Showing posts with label Healthcare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Healthcare. Show all posts

Friday, December 2, 2022

Theranos: Elizabeth Holmes Fraud Downfall (2015- 2022)

Theranos: Elizabeth Holmes Fraud Downfall (2015-2022)


ABSTRACT

Elizabeth Holmes
            There are many health technology companies that have been very successful in the work they do but Theranos is not one of those companies. The young start-up company was on track for big things but soon faced issues on many accounts of fraud and lying. In March of 2004 this was the start of Theranos, Elizabeth Holmes dropped out of Stanford to pursue her dreams of creating this startup company. Her goal of the company was to be able to diagnose diseases and medical conditions from a single drop of blood. After becoming one of the biggest and richest companies it was soon shut down for unethical and fraud reasons to their investors. In this case she completed many unethical actions that she didn’t follow any of the ethical theories. An individualist would say that she did not maximize profit within the law. A utilitarian would also say that she never maximized happiness of others she only maximized her own for a short moment before she was caught. In Kantianism she did not follow the formula for humanity, Holmes did not follow the rational way of life. Personally, I would also agree that she did not follow these ethical theories.

ETHICS CASE CONTROVERSY

            The case of Elizabeth Holmes did not start until 2018 but there were many years that the case was unfolding until the first court appearance. This whole case starts with Holmes dropping out of Stanford at 19 and she went to start her dreams of creating Theranos start-up. She also had a partner named Ramesh Balwani also known as Sunny. He joined her as the president of the start-up at the age of 20. There were many companies that invested in Theranos as you will read in the next paragraph about all the stakeholders that invested until the downfall of Theranos. The case controversy started when Wall Street Journal did an investigation on Holmes and said that she wasn’t doing what she promised and that she was lying about the single drop of blood method that she has promised she was doing. This was the start of when big name companies like Walgreens started to pull out. Many other

Machine that was used to Test the Blood

small companies at the time also decided to pull out because of the claims that were being made against their labs. In 2016 Balwani steps away from Theranos and the company ends up voiding two years of blood test results that no one can see the results of. In June/July of 2016 she was worth $0 and lost her lab deals with Walgreens that were the ones making her the most money, she also got banned from running labs for two years because of the rumors. Many companies started to sue Theranos like Walgreens they wanted their $140 million that they originally invested into the company. Elizabeth decided to settle for the companies that wanted to sue her. March 2018 came the massive charge of fraud against her which involves more than $700 million from the investors. The fraud involved “elaborate, years-long fraud in which they exaggerated or made false statements about the company’s technology, business, and financial performances” (Doubek). When 2018 rolled around Balwani and Holmes were both indicted on criminal fraud charges, and both pleaded not guilty. Holmes then stepped down as the CEO of the company and in September of 2018 it then dissolves and Theranos is no longer a company. In March of 2021 Holmes was pregnant and she delayed her case until August 2021 when the trial begin. In January 2021 she was found guilty of four out of 11 of the charges and was going to face 20 years and a fine of $250,000 for each count of fraud. All of these charges were related to 1 account of defraud on investors and 3 wire fraud counts on investors (O’Brien).

            In July of 2022 there was talks from Elizabeth and she asked for an overturn conviction due to new evidence and lack of evidence in the last trail. Then in August 2022 she was seen pregnant again just as she wanted to start a new trail again. I don’t think that this was a coincidence rather than a plan attempt to keep pushing dates and final decisions back. In October of 2022 she went to the court hearing to ask for a new trail, she did this because a key witness visited her house a month before they raised fairness of the trail. Her former lab director went to her house and spoke with her husband Billy Evans about the case and how she should be granted a new trial because “the government made things worse than they really are” (Allyn) according to Holmes attorney claim Rosendorff. There was claims

Elizabeth Leaving Court with Husband after Verdict

of new evidence and they were granted a limited hearing from the Judge to allow him to explain himself. His claim on the witness stand was that Holmes is a mother of 1 and there may be a second on the way and she can’t be alone from her children that long and that they need a mother. On November 18th Holmes was allowed to be seen in court again they decided that she will be sentences to 135 month in prison or 11.25 years and then followed by 3 supervised years after prison. This was almost 9 years less than the other decision because of what Rosendorff said to the judge. She will now be sentenced to go to prison in April of 2023. But you never know if a pregnancy could affect this or push this back more.

STAKEHOLDERS

            Theranos was dependent on their stakeholders and the relationships with their stakeholders that did not last very long. The stakeholders trusted Elizabeth and the visions that she had to Theranos, but they were greatly misled. In the end of 2013, she got her first sponsorship with Walgreens, and they planned to make Theranos testing nationwide at the time. Theranos had many investors, but they soon began to pull out in the end of 2015. An example is Safeway who invested $350 million in the company to make blood tests available and have labs around the nation. The family of Betsy Devos was an investor in the company and gave their money because they believed in what Elizabeth was saying and they thought that this would be innovative for the health care industry. Lisa Peterson was also a stakeholder in the company, she was the co-founder of Amway, she invested $100 million in 2014. The families were all given fake revenue projections like $990 million in revenue in 2015. The DeVos family was one of the biggest investors and the family invested their money based on the information that Holmes provided to them. A family called the Walton’s, created Walmart, they “invested $150 million into the company” (Keown) also. There are many investors that made this start-up work like Riley Bechtel, chairman of constriction business Bechtel Group, and Cox Enterprises. This was all part of her plan to get lots of stakeholders to invest and be private donors so that she could safely run her company. She also was smart and would surround herself with my political figures that were into helping the pilot program for blood testing technologies.

