Showing posts with label lawsuits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lawsuits. Show all posts

Thursday, April 5, 2018

Nestlé PetCare Purina Company: Lawsuit on Beneful Dry Kibble (2015)

Nestlé Purina PetCare Company Headquarters in St. Louis, Missouri

Controversy: Nestlé Purina PetCare Company (Nestlé Purina) manufactures and distributes food product for cats and dogs. It operates as a subsidiary of Nestlé S.A. , which is a food and beverage company that was founded in 1866 and is headquartered in Vevey Switzerland. The current C.E.O. of the company is Ulf Mark Schneider. It operates in more than 70 companies through Europe, Americas, Asia Oceania and sub-Saharan Africa. Its products ranges from baby food, coffee, frozen food to dog food. 

Advertisement four months after
outbreak of lawsuits.

In year 2015, Nestlé PetCare Purina Company was faced with multiple lawsuits on their dog food product, the Beneful Series Dry Kibble. The dry kibble variations named in the suit include Purina Beneful Healthy Weight, Purina Beneful Original, Purina Beneful Incredibites, and Purina Beneful Healthy Growth For Puppies, Purina Beneful Healthy Smile, Purina Beneful Healthy Fiesta, Purina Beneful Healthy Radiance, and Purina Beneful Playful Life. Within these lawsuits from states including California, Massachusetts, Missouri and more, the common allegations was that Beneful was manufactured with harmful toxins like propylene glycol and mycotoxin that caused illness and/or death. In addition to the lawsuits, more than 3000 pet owners had complained through the safety reports of U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and ConsumerAffairs.com about their dogs getting sick after switching solely to Beneful. The most recent death reported was today, April 5, 2018. The dogs that were sick shared symptoms of kidney failure, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach related internal bleeding, weight loss and liver malfunction. Even though this chemical was listed as a safe substance by the FDA, there are research that have shown positive and negative effects of these chemicals. Because the effect of sickness happened after the pets solely consumed Purina, for 3000 times, as a same pattern of sickness, it is highly likely that Purina does have dangerous substances in their dog food. Moreover, on April 21, 2016, the FDA published a report after finding overdosage of cyanuric acid and melamine in six samples of Beneful Series Dry Kibble. However, the only response from Nestlé Purina PetCare Company was an arrogant short statement, saying "Vets know pets get sick for many reasons and the food they eat is often not the root cause".


Individualism: This ethical framework argues that “business actions should maximize profits or the owners of a business, but do so within the law”. Nestlé Purina was unethical because it violated two rules and regulations while attempting to maximize profits. According to the FDA report, six samples of the Beneful Series Dry Kibble had cyanuric acid and melamine ‘above the allowable level’. According to the president of TruthAboutPetFood.com, these were “the two deadliest adulterants in the history of pet food”. Also, the report also stated that the samples collected “contained ethoxyquin; 
[and it] was not indicated on the product labeling”. This violates another tule because the Food Safety and Modernization Act (FSMA) required that the full ingredient list to be labeled on food packages but Nestlé Purina did not follow this rule.



A dog consuming dry kibble of the Beneful series.
Stakeholders and Utilitarianism: The stakeholders involved in this case include the dogs from more than 3000 households that have suffered from illness after consuming Beneful. Utilitarianism states that the main purpose of a company is to “maximize happiness in the long run”. However, in this case, happiness is clearly taken away because the dogs that were originally healthy went through pain after eating Beneful. Another stakeholder of this case is the pet owners of these dogs. They had their happiness taken away when their pets, which they treasure as part of the family, suffered illness and/or passed away. These pet owners had to give up their happiness emotionally in order to grief for their pets and financially in order to provide the best medical treatment for their pets. The third stakeholder in this case was the community of pet owners who were still feeding their pets Beneful. Their happiness was taken away because they would become concern of their pet’s health when the news broke out. The fourth stakeholder will be Nestlé Purina's employees and shareholders because the sales of the company was affected, and this put the company's asset and liability at risk, which in turn affects the management of the company. In this situation, Nestlé Purina's happiness was violated because of the loss of company stability. 


