Showing posts with label Toyota. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toyota. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 4, 2017

Takata: Faulty Airbags Cause Largest Recall in History (2013-2017)

Case Controversy


Takata is a Japanese company that has manufactured automotive parts since the 1930s.  More specifically, Takata has specialized in safety equipment for automobiles, including but not limited to: seatbelts, child restraint systems, and airbags.  A controversy regarding Takata’s airbags began in 2013, but it has been ongoing ever since with many new recalls issued and new information on why occupant safety is compromised with Takata airbags.

It seems that Takata’s airbags have several issues leading up to the safety concerns, and they begin with the use of ammonium nitrate, known to chemists as an unstable and quite volatile chemical.  This chemical is used in the airbag inflator, thus it is designed to have a quick working chemical reaction (explosion) in order to inflate the airbag as quickly as possible in the event of a crash.  The second issue stems from the first, but Takata did a terrible job protecting this “volatile” chemical inside the airbag assembly, and water (even high levels of humidity in the air) and high heat do not have a difficult time infiltrating the assembly, which causes a reaction with the unstable ammonium nitrate.  Because of both issues, it is entirely possible for a Takata manufactured airbag to explode in non-crash situations, causing injury and even death to the occupants both due to the actual airbag explosion or an accident related to an unnecessary airbag inflation.  In addition, the airbags have been known to explode more violently than they should, again due to ammonium nitrate, which could cause shrapnel to fly into the occupant’s face.

The ethical issues in this case are startling, especially since Takata manufactures safety equipment, designed to protect occupants, which can actually injure or kill them.  As of the present date, there have been approximately 180 injuries and 11 deaths in the U.S. because of the faulty airbags.  Furthermore, over thirty automakers have recalled vehicles affected by these airbags, including American, Japanese, British, and German manufacturers.  Trustworthiness is the biggest violation in this case, because it seems high ranking officials either knew about the possible negative effects of the chemical, or should have done the necessary research to ensure the chemical was safe for the task, but nothing was done in either case.
A few of the 30+ automakers that issued recalls.
Reported deaths have since increased.

Stakeholders

Some of the major stakeholders in this case are all of the automakers that use and have used Takata airbags.  Though Takata is the company manufacturing the airbags, it is the automakers that have to bear the brunt of the recalls, and it is also those automakers who receive negative connotations due to those recalls.  On another note, it was also the automakers who purchased the Takata airbags, and it seems that their research into the product was questionable.  In addition, essentially everyone who owns a car and drives on public roads is a stakeholder.  The safety of drivers and occupants directly relies on the real-world performance of their airbags.  Also included are other airbag manufacturers, who are currently out of the limelight.  Takata's future actions as a company will have a major impact of the successes of other companies in this field.

Ethical Analysis - Individualism

In the Individualist viewpoint, it is very important maximize profits for the business owners, but to do so within the law.  The maintenance of the business's financial integrity thus relies on high ranking officials to make the correct decisions which result in increasing profits obtained legally.  Based on this definition of individualism, Takata's actions constitute "failed individualism".  A lot of companies simply think greed alone will fulfill individualism, but ethical business under this theory is actually a lot more complicated.  Frankly, it's hard to maximize profits when you know that you are screwing people, since it will almost certainly come back to bite you.  Again, Takata demonstrated very unethical behavior according to individualism.  Firstly, they broke the law by withholding the results of their safety testing from the public.  The law requires that airbags, and their fundamental designs, be tested for safety, since their job is to provide safety anyway.  Secondly, not only did Takata's high ranking officials not maximize profits for the company, they had to pay out billions of dollars.  In January 2017, Takata paid $1 billion to resolve the investigation, $25 million for a criminal penalty, $125 million in victim compensation, and finally $850 million in automaker compensation.

Ethical Analysis - Utilitarianism

Utilitarian ethics hinges on maximizing the happiness of all possible stakeholders of a company and/or case.  In Takata's case, it is certainly unethical under this viewpoint, as the vast majority of the stakeholders likely experience negative amounts of happiness.  The happiness for consumers who drive affected automobiles and consumers who were injured or killed by Takata airbags will be negative as well.  Same goes for the automakers, since their brands will have experienced some negative connotations from the large number of recalls.  The only group of stakeholders that may experience an increase in happiness are other airbag manufacturers who may be able to grow their businesses in the wake of Takata's scandal, but the lack of happiness from all other stakeholders far outweighs this happiness.

Ethical Analysis - Kantianism

Kantianism is an ethical theory that is based in respect for all individuals affected by a situation (or business) in some way, and emphasizes that individuals should be provided the information necessary to make their own decisions.  People should not simply be used in order to make a profit based in self interests, people instead can assist in growing profits if they are provided with a product that they want to purchase after being provided with all of the necessary information about the product.  Takata is unethical under Kantianism since they withheld (and reportedly destroyed) the results of the safety tests on their airbags.  Since they were hiding the information that would have resulted in "nobody" wanting to buy their product (including automakers at the first tier, and consumers buying the automobiles at the second tier).  Automakers and consumers were unable to make an educated decision about the product, and they were not given the respect of their individuality.  Also, this decision by Takata to use these faulty airbags was not made in good will at all, but certainly in self-interest.