INDIVIDUALISM

            According to Freidman’s Individualism as a business you want your main goal and maybe your only goal to maximize the profit of your company by following the law (Salazar) for the owner, so in this case Elizabeth Holmes, or the stakeholders which are listed above. It is also phrased as that anyone who works for an organization is responsible for themselves and what they do, they should focus on themselves and help change their behavior to help the company benefit. An Individualist would say Elizabeth Holmes did not profit within the law, and she did quite the opposite. According to an Article Verdict in fraud case of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes offers lessons for investors she supposedly raised $945 million from investors based on her false blood-testing claims. She made sure that Theranos had the money that it needed even though it was true that the company ever even had a prototype that worked. Elizabeth Holmes was only worried about herself and the company that she created. For example, when Theranos started she was one of the richest women in America with $4.5 billion and looking back at it know she probably only cared about the money that she now owned rather than the company. She also was individual because she only looked out for herself when the company started to downfall. They layed off 155 employees in 2017 and she obviously did not care about the workers and doing the right thing because she would just continue to lie and settle when a lawsuit came along. In 2018 she stepped down as CEO when the company lost all profits, and she knew that the company would not come back from this. Once the investors and the profits went, she also knew that it would be best to leave and to try and stay aways from all the laws she broke but it caught up with her in the long run.

UTILITARIANISM

            Utilitarianism is seen as “happiness or pleasure are the only things of intrinsic value” (Salazar) It is seen as happiness of yours and others matters even when some things don’t bring happiness you should still do those things. A utilitarian would view this as an unethical case because of how Holmes went about her company, and she didn’t care for anyone else including the customers/patients, workers, and stakeholders. According to the book utilitarian’s are also concerned about the well-being of the community, Elizabeth Holmes was only concerned about her own happiness with money, and she seemed as if she could care less about the stakeholders. She gave them and the media false hope for what she was creating. When she lied to the stakeholders, she broke a rule of utilitarianism, and this resulted in them withdrawing from the company and also wanting to sue Theranos in the later years.  The stakeholders of this company wanted to maximize happiness with everyone and make sure that Theranos had money to produce the results that they needed. The number of total stakeholders are not given but they were harmed badly and lost trust in medicine. Based on an estimated number Theranos and Elizabeth Holmes sold 1.5 million blood tests from 2013-2016 and 7.8 million tests results for over 175,000 buyers. Holmes hurt many people in this situation and that included “more than 10% of all Theranos test results for 176,000 Arizona consumers were later voided or corrected” (Goodkind). From a utilitarian’s view Elizabeth is not able to see clearly right from wrong and how her decisions effect millions of people. People needed real diagnosis but were left in disbelief and distrust against Elizabeth.   The employees needed to also feel like they were creating happiness but when they have to lie about what they did in the labs it is very unethical. When the company was making false readings, this is a liability to the patients when they need this important information.

KANTIANISM

            Kantianism which was created by Immanuel Kant was not to act irrationally and to consider rationales beings and have dignity and be respected. To respect people and be consistent in your actions that other people would also follow your actions. A Kantianism person would not be on the side of Elizabeth Holmes because mostly some if not all her decisions were made irrationally, and no one should follow her as an example. Under Kantianism the Formula for Humanity states “so act that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always at the same time as an end, never merely as a means” (Plato. Stanford). Holmes in the beginning showed people that she was making a difference in the science world but in reality, she was not making a difference at all. She was very respected in the beginning when people saw that she dropped out of Stanford to pursue her dream and became very rich but according to Kantianism she acted irrationally, and her dignity was gone in the end when she lost it all. Holmes was lying a lot and this false information led to her case being unethical and against mostly all the theory’s. One thing that was present was the motivation that Holmes had to keep Theranos afloat, she was motivated to make Theranos a reality when she first started in 2003 but that motivation became overpowered by the view of money and the fear of failing. When Elizabeth got caught by the stakeholders she lost respect from everyone and the motivation to save Theranos also disappeared.

VIRTUE THEORY

Going back a long time was when Aristotle created the Virtue Theory, virtues “are things that enable for something to function well or be good” (Salazar) The Virtue theory consists of four virtues of character and these are courage, temperance/self-control, honesty, and justice/fairness. To add, there is intellectual virtue and prudence is associated with that, it is liability to make good decisions for your future self. These theories were created for people to differentiate between the good and the bad. When people realized what they were doing was good and their purpose they would then achieve what they needed to, it would result in virtue. The courageous part of this case was the whistleblower in this case Tyler Shultz, he was “not only the Theranos Whistleblower, but he was the first to report troubling

Tyler Shultz Whistleblower

findings at the company to regulators” (npr.org). He was being a bold person in doing this because he knew what she was doing was wrong and that the world needed to know about all the money that they were wasting on Theranos. When thinking about the virtue characters honesty is the first one that comes to mind because that is the thing that Elizabeth was not. She was never honest to her patients, stakeholders, workers, and everyone in the world. Elizabeth said “At a relatively young age, I began to believe that building a business was perhaps the greatest opportunity for making an impact, because it’s a tool for making a change in the world” (Brainyquote.com) When reading this it made people think that she was doing the right thing but she did the opposite and was dishonest. Elizabeth Holmes is not a courageous person because she lied and never could get herself to come clean about her work. If she had courage she would stick up for Theranos and find a way for it to survive. She had no temperance when it came to money that she and her company were gaining her self- restraint was zero in this company. In the self- control side, she should have been able to control everything if it went out of hand but she was not able to. She relates to fairness/ Justice because she may have felt that the original court ruling was not fair so she asked for a retrial. The judges thought otherwise that the case was fair and the information provided was liable. She was brought to justice and punished for her crimes, she will face the 11 ½ years in prison. Lastly, she did not contain the characteristic of prudence, she set her future self-up for failure by her unethical ways described above.

JUSTIFICATIED ETHICS EVALUATION

            After reviewing this case and the new decision that was just made for Elizabeth Holmes, I agree with the judge in the decisions that they made. The opportunity that she wanted for a retrial was unnecessary which I agree with them that nothing would have changed her case because all of her evidence was so public, and she could not have taken back what she did. In this case mostly everything that she did with Theranos was non permissible. She was lying constantly to keep the investors and try to make her dreams come true. Theranos actions were very unethical, and I can’t see how she would have gotten away with this no matter how hard she tried. They stole millions of dollars and poured the money into a failed project that scientifically could have never worked. It is pretty impossible to test for millions of diseases with just one drop of blood, there are not enough molecules in one drop of blood for this to work. She deserves the time that she was sentenced because of her unethical actions and the effect that it had on people in negative ways.