A picture on their website stating their slogan: "Your Pet, Our Passion".
Kantianism: Kantianism states that people should be honest and not interfere a rationale of another rational being. Kantianism also states that people should treat another rational being as a means to their end. The company claimed on its website that it maintained “a strict code of standards for buying, storing and processing ingredients used in [their] pet foods”. Kantianism advocates for “autonomy of individuals, honesty and freedom” would say this case was ethically impermissible. Nestlé Purina declared that their dry kibble had safe ingredients when in fact it contained substances that caused tragedy on the dogs’ lives. Moreover, Nestlé Purina also exploited their customers by continuing to deny the responsibility of mistakes in products. This helped protect their reputation so that they could continue earning profit from their customers. However, Kantianism would say this is not ethical because, based on the formula of humanity, Nestlé Purina used their customers as means to their ends. 



An example of the Beneful series dry kibble:
Purina Beneful Healthy Weight
Virtue Theory: Justice, prudence, intelligence and honesty are a few of the many virtues that help business people to flourish within the society. In the perspective of Virtue Theory, Nestlé Purina was not ethically permissible. This is because they did not act in according to prudence when they responded with a commercial where employees who made Beneful Series Dry Kibble were feeding it to their dogs, demonstrating confidence in their products. Even though four months later, the Beneful series might have been safe to consume again, this did not directly address the stakeholders' loss. Rather, the company decided to continue to promote their product to gain profit. This caused a feeling of injustice within concerned customers and showed how the company did not act intelligently when a controversy arose. They also were not intelligent in fulfilling the purpose that they company set for themselves. With the slogan of "Your Pet, Our Passion”, Nestlé Purina did not do what it promised the public with its products. In addition, the dry kibble did not fulfill its purposes of nourishing the health of the pets, as stated on the label on the packet. Also, lying to their customers about the ingredients violates the honesty virtue. Therefore, Nestlé Purina failed to be ethical in the perspective of Virtue Theory.
References:

Carey, Gillam. “California dog owner alleges Purina Beneful pet food can kill.” Reuters, 25 Feb. 2015, www.reuters.com/article/usa-purina-lawsuit/california-dog-owner-alleges-purina-beneful-pet-food-can-kill-idUSL1N0VZ1LL20150225. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.

“Company Overview of Nestle Purina PetCare Company.” Bloomberg,www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapId=33452.Accessed 3 Mar. 2018.

“Dog Owners Alarmed at Beneful Lawsuit as Purina Denies Claims.” NBC News. 8 Mar. 2015. www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/dog-owners-alarmed-beneful-lawsuit-purina-denies-claims-n316856. Accessed 3 Mar. 2018.

Laine, Samantha. Purina lawsuit: Does one of its products cause pets to become ill? The Christian Science Monitor, 24 Feb. 2015, www.csmonitor.com/USA/USA-Update/2015/0225/Purina-lawsuit-Does-one-of-its-products-cause-pets-to-become-ill. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.

“Lawsuit Claims Purina’s Beneful is Poisoning, Killing Dogs.” NBC News. 24 Feb. 2015,www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/lawsuit-claims-purinas-beneful-poisoning-killing-dogs-n312176. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.

“Lawsuit Claims Purina Beneful Pet Food Sickens Kills Dogs.” CBS News, 25 Feb. 2015,www.cbsnews.com/news/lawsuit-claims-purina-beneful-pet-food-sickens-kills-dogs. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.

Lupkin, Sydney. “Lawsuit Claims Beneful Dog Food Kills Pets”, ABC News, 24 Feb.2015.

Salazar, Heather. “The Business Ethics Case Manual.” n.d.  Silva, Daniella. “Purina Backs Beneful Dog Food as Lawsuit Expands Allegations.” NBC News, 14 Jun. 2015, www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/purina-backs-beneful-lawsuit-expands-allegations-n375101. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.