Ethical Analysis - Virtue Theory

Virtue theory is pretty simple, and it's based on a number of good virtues that equate to good character in people.  Analyzing if something is ethical under virtue theory, or virtuous, can be done by seeking out any vices, the opposite of virtues, that the people or companies involved may possess.  In the case of Takata, several vices are obviously present, such as greed, dishonesty, and selfishness.  These vices alone are enough to deem Takata unethical under this theory, but I'd go farther to say that the breaching of the virtue "trustworthiness" is the most important wrong in this case, as stated in the case controversy outline.  When people drive, they are potentially putting their lives at risk, so they may trust their vehicles to have well designed safety equipment.  When it comes to safety, people may never trust Takata again.
Takata pleads guilty in the investigation. A woman
who suffered severe injuries is shown.

Justified Ethics Evaluation

As stated earlier, Takata is a Japanese automobile safety equipment manufacturer that has been around for over eighty years.  Their actions in the twentieth century, including the lack of good research and production of faulty airbags, are extremely unethical and morally wrong.  This is a crime of the most serious offense, since negligent research in the safety field results in the injury and death of human beings.  Although it may sometimes seem this way, businesses are not simply objects or entities, businesses are created by and made up of people, and there are people in the Takata company who should be held directly responsible for the deaths of about eleven people.  These people likely aren't "killers", but it's no excuse that they didn't want to spend the money on more research when their "state of the art" airbag innovation turned out not to be so great.  They have lost my trust, and frankly they don't deserve the trust of any consumer or automaker.  If Takata wants to survive as a reputable company, they need to do more than simply pay $1 billion dollars to end the investigation.  That says to me that they know they're wrong, but they don't care enough to fix the issues since they have enough money to cover the reparations. They need to go back to the drawing board and design a new airbag that doesn't have these issues.  The new airbag must then be stringently safety-tested by a third party, and the results need to be published for the general public.  Only then will they be able to gain some trust back from the consumers, and they may be able to once again thrive as a company.



References
America Business Radio Podcasts Asia-Pacific North. "What Caused Takata's Airbag 
     Problems?" Knowledge@Wharton. N.p., 29 Feb. 2016. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
Reifowitz, Ian. "Criminal charges against executives who break the law protect us from 
     greed. What say you, Trump?" Daily Kos. N.p., 22 Jan. 2017. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
Richard Read Reporter. "Takata's Exploding Airbags Finally Explained (No Thanks To 
     Takata)." The Car Connection. N.p., 24 Feb. 2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
Salazar, Heather. Western New England University. Spring Semester 2017 Class Notes.
"Takata Airbag Recall - Everything You Need to Know." Product Reviews and Ratings - 
     Consumer Reports. N.p., 2 Mar. 2017. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
"Takata Corporation." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 04 Apr. 2017. Web. 04 Apr. 2017.

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Toyota: Class Action Lawsuit (2009-2014)


Toyota Corp. logo
Controversy
The case of Toyota's class action lawsuit placing blame takes place starting in 2009, and ending recently in 2014. Toyota is a major motor corporation, Headquartered in Japan, and is currently recognized as the 14th best brand in the world. Toyota's mission statement claims that "Toyota will lead the way to the future of mobility, enriching lives around the world with the safest and most responsible ways of moving people”. Recently, however, as it is probably fresh in the minds of many, Toyota has fallen under scrutiny from both the NHTSA as well as consumers. Faced with a massive 9 million vehicle recall spanning from 2009-11 over faulty accelerator pedals, among other things, the employer of over 300,000, with 20,000 of those working in the United States, Toyota struggled to maintain a positive image with consumers, and some legal tactics in the handling of the class action lawsuit and subsequent settlement raised even more concern with the ethical state of being within the company.

When Toyota was defending themselves from the 200 plus lawsuits that were filed over the many deaths and countless injuries from the faulty equipment, they used a stance that focused not on the defective pieces, but instead the legal team worked to squarely place blame for the accidents on the drivers of the car. This stance was met with heavy opposition, unsurprisingly, because it was proven that the vehicles had defective hardware, and the pain and suffering already felt by those who lost loved ones was worsened with these false accusations. Once the case was settled in 2013, for a sum of over 1.6 billion paid out to those affected, those who received the money assumed that they were done being harassed by the Toyota legal team. In the settlement however, there was a provision for $100 million in "unclaimed funds", that didn't go to any specific party. Toyota intended this $100 million, or 6% of the settlement, to go towards "driver re-education programs". Toyota again stood behind there defense of its not me, its you, and blamed the injured or dead drivers of the vehicles that were equipped with defective equipment. This eventually was caught by mainstream media, exposing what Toyota had done to their loyal customers.