CONCLUSION

            In conclusion, Elizabeth Holmes got what she deserved in her second round of being Infront of the judge after asking for the retrial. Her and Sunny both got in equal trouble for what they did. Elizabeth’s current pregnancy will be in question as she gets closer to her prison date, and we will see if it get pushed away even longer. She continued to play many games with the law throughout her time with Theranos and even throughout her court trials. Elizabeth lived a very unethical life from a young age, and I will not understand how she could live with herself lying everyday about the work that she did. She was supposed to be the future for healthcare technology but instead she lied to just get money and become more famous. In the case her husband Billy Evans and her parents are still very supportive of her and are on her side. This is shocking after all she has done.



           

 

 

 


                                                                        REFERENCES  

Allyn, Bobby. “Theranos Whistleblower Celebrated Elizabeth Holmes Verdict by 'Popping Champagne'.” NPR, NPR, 5 Jan. 2022, https://www.npr.org/2022/01/05/1070474663/theranos-whistleblower-tyler-shultz-elizabeth-holmes-verdict-champagne. 

DesJardins, Joseph. “Chapter 3.” An Introduction to Business Ethics. 

Dumas, Breck. “Key Witness in Elizabeth Holmes Trial Stands by His Testimony.” Fox Business, Fox Business, 17 Oct. 2022, https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/key-witness-elizabeth-holmes-trial-stands-by-testimony. 

Elizabeth Holmes Case Takes on More Drama Ahead of Sentencing. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/17/technology/elizabeth-holmes-case-adam-rosendorff.html. 

“Elizabeth Holmes Quotes.” BrainyQuote, Xplore, https://www.brainyquote.com/authors/elizabeth-holmes-quotes. 

Jdickler. “Verdict in Fraud Case of Theranos Founder Elizabeth Holmes Offers Lessons for Investors.” CNBC, CNBC, 4 Jan. 2022, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/04/verdict-in-fraud-case-of-theranos-founder-elizabeth-holmes-has-lessons-for-investors.html. 

Keown, Alex. “Rep for Wealthy Theranos Stakeholder Describes Holmes' Investor Courting Practice.” BioSpace, BioSpace, 27 Oct. 2021, https://www.biospace.com/article/wealthy-theranos-stakeholder-describes-meeting-with-holmes-ahead-of-100-million-investment/. 

Kerstein, Samuel. “Treating Persons as Means.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University, 13 Apr. 2019, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/persons-means/#:~:text=One%20formulation%2C%20often%20called%20the,1785%3A%20429%2C%20italics%20removed).

O'Brien, Sara Ashley. “The Rise and Fall of Elizabeth Holmes: A Timeline | CNN Business.” CNN, Cable News Network, 17 Nov. 2022, https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/04/tech/elizabeth-holmes-rise-and-fall/index.html. 

Salazar, Heather. Business Ethics PowerPoint Slides

Ushe, Naledi. “Elizabeth Holmes's Trial Left Theranos Patients without Justice.” POPSUGAR Entertainment, 2 Mar. 2022, https://www.popsugar.com/entertainment/what-happened-to-elizabeth-holmes-theranos-patients-48735060.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Monday, November 30, 2020

CityMD: Wrongly Tells Patients They’re Immune From COVID-19 (May 2020)

    CityMD is a healthcare company that runs urgent cares based in New York.  When COVID-19 came to the United States and testing became available, many turned to CityMD for these services.  They also had antibody testing to determine if patients had antibodies to the coronavirus.  However, they ended up mistakenly telling patients that were positive for antibodies that they were now immune to the coronavirus, something that was not proven and might not be true.  After the news broke, CityMD came forward and acknowledged their mistake, and contacted the affected patients.  This analysis will look at this case from the ethical theories of individualism, utilitarianism, Kantianism, and virtue theory.  An individualist, who values maximizing profits within the law, would argue that this was wrong, as a mistake like this could hurt profits, even though nothing illegal was done.  A utilitarian, who values happiness for all, would feel negatively about this case because being lied to and in danger would make people unhappy.  A Kantian, who values treating people with respect, would say that this is wrong because people were lied to.  Lastly, a virtue theorist would say that CityMD acted unethically because they lied, violating the cardinal virtues.  Going forward, CityMD should be more proactive with reviewing what they put out and doing their research.  They should also continue to maintain transparency and take responsibility for their actions.

Company Background

    CityMD is an urgent care company that was co-founded in 2010 in New York, New York by four ER doctors, including Dr. Richard Park, CEO.  The company operates 136 urgent care centers throughout New York, New Jersey, and Washington state. (CityMD)

    CityMD’s aim is to make healthcare inclusive.  Their mission is to serve their communities by “providing quality medical care through convenient access and an exceptional experience, and we consider this mission with every patient that walks through our doors.”  They state that they hire the best board-certified doctors, and provide them with “ongoing medical training and information, along with the most modern technology.”  They are also “built upon the philosophy of serving patients with kindness.” (CityMD)

People wearing masks waiting to be tested
for COVID-19 outside CityMD in
New York City, April 30, 2020

    When the coronavirus came to the United States, with the first case being in Seattle and cases skyrocketing in the New York area, CityMD stepped up and started testing many people.  They now offer three tests for COVID-19: the rapid test, the PCR test, and the blood (antibody) test. (CityMD, 2020) The first two test for whether you currently have the virus, and the third tests if you have antibodies for the virus.  According to the Daily Telegraph, “CityMD administered about 314,000 [COVID-19] tests across New York City, as of June 26. In total, 26 per cent of the tests came back positive.” (Gale) They test at all their locations across New York, New Jersey, and Washington.