Thixton, Susan. “FDA Releases Concerning Information About Beneful.” Truth About Pet Food. http://truthaboutpetfood.com/fda-releases-concerning-information-about-beneful. Accessed 4 Mar. 2018.
'



Friday, November 21, 2014

American Airlines: Bankruptcy (2011-2013)

Controversy
American Airlines logo
In 2011, American Airlines filed for bankruptcy, the same day the new CEO, Tom Horton took control of the company. Over the prior 10 years, American Airlines had lost over $10 billion, putting the company in a precarious financial position. In efforts to reduce costs, Horton proposed a variety of so-called solutions. One of his proposed solutions was to cut over 13,000 jobs, which the bankruptcy court didn’t allow. Instead, Horton cut pay and benefits for pilots, which resulted in many flight delays and cancellations that year. Over the two years Horton spent as CEO of American, he only marginally improved the company’s deficit. Horton decided to leave the company in 2013 and hand the position over to Doug Parker, who is currently the CEO of American Airlines. Upon Horton’s departure, he requested a $20 million severance package, otherwise known as a golden parachute, all while the company was still in bankruptcy. The bankruptcy court ruled against the severance package; however Horton fought against it claiming that he had assisted with the company merging with its biggest competitor, United Airlines and that he still deserved the severance package. In the end, Horton received a $17 million golden parachute as well as 171,000 shares of American Airlines stock, despite the fact that the company was in bankruptcy at the time and the investors should have been the top priority. 

Stakeholders 
Tom Horton, former CEO of American Airlines
American Airlines over the years has been seen in a negative light by its stakeholders, which as a result has damaged the company’s reputation and tarnished the faith of investors. American Airlines has three major groups of stakeholders: its employees, its investors, and its customers. American Airlines’ largest group of stakeholders are likely its investors because they were the ones who primarily financed American Airlines’ operations. By allowing Horton to take a severance package that large, it is essentially robbing the investors of the capital they put forward for American. The other group of stakeholders for American are its customers because they are the ones who purchase American’s tickets and provide the company with revenue that they need to operate. By cutting pay and not maximizing the return to investors, American provides its customers with a subpar flying experience, which as a result provides them with less revenue as they choose to fly other airlines. Finally, another large group of stakeholders are American’s employees because they rely on American for a job. If the company isn’t maximizing profits and is giving their CEO enormous severance packages while cutting employee pay and benefits, they are doing their employees a disservice and potentially costing them their jobs in the future.

Individualism
Individualism is an important aspect of business ethics. Originally coined by Milton Freedman, individualism states that “the only goal of business is to profit, so the only obligation that the business person has is to maximize the profit for the owner or the stockholders”. In respect to this case, American Airlines did not comply with the ethical concept of individualism. Not only did Horton not help American Airlines much in terms of generating profit for the company, but he also counteracted the maximization of profit for the shareholders by claiming a large sum of money for himself. An individualist would most likely recommend that Horton took a smaller severance package and redistributed the money back to the shareholders who have lost so much on their investments in the defunct airline. Like most business decisions, the stakeholders are always affected, and under the principle of individualism, the stakeholders are the ones who should have received compensation for the poor business decisions that American Airlines has made. 
Above: Summary of American Airlines' (AAL) financial statements during Horton's years as the company's CEO.
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism is the belief that decisions made should be made to benefit the greater good. Essentially what this means is that when making decisions it is important to give the most amount of good to the most amount of people. This, in a way builds off of individualism in the sense that the company should be focused on the bigger picture and the people it impacts, rather than itself. Where utilitarianism differs, however, is that it considers more than just the stakeholders. In American Airlines’ situation, the CEO did not make decisions with utilitarianism in mind. It is apparent that the only person that CEO Tom Horton wanted to benefit was himself. Unfortunately, for many businesses, greed is a major issue – an issue that utilitarianism tries to mitigate. By taking a $20 million severance package, it does not reflect the beliefs of utilitarianism whatsoever. Even if American Airlines decided not to compensate its investors, they could have reinvested the money back into the airline and making it better for its customer base, thus benefiting the greater good. When Horton was confronted about receiving such a large severance package while the company was losing money, he defended himself by stating the company was able to cut labor costs by 20%. In other words, the former CEO defended his extravagant severance package by cutting jobs and hours of many employees who earn much less than him. A utilitarian would absolutely agree that Horton has gone against every utilitarian value with his statement. There are a number of things American Airlines could have done to align with utilitarianism, but it’s obvious that greed is a major factor that got in the way.