Accelerator trapped by unsecured floor mat in Toyota vehicles
Stakeholders
The stakeholders, or the persons who are key to the business and its actions, are multi-fold. The first and foremost include the customers of Toyota, specifically those who owned or previously owned a vehicle equipped with the faulty equipment. These are the people most affected by the actions of Toyota, and its stance on the settlement they received. Next in line are the executives of Toyota, the ones who are making the decisions in the legal defense as well as the provisions in the settlement. Thirdly are Toyota's stockholders. In the course of the recall, lawsuit, and subsequent settlement, Toyota stock experienced periods of decline, and little stability. The stockholders suffered as a result of Toyota's mismanagement of the vehicles, legal battle, and payout.

Individualism
The theory of individualism means that one is best served to pursue their own interests without making choices for others. In a business sense, this theory means that a business' only goal is to profit for its stockholders, and that is its responsibility. Even with that in mind, Toyota was not acting ethically according to individualism, because they allowed the business to become awash with criticism, ultimately hurting their value. Toyota wanted to maximize profit and maintain an image by asserting they were not to blame for the problem vehicles, but in the end this came back to haunt them, by hurting their image even further.

Utilitarianism
In the utilitarian theory, the goal is to maximize happiness for all people, while keeping in mind that the ends do not justify the means. For a business, this means maintaining success, but not at the expense of another. Toyota did the opposite of that, focusing more on an egoist perspective, maximizing their own happiness above all others. They were far more interested in their own image and profits to worry about what they were doing to their customers and eventually stockholders. Alienating those who had invested in them showed that they were unethical according to utilitarianism, because they were uninterested in how those who are so integral to their business felt about their practices and products.

Kantianism
One of many crashes caused by accelerator in Toyota vehicle

The Kantian perspective means that one should act rationally to fulfill a purpose. In simpler terms, to act ethically according to Kant, one must do what is right because it is right, not for any other reasons. Toyota was clearly unethical according to the Kantian perspective, because their actions were carried out because Toyota believed it would give them the best chance at reviving their tarnished image. If they had done the right thing because it was the right thing to do, it would be safe to assume they would not have been in the predicament they are in. Toyota knew exactly what had happened and what went wrong, and knew they were to blame, but made the choices for the wrong reasons, and therefore were acting unethically according to Kantianism.

Virtue Theory
Virtue theory is a theory that is very simple to understand, and contains four key virtues. According to virtue theory, you must act rationally in order to live a good life, and the four main virtues are courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. When Toyota went about their case and settlement, all of the virtues save for temperance were ignored. They showed no courage in hiding behind their legal team while they blamed victims of their own faulty equipment. The lack of honesty is all too obvious, with false statements made about drivers who lost their lives to defective pieces installed by Toyota. And the fact that this went on without question from any authority shows a lack of justice for those affected by Toyota's actions.


References:
Gustafson, Andrew. 2013. "In Defense of a Utilitarian Business Ethic." Business & Society Review (00453609) 118, no. 3: 325-360. Business Source Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 19, 2014).

Dierksmeier, Claus. 2013. "Kant on Virtue." Journal Of Business Ethics 113, no. 4: 597-609. Business Source Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 19, 2014).

Bright, David, Bradley Winn, and Jason Kanov. "Reconsidering Virtue: Differences of Perspective in Virtue Ethics and the Positive Social Sciences." Journal Of Business Ethics 119, no. 4 (February 8, 2014): 445-460. Business Source Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 19, 2014).

Aęcigil, Semra F., and Nace R. Magner. 2013. "Is Individualism a Predictor of Social Capital in Business Incubators?." Journal Of Management Policy & Practice 14, no. 5: 113-119. Business Source Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 19, 2014).

Madsen, Peter M., and John B. Bingham. "A Stakeholder-Human Capital Perspective on the Link between Social Performance and Executive Compensation." Business Ethics Quarterly 24, no. 1 (January 2014): 1-30. Business Source Premier, EBSCOhost (accessed October 19, 2014).

Better Business Bureau (BBB). (2004). Toyota Accredidation. Washington: BBB.

Brinkerhoff, N. (2014, January 8). All Gov. Retrieved September 2014, 2014, from Where is the Money Going?: http://www.allgov.com/news/where-is-the-money-going/16-billion-dollar-toyota-sudden-acceleration-class-action-settlement-tried-to-blame-drivers-140108?news=852112

Carty, S. S. (2012, January 13). Huffington Post Business. Retrieved September 30, 2014, from Huffington Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/13/toyota-sudden-acceleration_n_1205022.html

Desjardins, J. (2014). An Introduction to Business Ethics. New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

Rasmussen Reports. (2010). 59% Still Hold Favorable View of Toyota. Rasmussen Reports.

Toyota Global. (2014, January). Toyota Mission Statement. Retrieved September 30, 2014, from Toyota: http://www.toyota-global.com/company/vision_philosophy/toyota_global_vision_2020.html

Toyota Motor Corp. (2014, January). Toyota Global. Retrieved September 30, 2014, from Annual Report: http://www.toyota-global.com/investors/ir_library/annual/pdf/2014/

Wolfman, B. (2014, January 6). Corporate Crime Reporter. Retrieved September 30, 2014, from http://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/news/200/red-flags-raised-over-toyota-class-action-settlement/