Ethics Case Controversy

    When the first COVID-19 case was diagnosed in the US on January 20th, no one expected it to get as big as it did.  But on March 11th, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a pandemic.  Many places countrywide started to quarantine, and New York and New Jersey, being some of the first, started on March 28th. (NBC) On April 2rd, after many people had contracted and recovered from the coronavirus, the FDA approved the first antibody test for COVID-19. (Mandavilli)

COVID-19 antibody test
These tests were very new, and no one quite knew what they could tell us, other than whether or not someone had had COVID-19 at one point.  According to the University of Maryland Medical System, antibody tests are primarily being used to “help determine how widespread coronavirus infection is in certain communities.” (UMMS) They go on to say that “this can be beneficial for creating public policy and better understanding how to keep communities safe.”  Many, though, have taken these antibody tests as a sign of being immune to the coronavirus.  This is what most likely led to CityMD’s mistake.  The World Health Organization says that “most people who are infected with COVID-19 develop an immune response within the first few weeks after infection. Research is still ongoing into how strong that protection is and how long it lasts. WHO is also looking into whether the strength and length of immune response depends on the type of infection a person has: without symptoms (‘asymptomatic’), mild or severe.” (WHO)  While the antibody test shows that you had an immune response from the coronavirus, it doesn’t tell you whether you are protected enough from reinfection.  “In general, reinfection means a person was infected (got sick) once, recovered, and then later became infected again. Based on what we know from similar viruses, some reinfections are expected. We are still learning more about COVID-19.” (CDC) Dr. Maria Van Kerkhove, head of the WHO’s emerging diseases and zoonosis unit, said, “Four months into this pandemic, we’re not able to say an antibody response means someone is immune.” (WHO) Some sources “found that people who recover from even mild cases of COVID-19 produce antibodies that are believed to protect against infection for at least 5 to 7 months, and could last much longer.” (Schimelpfening) However, this is a new virus and the little evidence we have is not enough to prove immunity, “simply because not enough studies have been done yet.” (Schimelpfening) Despite the lack of evidence, on May 11th, the news broke that CityMD had told 15,000 people who had positive antibody test results that they were immune to the coronavirus. (Feuer)  They had made antibody tests available to those who had previously tested positive for COVID-19, those who believed they already had it and have been symptom-free for at least two weeks, and for those who believe they were exposed to the virus. (ABC) There was also no charge from CityMD for these tests, as they waived insurance copays.  This led to many people getting tested and being told that they were now immune, even though there was no solid research to show that this was true.  While CityMD might have been using unproven assumptions about immunity, it could also have been an honest mistake.  According to CityMD, the mistake was “due to an editing error in the patient portal,” and they described the situation by saying that “some CityMD patients have received incorrect information saying a positive result on the COVID-19 antibody test confers immunity...CityMD patients getting the COVID-19 antibody test are given several documents explaining that a positive result does not mean they are immune to COVID-19.” (Feuer) While we don’t have access to the exact documents that patients received, this must have confused many patients.  That being said, this mistake may have been an error from reusing documents from past viruses where immunity was known.  This led many people to believe, for at least a short time, that they were immune, which put them in danger of being careless and exposing themselves to getting reinfected. 
People in New York City during the pandemic
being careless by not wearing masks,
putting themselves and others at risk
“The common perception is that if you test positive for COVID-19 antibodies, you’re “safe” from COVID-19 and are immune. But there are many factors in antibody testing, and not all tests are created equal.” (Tripucka) In fact, Professor Helen Ward says, “This very large study has shown that the proportion of people with detectable antibodies is falling over time...We don’t yet know whether this will leave these people at risk of reinfection with the virus that causes COVID-19.” (Ellis) After CNBC reached out, CityMD did say that they “removed the incorrect language and will contact all patients to ensure they have the correct information,” however, it is uncertain how much damage had already been done by then by a company that many people looked to for safe, accurate information.  As of now, their website currently states, under the description for the antibody test, “This test will detect if you have had prior exposure to or infection with COVID-19 and have built antibodies for the virus. For most viral illnesses, a positive antibody means prior exposure to a virus and possible immunity to future infection. As COVID-19 is a novel (new) infection, it is unclear if a positive antibody offers immunity.” (CityMD, 2020)

Stakeholders

    This particular case has two main stakeholders.  On one side, we have CityMD and its executives, and on the other side, we have the patients of CityMD.  CityMD is responsible for the information they provide to their patients, and their patients should be able to trust CityMD to care for them and provide them with accurate information.  CityMD will be affected depending on how they handle situations of misinformation.  Patients will be affected based on who they trust and how long they believe potential lies.  Since CityMD is popular for its health care, people should be able to trust it, and breaching that trust could have dangerous effects.

Individualism

    One way to view this case is from an individualist perspective.  Milton Friedman’s theory of individualism states that a company has the responsibility to maximize profits for the owners (which are most often stockholders) within the law.  Right or wrong aside, as long as it’s legal and makes a profit, an action is considered permissible according to individualism.  The individualist would not view the CityMD case as permissible.  While nothing they did was against the law, they told patients misleading information, and as a healthcare company, this breach of trust could hurt their business.  When the news came out that they had done this, they acknowledged their mistake, but by then it was after the fact and the damage had already been done.  They surely must have lost customers and business from this situation, which means they aren’t operating individualistically.  They didn’t maximize profits and in this way, their action is deemed impermissible.

Utilitarianism

    Another way to view this case is from a utilitarian perspective.  The goal of utilitarianism is to maximize happiness for all in the long run.  Instead of “good” versus “bad”, things are measured based on what is good, better, or best according to how many people are happy, and how happy they all are.  A utilitarian would most likely take a negative view of CityMD’s case.  The two main stakeholders in this case were CityMD and its patients.  After we found out that CityMD made the mistake that it did, many patients had to find out that they were lied to, and CityMD had to own up to their faults and contact everyone.  Long term, neither party will be very happy.  After finding out they were lied to about their immunity and indeed in danger of reinfection, patients won’t be happy.  And after having to admit they were wrong and take a hit to their public image, CityMD also won’t be very happy.  While it is unclear from the research available whether there was backlash or a spike in COVID-19 cases after this incident, this was still an impermissible action that made many people unhappy.