Kantianism
Doug Parker, CEO of American Airlines following Tom Horton
Kantianism is the study of the ethical beliefs of Immanuel Kant, which fall into four major categories. Act rationally, allow and help people to make rational decisions, respect people and their needs and differences, and to be motivated by good will and seek to do what’s right because it’s right. The second and third points of Kantianism really do not apply to this particular case; however the first and last points relate perfectly. Horton’s decision was completely irrational and filled with greed. A rational person would not cut jobs and hours in order to receive a golden parachute. One could argue that Horton’s decision was rational if he was in desperate need of money; however, Horton received over a million dollars a year in salary and stock units. It is completely irrational for someone who makes roughly $1.25 million per year to request a severance package nearly 40x their base salary, at the expense of others. Leading off of that, the last point of Kantianism is to be motivated by good will and seek to do what’s right because it’s right. It is evident that Horton was motivated by greed rather than good, and had no intention to do right, whether it was good or not. Horton seized an opportunity to be CEO of a failing company, run it into the ground and cash out. 

Virtue Theory
Aristotle believed in four virtues that allowed things to function properly: courage, honesty, temperance and justice. Unfortunately, Tom Horton didn’t see things the same way as Aristotle. The first virtue, courage, essentially means to stand with what is right. As discussed in the paper, we know that Horton stood with what was wrong and was opposed by the majority of people. However, due to his own personal desires, he chose to stand with the wrong decision, despite the obvious objections. This leads us to the temperance virtue which states that people should have self-control and to have reasonable expectations and desires. Most people would agree that a severance package that is 40x larger than a base salary for doing a sub-par job leading a company out of bankruptcy is completely unreasonable, yet, Horton seemed to think otherwise, which leads us to justice. The justice virtue revolves around fairness in decisions and good ideas. Horton’s view on this matter included laying off employees, cutting pay and benefits for pilots, charging unnecessary fees to customers and raising airfare while taking large bonuses and other compensation. The act of greed is anything but just, and it negatively impacted many stakeholders and people who relied on American Airlines to be a successful and profitable company. The final virtue doesn’t apply much to this case considering Horton was honest regarding his decisions; however, due to the greedy nature of his decisions, one could argue Horton had an ulterior motive in the merger between United and American Airlines which is one of the main reasons Horton received his severance package in the first place, which can be portrayed as dishonest. Regardless, Horton’s decisions by definition were not virtuous at all and were a step backwards for the company that current CEO Doug Parker hopes to correct.


Works Cited
American Airlines. Becoming a new American. n.d. 2 October 2014. <http://www.aa.com/newamerican>.
American Airlines CEO Quits. 25 April 2003. 30 September 2014. <http://www.cnn.com/2003/TRAVEL/04/25/american/>.
Carey, Susan. American Airlines Raises New CEO's Pay. 27 January 2014. 2 October 2014. <http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303277704579347270112960830>.
Finger, Richard. Paid To Fail: Bankrupt American Airlines CEO Slated For $20 Million Severance. 29 March 2013. 2 October 2014. <http://www.forbes.com/sites/richardfinger/2013/03/29/paid-to-fail-bankrupt-american-airlines-ceo-slated-for-20-million-severance/>.
Martin, Hugo. American Airlines' former CEO gets $17-million severance package. 11 December 2013. 2 October 2014. <http://www.latimes.com/travel/la-fi-mo-american-airlines-former-chief-gets-17-million-severance-package-20131211-story.html>.
The Associated Press. A timeline of events in American Airlines' history. 12 November 2013. 30 September 2014. <http://finance.yahoo.com/news/timeline-events-american-airlines-history-011902886.html>.

