpha-1 but have shown some side effects that could ultimately hurt the person taking the drug. To a utilitarian, if anyone is being harmed from an action, that action is deemed impermissible. 


Kantianism:

Kant’s theory says that it is wrong for one to manipulate and exploit people for their own advantage. The basic principles of Kantianism are to act rationally, to help others make rational decisions, to respect people, to be driven by one’s own goodwill, and to do the right thing because it is right. According to Kant, if an action follows these principles, that action is considered permissible. The test that is used to see if an action is permissible or impermissible is called the Categorical Imperative. The Categorical Imperative is based on the Formula of Humanity which states that it is wrong to use people as a mere means to get what you want out of them because it exploits them. 

. Wells Pharmacy Network’s actions during the COVID19 pandemic would fail the Categorical Imperative test. They manipulated their customers with lies to make them buy a phony coronavirus treatment. They found out a way to “misuse patients' trust to help create a market for drugs that haven't been proven to work” [2]. These deceitful actions from the compounding company use the patients as a mere means to make a little extra cash during a tough time. Overall, Wells used their patients as objects in order to get what they wanted out of them, money. 


Virtue Theory:

Virtue Theory focuses on four main virtues that include courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. Having courage means one will take risks and stand up for what is morally right. Being honest is agreeing to be truthful with everything one does in their life. Temperance is having self-control in any situation where one wants to do something that could be morally wrong. Justice defines what is lawfully right and fair in life. All four of these virtues must be met in order to be a virtuous or ethical person. 

We can apply virtue theory to Wells Pharmacy Network to see if they are ethical in their practices or not. The company was courageous in one way by taking a risk to promote an unapproved drug to the public, but this was a risk taken in the wrong direction. Since they did not stand up for what is morally right in this situation by not acknowledging they had done something morally wrong and also not trying to initiate a plan to undo this wrongdoing, Wells Pharmacy Network cannot be considered courageous. The most obvious problem with the compounding pharmacy is that they were never honest with their patients, the FDA and FTC, nor with themselves. They purposely lied to try to make a profit. The pharmacy had no temperance in this situation since they couldn’t stop themselves from being unethical and manipulative just to make a quick buck. They saw an easy opportunity to take advantage of their patients and they couldn’t stay away. Lastly, they do not demonstrate the characteristic of justice since they were not lawful or fair in their practices during the pandemic. They violated the FTC Act which breaks the law, and they used their customers’ insecurities about the pandemic against them which was unfair. So according to virtue theory, Wells Pharmacy Network has none of the four virtues needed to be ethical, therefore they are not. 


Justified Ethics Evaluation:

        In my opinion, Wells Pharmacy Network should not be in business anymore. They have received too many second chances for some reason after all of the problems they have caused over the past decade. They began prescribing thymosin alpha-1 early on in the pandemic to give people something that they can do so that they felt like they weren't helpless. But in the long run they were potentially putting their own patients at harm. I think promoting thymosin alpha-1 as a coronavirus treatment was unlawful and unethical because those such claims were not supported by reliable scientific evidence. The whole point of putting a drug on the market is that there are several good, reliable, and respected scientific studies proving that the drug really helps to treat or cure some medical condition or illness. Peoples’ health, wellbeing, and safety are on the line, and that should not be put on the back burner just to make more money. That is just not right. 

On top of this, I believe there are several problems with compounding pharmacies, from the non-FDA approved drugs, to the several safety hazards and unsanitary conditions. I think compounding facilities should not be trusted since almost every company of this kind has a history that is very similar to Wells’. Something just doesn’t feel right to me that ingredients get put together by people other than those working for the FDA. I think there needs to be a lot more regulation in this field for the health and safety of everyone. 


Action Plan:

There are many steps Wells Pharmacy Network needs to take if they even want to get close to repairing their image. The pure number of scandals they have alone makes them look bad. I think a good start for Wells could be to follow the law entirely, so no cutting corners or loopholes. That type of behavior from professionals is unexceptable. Another big thing they need to work on is being completely transparent and honest with their patients. They state on their website that patient safety is their number one priority, but that could not be further from the truth. 

A new mission statement for the company should be “We vow to keep our patients safe, happy, and healthy by using the most reliable and trustworthy science around.” This statement is much less vague than the mission statement they have now, which is an improvement in itself. The new statement also ensures that there will be no manipulation or unfairness, and that all of the patients will be in good hands. 