Kantianism

    Another way to examine this case is with Kantianism, which is the philosophy of Immanuel Kant.  Kantianism’s goal is to treat every person with respect, not using anyone as a mere means, and not lying or manipulating in any way.  It doesn’t regard the ends so much as the means of how one got there.  No matter how “good” the results of an action are, the means to get there must follow Kant’s ethics to be considered permissible.  A Kantian would argue that CityMD’s case was a very bad situation.  First and foremost, 15,000 patients were lied to.  Even if it was an honest mistake, not putting in the effort to research or review what they’re saying is a disrespectful move by the company.  CityMD didn’t take the patients’ health and safety into consideration before releasing the information that said they were immune, and in this way, they violated the formula of humanity, which is the claim that people should not just be a means to an end.  CityMD treated their patients as mere means (by lying to them) to an end (making their company look good and profit).  Kant would be pleased that CityMD later told the truth, respecting their patients by correcting their mistake, but overall, this situation would be considered unethical according to Kant.

Virtue Theory

    The last way we’ll look at this case is with virtue theory.  This ethical perspective is all about one’s character, and whether or not they not only act virtuously but are virtuous.  It judges based on whether one acts with good character traits, specifically the four cardinal virtues.  The four cardinal virtues associated with virtue theory are courage, justice, honesty, and temperance.  In order for an action to be considered ethical, or permissible, one must act with all four of these virtues.  A virtue theorist would overall take a negative view of this case.  We can look at both the action and the aftermath to determine whether CityMD demonstrated these virtues.  CityMD did not act with honesty or temperance when they carelessly released false medical information regarding immunity.  However, CityMD did act with courage and justice when they owned up to their mistake and sought to tell all their patients the truth.  Other good business virtues such as fairness, humility, and good leadership were also shown by the way CityMD reacted to the problem they were faced with.  Since they didn’t show all of the cardinal virtues though, virtue theory would count this situation as unethical.

Justified Ethics Evaluation

    In my opinion, CityMD acted unethically.  They released significant medical information about immunity without making sure it was completely accurate, and for a healthcare company, that could have very dangerous effects, such as many patients getting reinfected with COVID-19 after thinking they were immune.  They did try to fix their mistake, but we don’t know how much damage was already done by then, and the fact that they made this mistake in the first place trumps the fact that they fixed it.  All four of the ethical theories we looked at agree with this view as well.  Lying to people about important health information is not ethical on any level.  This could have been avoided simply by reviewing things and being more proactive with doing research.

Company Action Plan

    CityMD’s problem was that they had led their patients to believe that they were immune to the coronavirus if they had received a positive antibody test.  When this mistake went public, CityMD was quick to admit that it was wrong and that this was because of an error in the patient portal.  They also contacted the affected patients to let them know as well.  CityMD did a very good job in resolving the issue by themselves, but they can still go a step further to improve.  They should be proactive in spreading the truth about COVID-19 and immunity to their patients and communities.  They should also be vigilant about the accuracy of the information they use or provide to patients.

    CityMD’s mission statement is to “make healthcare as inclusive as possible.”  An improvement to this statement would be a mission to “make healthcare inclusive while maximizing accuracy and transparency for patients.”  As of now, their focus is on the people they serve and how they serve them.  However, especially in the medical community, they need to pay just as much attention to the accuracy of the information they provide as to who it’s for.  This new mission strikes the right balance that allows CityMD to best care for their customers.

    There are a few core values that exemplify what CityMD should strive for.  These include customer safety, honesty, accountability, and learning.  They should work first and foremost for the patients and making sure they are safe and well taken care of, then they should be committed to continually learning and being honest about medical facts and about when they make mistakes.

    In order to ensure that this problem doesn’t happen again, CityMD can make sure to review all of the information that comes out of their company.  This may include hiring people to proofread their documents, or researchers to double check the accuracy of what they’re saying.  And if the issue was just a technical error in the patient portal, they can train people on how to use this resource and have IT make sure no mistakes go out.  In regards to their public image, no improvements or marketing schemes need to be made.  They did a great job at correcting their error and are currently back to being a thriving, respected business, opening new locations to this day.  However, this plan of committing to research and transparency will benefit them as a whole because they will become more knowledgeable and trusted, which is sure to increase profits as more people come to CityMD for their medical needs as a place that values inclusion and honesty, which is key for being an ethical business.


Sarah Mollin


References

“Coronavirus News: CityMD Changes Messaging after Telling 15,000 Patients with Antibodies in New York, New Jersey They Have Immunity.” ABC7 New York, WABC-TV, 13 May 2020, abc7ny.com/citymd-coronavirus-antibody-immunity-tests/6176201/.

Feuer, Will. “CityMD Mistakenly Told 15,000 People with Coronavirus Antibodies They're Immune.” CNBC, CNBC, 11 May 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/05/11/citymd-mistakenly-told-15000-people-with-coronavirus-antibodies-theyre-immune.html.

“Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19): Herd Immunity, Lockdowns and COVID-19.” World Health Organization, World Health Organization, 2020, www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/herd-immunity-lockdowns-and-covid-19.

“Coronavirus Immunity.” University of Maryland Medical System, 2020, www.umms.org/coronavirus/what-to-know/diagnosis-symptoms/immunity.

Schimelpfening, Nancy. “How Long Does Immunity Last After COVID-19? What We Know.” Healthline, Healthline Media, 14 Oct. 2020, www.healthline.com/health-news/how-long-does-immunity-last-after-covid-19-what-we-know.

"Immunity in New York as high as 68pc, tests suggest; Antibodies Findings raise hope that affected areas in London could protect themselves from a second wave." Daily Telegraph [London, England], 10 July 2020, p. 11. Gale OneFile: Health and Medicine, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A629046739/HRCA?u=mlin_w_westnew&sid=HRCA&xid=35f0a5aa. Accessed 14 Nov. 2020.

“Reinfection with COVID-19.” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2020, www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/your-health/reinfection.html.

Tripucka, Jennifer. “If You Tested Positive for COVID-19 Antibodies via City MD, You Should Read This.” Hoboken Girl, Hoboken Girl Publishing, 13 May 2020, www.hobokengirl.com/city-md-covid-19-antibody-testing-news/.

Ellis, Ralph. “COVID-19 Antibodies Decline Over Time, Study Shows.” WebMD, WebMD, 2020, www.webmd.com/lung/news/20201028/covid-19-antibodies-decline-over-time-study-says.