Yahoo! Finance. AAL Income Statement | American Airlines Group Inc. (AAL). n.d. 2 October 2014. <http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=AAL+Income+Statement&annual>.

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

Pfizer: Defense of Bextra & Celebrex (2013)

logo_pfizer.jpg
Pfizer logo
Controversy
Starting in 2006 Pfizer has been under fire from stockholders and consumers over concerns about its painkillers Bextra and Celebrex.  Both drugs are anti-inflammatory drugs most notably prescribed for arthritis relief.  In 2004 the pharmaceutical company Merck pulled their similar drug, Vioxx, from the market due to concerns over increased chances of stroke and heart attack in consumers using Vioxx.  This began to stir up concerns over Pfizer's Bextra and Celebrex due to their similar purpose and chemical make-up.  Bextra would eventually be pulled from the market and, in 2008, Pfizer would spend almost $900 million to settle all lawsuits related to Bextra.  Then in 2009 Pfizer would settle a whistle-blower case against them over Bextra for close to $2 billion.  That same year a shareholder lawsuit would be brought against Pfizer for misrepresenting the dangers of Celebrex and for cherry-picking data from clinical trials to help promote Celebrex.  This lawsuit from 2010 is still going on despite Pfizer's attempts to dismiss the case in March 2013.  This case is the most significant because of the allegations against Pfizer: that Celebrex was wrongly advertised to be easier on the heart and stomach than other arthritis drugs.  Evidence presented for this lawsuit has shown that Pfizer willingly took the data from the first half of their clinical trials to show that Celebrex was better at preventing gastrointestinal injuries.  The entire trial showed that this was not the case and so the marketing of Celebrex was intentionally misleading, both to investors and consumers.  The stakeholders for this case is Pfizer (along with its partner Pharamcia), the investors (involved in the lawsuit(s)), and consumers that were prescribed Celebrex and Bextra in the early 2000s.  Pfizer's intent and actions will be analyzed using four ethical theories: Individualist Theory, Utilitarianism, Kantianism, and Virtue Theory. 

Individualism
Individualist theory states that the primary goal for a business is to generate profit for its employees and investors. However profit must be gained while still respecting laws and human rights. Pfizer chose to make the most profit by advertising a "safer" arthritis drug with Celebrex and Bextra. The first half of their year-long study of Celebrex showed a possible decrease in gastrointestinal injury. Pfizer chose to use this data set to help promote Celebrex to consumers and investors. But the rest of the clinical trial showed that this decrease was no better than other COX-2 inhibitors on the market, yet Pfizer chose to say otherwise. This shows that while Pfizer was using misinformation to promote Celebrex, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) had approved the use of Celebrex and its inclusion in the market. Pfizer intentionally misled the public in the safety of Celebrex and Bextra. This misinformation eventually led to Bextra being pulled from the market but Celebrex is still available today. When held up to Individualist virtues, Pfizer has acted unethically by misleading the people in their right to know. 

Utilitarianism
10mg bottle of Bextra

Utilitarianism states that happiness is the most important aspect of ethics. In other words, if an action brings happiness then it is ethical. At first Pfizer may have wanted to help arthritis sufferers but the dangers of the drug outweigh the benefits. Consumers have an increased risk of stroke, heart attacks, and other heart and stomach complications from taking Celebrex and Bextra. While these two drugs may have benefited people at first, if complications arise then their quality of life drastically changes (if they do not contribute to killing them first). For a Utilitarianist this is unacceptable. The multitude of lawsuits against Pfizer for Bextra -- and their tremendous settlement payouts -- show how unhappy investors and consumers are with Pfizer for how they presented the drug.