Wells Pharmacy Network could also follow some core values in order to become more ethically efficient in their actions. Their new core values should involve authenticity, patient safety, responsibility, and intelligence. The company really needs to work on being authentic and honest because that has been their biggest struggle during their several scandals. Being honest will be challenging for them because of all of the easy loopholes that come with being a compounding pharmacy. In my opinion focusing on patient safety is the most important thing for them to do. If they keep putting the public in harm's way, they could get shut down for good. If they want to be taken seriously from this point on, they will need to be responsible and act like real professionals. And finally, Wells Pharmacy Network needs to be more intelligent when making decisions. If they do not, the state of the company could be destroyed. Changes in policies, like a new mission statement and four core values need to take place if Wells wants to have any kind of future as a successful company.

A good thing for the company could be finding completely new management and other higher positions like CEO. The new employment should be from the same field but should also be known for being trustworthy to patients. Wells needs to rethink their marketing strategy as well. Using the marketing tools they have now makes them break the laws enforced by the FTC. They have to stop using deceitful and unfair misinformation when marketing their products. If Wells follows a plan similar to this, they could mend up their relationship with their patients and possibly become more successful and make even more of a profit off of doing good instead of doing bad. 


Resources:

[1] Apothecary, Archway. “3 Differences Between Compounding & Retail Pharmacies.” Archway Apothecary, 28 Aug. 2019, archwayapothecary.com/3-differences-between-compounding-retail-pharmacies/.

[2] Dreisbach, Tom. “Web Of 'Wellness' Doctors Promote Injections Of Unproven Coronavirus Treatment.” NPR, NPR, 1 Oct. 2020, www.npr.org/2020/10/01/914433778/web-of-wellness-doctors-promote-injections-of-unproven-coronavirus-treatment.

[3] Goldschmidt, Debra. “Wells Pharmacy Network Recalls Hundreds of Products.” CNN, Cable News Network, 22 Sept. 2016, www.cnn.com/2016/09/22/health/wells-pharmacy-network-recall/index.html.

[4] Indest III, George F. “Are You Facing Allegations Against Your Medical License?” The Health Law Firm, 22 Aug. 2012, www.thehealthlawfirm.com/blog/posts/franck-s-pharmacy-closes-its-doors-compounding-lab-becomes-wells-pharmacy-network.html.

[5] Krishnamoorthi, Raja. “To FDA and FTC Re Thymosin Alpha-1.” Received by The Honorable Dr. Stephen M. Hahn and The Honorable Joseph Simons, Oversight.house, Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy , 28 Oct. 2020, oversight.house.gov/sites/democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/2020-10-28.RK%20to%20FDA%20and%20FTC%20re%20Thymosin%20Alpha-1.pdf.

[6] Pantoja, Eduardo. “Wells Pharmacy Network Is Proud to Host a Webinar with Dr. Crozier on Quad Immune.” Wells Pharmacy Network, 24 July 2020, www.wellsrx.com/webinar-quadimmune/.

[7] Reynolds, Matt. “Compounding Pharmacy's Drug: Accused of Blinding Patients.” CNS, 11 Mar. 2013, www.courthousenews.com/compounding-pharmacys-drug-accused-of-blinding-patients/.

[8] “Side Effects of Zadaxin (Thymalfasin), Warnings, Uses.” RxList, RxList, 3 Mar. 2009, www.rxlist.com/zadaxin-side-effects-drug-center.htm.

[9] Turcovski, Susan M. “Warning Letter FLA-15-07.” Received by Benjamin H. David, President, CEO of Wells Pharmacy Network, Web.archive, 10 Nov. 2014, web.archive.org/web/20170406034011/https://www.fda.gov/ICECI/EnforcementActions/WarningLetters/2014/ucm423242.htm.

[10] Tuthill, Cynthia W, and Robert S King. “Thymosin Alpha 1–A Peptide Immune Modulator with a Broad Range of Clinical Applications.” Journal of Clinical and Experimental Pharmacology, 2013, doi: 10.4172/2161-1459.1000133.

[11] Wells Pharmacy Network. Product Catalog, Wells Pharmacy Network, 2020, irp-cdn.multiscreensite.com/1571d9a1/files/uploaded/Catalog2020-V2.pdf.