“On a Mission to Do More.” CityMD, www.citymd.com/our-story.

“COVID-19 Testing Information.” CityMD, 2020, www.citymd.com/news/covid-19-testing-update.

Mandavilli, Apoorva. “F.D.A. Approves First Coronavirus Antibody Test in U.S.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 2 Apr. 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/health/coronavirus-antibody-test.html.

NBC New York. “CDC Issues 14-Day Travel Advisory for New York, New Jersey, Connecticut.” NBC New York, NBC New York, 28 Mar. 2020, www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/even-with-relief-bill-passed-no-rest-for-ny-as-cuomo-says-peak-of-crisis-still-yet-to-come/2348306/. 

Wednesday, November 25, 2020

Teletracking; COVID-19 Data tracking Contract Debate (2020)

 

Abstract

Teletracking is a data collection and processing company that has been around for nearly thirty years. In the beginning of October, the Trump administration renewed a contract that was signed in March of this year, with Teletracking to track and process COVID-19 data from hospitals across the United States. This case is going to analyze the effects that this contract is having on the general population of the United States, specifically the strain that it has put on health care workers who are faced with COVID-19 cases on a daily basis, and also businesses who rely on this data and information to determine if it is safe to re-open and to what capacity. The four ethical theories that will be used to analyze this case will be Individualism, Utilitarianism, Kantianism, and Virtue Theory ethics. Each Theory disagrees with the actions taken in this case; Individualism disagrees because profit is not being maximized and not for the overall population. Since most of the country is upset with this decision, Utilitarianism will also disagree with this case. This move was made without considering the effect it would have on health officials and was also made very secretly so Kantianism has a major problem with those actions. This case does not show great leadership, or good decision making which is the basis of virtue theory. To correct this action, the government needs to have the center for disease control oversee data collection, since they have a decade old system in place. There should also be rules set in place to give the public access to the detail of government contracts and how they are given out.

Company Logo
Stakeholders

With a contract this important, and with it being directly linked to the pandemic, there are many stakeholders in this controversy. You could say that everyone in America is a stakeholder because everyone wants to use this data to know
the current situation of the pandemic and how worse/better it is getting. The majority stakeholders are state officials, who rely on this information to know how to regulate their respective states during the pandem
ic. Health officials and hospital workers have been delegated to using two very similar systems that is causing huge discrepancies in data and making it challenging to process this data. This effects small business owners as well, as they need this data to know when to re-open and to what capacity they can run. The last majority stakeholder is schools and universities as they are responsible for hundreds to thousands of children and young adults and use this data to formulate either a re-opening plan, or plan to stay remote and teach from home. Overall, every citizen is a stakeholder because we all need this data to understand what direction the pandemic is heading. Without this data, many people will be left in the dark and left to wonder the status of COVID-19.

Case Summary

In the spring of 2020, a pandemic that was rapidly spreading across the globe, finally reached the shores of America. COVID-19 is a highly contagious virus that exudes flu like symptoms and other various symptoms, which has infected over ten million people in the United States and has resulted in over two hundred thousand deaths. While the country tries to get a hold on this virus and stop the spread, one key component of this has been to track the data from hospitals to see where the virus is most prominent and to determine what hospitals are lacking beds, masks, ventilators, hazmat suits, and other essentials to fighting this virus. In the spring, a company called Teletracking, a Pittsburgh based company, was awarded a $10.2 million dollar contract by the Trump administration (Temple-Raston & Mak, 2020). This contract was set to run for six months, with a renewal option after the six months were up. While the trump administration was confident in their choice of data collection, many were puzzled on why the data collection responsibility was not given to the Center for Disease Control, which has had a system in place to track things like this for over a decade. Among those surprised was Angie Franks, the CEO of Central Logic, which provides technology for hospital systems. She said in a statement, “I was surprised to see that TeleTracking was the company that was pulling that data together. There are other companies that pull data together and this is not what I know of what TeleTracking does. So, it was not really surprising to see that it was, maybe not working as effectively as anticipated”


CDC Report on COVID-19
(NPR, 2020). When the contract expired last month, Teletracking was awarded anther identical contract on October second which will expire next spring. This caused an uproar on capitol hill, especially from the democrats, who cited that the contract was only offered to a sole company, rather than be offered in a bidding style process. They also stated that there were several inconsistencies over the six-month period which included the state and federal reporting of hospital beds, being inaccurate by a large margin. Also, the timing in which the data was supposed to be reported was significantly delayed. Regarding the issue of there only being one bidder for the contract, the HHS said back in the spring that the contract was rewarded with a no bid process, but then flipped their answer and said that it was a competitive bid. The same answer is being said today, as the HHS said that there was a total of six companies in the bidding war for the contract. As of today, no other companies have been linked to the bidding process and the federal investigation agencies are currently undergoing an investigation as to determine the legitimacy of the awarded contract. Many top Democrats are willing to take matters into their own hands as Senator Bob Menendez of New Jersey told reports that if the administration did not reverse the move, and put the CDC back in charge, “we will look at withholding funding until the administration changes course” (Stolberg, 2020). A non-disclosure agreement was also built into the contract so that the details of how the contract was given, or how the data is being collected is hidden from the public and even state officials.
COVID-19 Testing facility 