Kantianism
100mg and 200mg boxes of Celebrex
Kantianism states that companies should intrinsically want to help consumers and allow them to make informed decisions. It also states that companies should always work within the boundaries and never feel exempt from rules and regulations. Pfizer did not intrinsically want to help consumers; if they did they would have waited for the entirety of their clinical trial before marketing the drugs. Pfizer was not going to allow consumers to make well-informed decisions by withholding the dangers of the drugs and by having an apparently superior anti-inflammatory drug compared to others on the market. Their deception prevented consumers from looking at other similar drugs if those drugs could not promote a decreased risk in abdominal health. Pfizer also was not playing by the rules in their advertising. Other than the cherry-picked data from their trial run, documents show that marketers and advertisers for Pfizer were trying to come up with ways to explain away the rest of the trial run. Investors were being brought in on the credentials of Celebrex despite it being no better than other arthritis drugs. Pfizer fails under these Kantian principles.

Virtue Theory
Ian C. Read, CEO of Pfizer
Virtue Theory has four main virtues: courage, honesty, self-control, and fairness. A company is courageous if it takes chances and stands up for what is right. A company is honest if it is transparent with its business actions. A company shows self-control if they create reasonable expectations and lives up to those expectations. A company is fair if it works hard and follows fair practices. Pfizer certainly took a chance in using unconfirmed data to promote their drugs but in doing so they did not stand up for what is right. Their own actions were shrouded from investors. They were hardly transparent by hiding the fact they were using wrong information in advertising. Pfizer, as a company, had created reasonable expectations that the drugs they sold would be safe but failed to live up to those expectations with the complications that arise from using Bextra and Celebrex. Pfizer was hardly fair in how they promoted the drugs by allowing wrong information to be used. Pfizer has gone against all of these virtues in how they marketed Bextra and Celebrex.

Conclusion
Pfizer has certainly shown how they value ethics in how they promoted Celebrex and Bextra. They failed to follow the four virtues in Virtue Theory, they deceived consumers under Kantianism, they brought unhappiness to consumers and investors under Utilitarianism, and failed to operate within rules and regulations under Individualism. It is interesting to note that Bextra has been removed from the market but Celebrex has not. Pfizer may just be trying to stay competitive by having at least one arthritis drug on the market and are thus aggressively protecting it. This can cause Pfizer to plummet even further down on their ethical principles if they cannot end up settling things and ensuring a better, safer drug.


References
Bratulic, Anna. "Pfizer Loses Bid to Dismiss Shareholder Lawsuit over Celebrex, Bextra Safetyclaims." - FirstWord Pharma. First World Pharma, 29 Mar. 2013. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Mercola. "Pfizer 'Cherry-Picked' Celebrex Data, Memos Say." Mercola.com. N.p., 9 July 2012. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Phillips & Cohen LLP. "Bextra Whistleblower Case Leads to Record-setting Pfizer Settlement." Phillips & Cohen LLP. N.p., 2 Sept. 2009. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Raymond, Nate, and Ransdell Pierson. "Pfizer to Pay $164 Million in Investor Lawsuit over Celebrex." Reuters. Thomson Reuters, 09 Oct. 2012. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Saul, Stephanie. "Pfizer in $894 Million Drug Settlement." The New York Times. The New York Times, 17 Oct. 2008. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Stempel, Jonathan. "Pfizer Fails to End Lawsuit over Bextra, Celebrex Safety." Reuters. Thomson Reuters, 28 Mar. 2013. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.

Thomas, Katie. "In Documents on Pain Drug, Signs of Doubt and Deception." The New York Times. The New York Times, 24 June 2012. Web. 28 Mar. 2014.