            Even though many are questioning the move, the Center for Disease control director said that he is fine with the change, even though many experts fear that the contract renewal will further sideline the agency. However, hospitals that already have been reporting to state health departments can keep doing this if they get a written release form from the state that says they can keep doing so. There are supporters to the renewed contract and there is the HHS has given their reasons on why they went with the change. Michael Caputo, the spokesperson for the HHS said that the CDC has been seeing a lag of a week or more in data coming from hospitals and that only 85 percent of hospitals have been participating (Stobbe, 2020). The change is meant to speed up the data collecting process and relay the information back to the HHS at a faster pace than the CDC has been going at. A CDC official who decided to remain anonymous, disputed Capito’s figures and said that only 60 percent of hospitals participate but that most data is collected and reported within two days (Stobbe, 2020). The CDC’s National Healthcare Safety Network system was launched 15 years ago and is best known for collecting and publicly reporting data on hospitals infections. It has been a key component in reducing the amount of certain hospital infections. Even though this system has been in place for many years, others have stated that it is outdated and that having to enter the information manually, has been a difficult task for hospitals during this pandemic. Dr. Hanfling, an expert in emergency preparedness and vice president at In-Q-Tel, a strategic investment firm said, “This is not just about HHS vs CDC. It is that we have outdated data collection systems that aren’t automated, are burdensome on health care providers, and don’t give you real-time situational awareness (Stolberg, 2020)”. Many believe that this move was made, to influence the results of the upcoming election. The administration’s decision to take control of the hospital data out of the hands of the CDC and give it to Teletracking, while centralizing the operations in Washington, drew public outcry who feared that data would be used in a political way. Many feared that data would be skewed or even withheld from the public to give a different perspective on how the pandemic is going. Many state officials and data modelers rely on the CDC data to determine when it is safe to re-open certain businesses and at what capacity based on the number of cases in that state. With the control being out of the CDC’s hands, it will be an even more uphill battle when it comes to collecting numbers for the coronavirus. Mr. Arrieta of the department of health and human services addressed the transparency issue by saying that it is considering giving members of congress access to the new database and was “exploring the best way” to make information from it available to the public, including to news organizations and academic researchers.  This new contract has raised eyebrows across Washington and now has the public’s attention. As of right now there is an ongoing investigation on how the contract was awarded and if it was in fact through a bidding system. As of right now, the contract runs through the new year and will be up for a renewal in March.

Individualism


Individualism, first developed by Adam Smith, is an ethical theory that Smith describes as being self-motivating to do the right thing. Smith says that self-interest will motivate people into exchanges, whether it be business or other sorts of exchanges, and a backdrop of morality will allow the invisible hand to work in the real world. Later, Milton Freidman developed his own way of thinking about individualism and how it works in the business world. Friedman’s individualism, says that the only goal of a business is to make profit, and to maximize the owners and stockholders’ profit within the confines of the law. Looking at the controversy surrounding the Teletracking contract, which was renewed this October, an Individualist would say that this is an unethical move and that taking away the Center for Disease Control’s job of data collecting is only going to make things more difficult during this pandemic. Many hospitals and health officials are already reporting discrepancies in certain states between the data they were using from the C.D.C and the data from Teletracking. Health officials are now saying that by allowing this other company access to the data, they have essentially created a duplicate data collection system that makes it very stressful and more complicated than it was before. Dr Grace Lee, a pediatric infectious disease physician and associate chief medical officer at the Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital at Stanford, said that the CDC system has been working well; “I'm very surprised that we are being mandated to report into a parallel system when hospitals have gotten used to reporting into NHSN. It's adding burden at a time when hospitals again are now responding to the surge of COVID-19," she adds, "The timing couldn't be worse, to be honest”

(NPR, 2020). Not only has this move slowed down the process at which data is being collected and looked at, it has left a wave of uncertainty throughout many small business owners across the United States. This will hurt business chances to re-open at the correct time because there is going to be large differences in the data collected by the C.D.C and by Teletracking. Also, having the investigation on how the contract was awarded goes against what Individualist believe in. Even though there has not been any update on whether there was foul play or not, the many speculations and confusion among health officials, leads to believe that eventually there will be evidence of illegal activity while awarding the contract to Teletracking. Having the details of the contract be hidden with a non-disclosure agreement, goes against the norm when awarding government contracts. Although it is not necessarily against the law, many have called for the details to be made public. A better way to ensure long term profit for the future, would be to allow the C.D.C primary control of the data collection, since most, if not all hospitals are already used to it, to ensure that data on COVID-19 is handled in a professional way and distributed to the public, so that they can have a better understanding on the status of the Coronavirus.

Utilitarianism

            Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that was conceived by John Stuart Mill during the mid to late 1800s. The main idea of Utilitarianism is to maximize happiness for the overall population. Utilitarianism states that happiness or pleasure are the only things of intrinsic values. The controversy surrounding the Teletracking fails to maximize happiness for the overall population, and is causing stress and unhappiness among many people, specifically healthcare workers. With Teletracking taking over the data collection process, hospitals were given only a few days’ notice of the change their data tracking ways, causing mass confusion and stress in this transition process. Not only has this been a difficult transition, but discrepancies between the C.D.C’s numbers and Teletrackings’, has caused even more public outcry to switch it back to the original system, and leave the data collection up to the Center for Disease Control. With so many people upset about the change, it is very clear to see that many people are not happy with the change, therefore happiness is not being maximized throughout most of the population. Before the switch, hospitals were said to be being able to handle the data collection, and the C.D.C’s system was one that they were very familiar with and it was easy for them to use. This new system that has been implemented has only caused mass confusion and unhappiness among healthcare workers. There was a general feeling that they had a good grip on COVID-19 data and that this information was going to help slow the spread. With contract renewal for Teletracking, especially during the middle of the pandemic and at the start of “cold and flu” season, things have become very difficult for healthcare workers and people across the country, which is failing to maximize happiness for the overall population. Switching up the data collection systems has so far proved detrimental to the fight against COVID-19 and has forced officials to work more hours and crunch more numbers unnecessarily, which is causing a wave of unhappiness and stress across the country which goes against what Utilitarianism stands for.

Kantianism

            Kantianism is an ethical theory developed by Immanuel Kant during the late 1700s. Kantian ethics can be described as treating others with respect and never treating people as simply a mere means. The Formula of Humanity is a very important component to Kantianism, and the formula of humanity can be best described as treating others as an end, and not simply as a mere means to an end. It puts individuals first, rather than just focus on the overall population. It is trying to have everybody treated with respect and not just as a step towards an ends. The Teletracking controversy has put many people in a very difficult position especially during a pandemic. The sudden change in data collection process has left many health officials with an even steeper uphill battle, than the one they have been battling for the past six months. The change was made because the Trump administration preferred the Teletracking company over the Center for Disease control when it came to collecting and processing COVID-19 data. Back in September, it was reported by CNN that Trump had lost his patience with the C.D.C, and the progress that it was making regarding the pandemic. Even though the C.D.C data system is used by every state and has had their system in place for over fifteen years, the administration decided to go with Teletracking, a long-standing data collection company with no experience in tracking hospital data. The change was viewed by many as a political move to manipulate the numbers in his favor for the upcoming election. This contract renewal was motivated politically and did not take into consideration the effect it would have on the general population. Kantian ethics views this as using health officials as a mere means to strengthen his political campaign. There was no mass polling done among hospitals to see what system they preferred, instead they made the change very suddenly and gave the hospitals very little time and is causing workers to learn this new system on the fly. There was no consideration for many individuals and there was no regard for others rationality on who should oversee data collection. This move seemed very politically motivated and took very little to no consideration about how this would affect the workers. Kant thinkers will have a very serious problem with this because it was not a rational decision. It did not give other individuals the chance to make a rational decision, and the fact that much information is being hidden about how the contract was given, is a sign of dishonesty and deceit among millions of people.

Virtue Ethics

            Virtue theory is an ethical theory based on four virtues. Those four virtues are courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. Businesses should act in this way if they want to be known as an ethically sounds and responsible company. The way the Teletracking contract was given has left many very confused. The non-disclosure agreement between the Human Health Services department and Teletracking has lost the trust the American population had in their government and the on-going investigation is causing more and more people to feel this way. This new contract is supposedly going to help the country get a better hold on the pandemic, but as discrepancies between data keep rising, many are questioning the decision that the White House made. The fact that most, if not all, of the bidding information has yet to be released, is showing the dishonesty of the government, which would, according to virtue theory, make them act in an unethical way. To be an ethical entity, honesty is a major component, and the government is clearly being very secretive in this controversy. The contract renewal has made it very difficult on health workers. Having to switch data systems within the span of two days has made the already difficult pandemic even more so. The government failed to take into consideration the effect this new contract would have on health employees, and decided to go through with the deal, even though many were outspoken. This shows a failure in leadership and has given the impression that those on capital hill have only their personal interests in mind. Being a leader means being able to guide people through the most difficult of situations. People look up to a leader and want to follow them through anything. Much of the American population feels like the government is leaving them to fend for themselves and work out this confusing change on their own. The contract renewal now is seeming like a very poor move by the government. Although it is early in the new deal, it is starting to look like a bad choice, and being able to make the correct choice in hard times is a virtue that ethical companies/entities must have. As more and more speak out about the new deal, it is being discussed if this going to be a detrimental choice by the government.

Justified Ethics Evaluation

            The contract awarded to Teletracking has so far proven to be a very controversial decision. The HHS continues to back its decision, claiming that it will help speed up the process of colleting COVID-19 data but with so many hospital and health workers already speaking out against the move, one must wonder if this was the correct decision. Since it looks like as of now, it was awarded without any other companies having a chance to put their bid in, it seems like this move was politically motivated. The Trump administration has had a rocky relationship with the Center for Disease Control, and since the contract renewal seemingly came overnight, it looks like the administration just wanted the C.D.C out of their way. As politically motivated as this move may or may not have been, it is safe to say that it has worsen the pandemic in the United States. There was a very familiar system already in place that health experts had been familiar with for over a decade. To now must juggle between two different data systems, is only going to slow down the process of getting crucial information out to the public. This was a very unethical move, as it has not necessarily helped anyone a great deal and has only seemed to hinder the efforts of health experts across the nation.

 

 

Solution

For this situation to be resolved and for the government to remain ethical, the first course of action should be to release how the bidding process went. If there was a legit bidding process, and that six other companies were involved and were outbid, then the current situation will not be as volatile. If it is reveled that the contract was offered to the sole bidder of Teletracking, then that is a serious flaw in the U.S government and the case should be investigated and if needed, be brought to court to determine the legitimacy of the contract. This is very important because it is the overall population that is being directly affected by the lack of information being disclosed. This step will shine a light on this very confusing case, but the problem of the actual data collection remains. For health workers and hospitals to be able to process data effectively and efficiently, an option should be given to use either Teletrackings data system, or the Center for Disease Controls data system. There could certainly be hospitals and health centers that work better with Teletrackings system, but the overall census claims that the C.D.C’s system was easier and more effective for them because they were familiar with it. This option would attempt to maximize data collecting efficiency across all hospitals in the U.S, and not force them into using both. The final step in correcting this situation is making the bidding process for something that will affect all Americans, open to the public. Non-disclosure agreements should be barred from being built into contracts such as this one. There should also be a vote taken from various hospitals across the country, to see which company or companies they would prefer, instead of a handful of people making the choice for them. As something as serious as a pandemic, frontline healthcare workers should be able to choose how they process the data. They are the ones who must deal with this virus head on and are put at risk every day from catching COVID-19. To leave the choice up to them would ensure faster data mining, and more accurate statistics for a virus that we know very little about.








Works Cited

·       Temple-Raston, D., & Mak, T. (2020, October 02). HHS Renews $10.2 Million Contract For Controversial COVID-19 Data Tracking Company. Retrieved November 20, 2020, from https://www.npr.org/2020/10/02/919064606/hhs-renews-10-2-million-contract-for-controversial-covid-19-data-tracking-company

·       Stolberg, S. (2020, July 15). 'Sole Source' Contract for Covid-19 Database Draws Scrutiny From Democrats. Retrieved November 20, 2020, from https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/us/politics/coronavirus-database.html

·       Stobbe, M. (2020, July 15). Coronavirus data is funneled away from CDC, sparking worries. Retrieved November 20, 2020, from https://apnews.com/article/57de8f0d25d9066731e6bd8cad0373c4

·       NPR, P. (2020, July 15). White House Strips CDC Of Data Collection Role For COVID-19 Hospitalizations. Retrieved November 20, 2020, from https://www.kpbs.org/news/2020/jul/15/white-house-strips-cdc-of-data-collection-role/

·       Diamond, J., Valencia, N., & Murray, S. (2020, September 25). Trump has lost patience with CDC head after series of mixed messages. Retrieved November 20, 2020, from https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/25/politics/redfield-trump-cdc-morale/index.html