Showing posts with label Investing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Investing. Show all posts

Friday, December 2, 2022

Venture Capital Firms: Rash Investing in FTX (2022)

 



(Larg investor of FTX)
ABSTRACT

            In the world of crypto currency and venture capitalist firms,’ ethics is not a term you might think of being especially important. Mr. Bankmen CEO of FTX swindled investors and mismanaged billions of customers money and eventually caused the failure of his company.  FTX and venture capitalist both fail when you grade them against the theory of individualism, they may have not broken laws, but they did not maximize profits. When FTX collapsed in on itself it also took with it many peoples life savings with it and with that their dreams and happiness there for FTX and venture capitalist fail to pass the ethical theory of Utilitarianism. Mr. Bankmen and the venture capitalist were motivated to make as much as possible and to them it did not matter so they were not motivated to do right because it is right, so they fail the theory of Kantianism. If businesspeople always used ethics to help them make their decisions events like the failing of FTX could be avoided.

ETHICS CASE CONTROVERSY

It all started when a Bahamas based cryptocurrency exchange company, FTX, was founded in May 2019 by Sam Bankmen. In the world of cryptocurrency Mr. Bankmen was seen as a savant that had complete understanding of the new and uncharted market of cryptocurrency. FTX’s goal was to try to make an easy and safe way for people to buy and hold and sell cryptocurrency. At their peak, they had over a million users. Sam Bankmen marketed his company aggressively through numerous different commercials. They ranged from comparing FTX to every major invention in history to having professional athletes endorse the company.

(FTX ad ran at the super bowl)

The ads put an emphasis on how safe and easy it was to use and now looking back at these statements it is extremely ironic. Mr. Bankmen’s aggressive marketing tactics also crossed over into his strategies when finding investors. His so-called pitch to potential investors was not really a pitch but a take it or leave it offer. Investors that heard Mr. Banksmen’s pitch stated that Mr. Bankmen believed that investors should only support and observe. This is where the FTX’s story becomes strange. Investors, after hearing Mr. Bankmen’s pitch, did not completely avoid this company like the plague but even more surprisingly invested with extremely little research into the company. The large venture capital’s firms that were investing should have the experience and knowledge not to just trust a person’s word but to conduct in depth research. It seems that they were blinded by the opportunity to be an early investor in a new market the New York Times
said, “Investing in FTX gave them a piece of the hottest start-up in an emerging sector that promised to be as big as smartphone apps or the internet itself.” (Griffith, Erin, and David Yaffe-Bellany) New York Times, 11 Nov. 2022). Venture Capital firms completely went away from their due diligence and hard-core review procedures that they got involved in when it came to FTX. They fell in love with this “unique” investment, and it ended up having a detrimental impact on their balance sheets. If investors took the time to investigate FTX’s company’s practices, they all would have turned away from the potential investment. Mr. Bankmen also was the CEO of Alameda Research which is a trading firm that came out November 2, 2022. This trading firm held five billion dollars’ worth of FTT coins, these are FTX’s own coins, and this discovery served as the spark to the powder keg that was FTX. On November sixth the world’s largest crypto currency exchange, Binance, said they were going to liquidate all the holdings of the coin FTT due to their concerns about risk management. This news sent shock waves throughout the crypto currency world causing mass liquidation of the coin. The problem with that is FTX did not actually have the money to give back and found itself in a crisis where they needed to find six billion dollars to give back to customers. During this the price of a FTT coin plummeted eighty percent in just two days. FTX started to look for ways out of the situation they found themselves in, so it had turned to one of its competitors. Binance announced on November eighth that they had made a deal to acquire FTX. They also released that it was still non-binding and did not release the purchase price. After this announcement FTX was going to be bailed out from the predicament that they had gotten themselves into. Only a day later, on November ninth, Binance announced that they would be pulling out of the deal due to their concerns on how the company was run and most importantly how the customer’s finances were being handled,  John J. Ray III a CEO who specializes in bankruptcy had this to say "Never in my career have I seen such a complete failure of corporate controls and such a complete absence of trustworthy financial information as occurred here," Ray said in a filing on Nov. 17(O'Halloran, Suzanne O'Halloran Fox Business, 28 Nov). This action thrust FTX back into its original position but with the add on of people questioning how their money was managed. November tenth the Bahamas securities regulator froze the remaining FTXs assets and California Department of Financial Protection, and Innovation started an investigation. Mr. Bankmen also took to twitter to inform the world that FTX did not have the capital to fulfill all the customers’ requests. He blamed the over leveraging of the company on “poor internal labeling.” (REIFF, NATHAN Investopedia 18 Nov. 2022) He also said that Alameda would slow down their trading. On November eleventh Mr. Bankmen would step down from his position as CEO and John J. Ray III would take his place as well as the company filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. When this was filed one hundred and thirty other companies were engaged in the proceedings. Soon after the filings took place, FTX stated that they were victims of “unauthorized transactions.” Third party business analysis believes that in a hack four hundred and seventy-seven million dollars was stolen. After this was discovered, the Securities Commission of the Bahamas, decided on November 18
th that FTX had to move all crypto assets to the regulator’s wallet to help protect everyone. Currently FTX is involved in civil lawsuits and one class-action lawsuit. The failure of FTX will most certainly leave a permanent stain on the crypto currency market and investors that invested in it without the research to see all the warning signs. Some economists have compared the FTX debacle to the collapse of Enron in October 2021.

(Timeline)

STAKEHOLDERS

(FTX's crypto currency) 
                   All those who engaged in FTX, were left with a bad taste in their mouths and less money in their pockets. The stakeholders that were hurt the most in the fall of FTX was the average person who was trying to invest in their future and ended up losing their hard-earned money, like Terri Smith an architect in Seattle who may have lost everything from this situation. Investors are left with depleted accounts and a limited hope of getting anything back once the bankruptcy proceedings happen. FTX did not only burn regular investors, but they did so to many venture capital firm such as Temasek and Sequoia, which stand to lose large amounts of capital.

INDIVIDUALISM

(Past CEO of FTX)
When you look at the case of FTX and the Venture Capital firms that were involved through the scope of individualism, it is hard to fully explore with the information that is currently available. At the time of this writing there are no criminal charges brought against any FTX employees. This lines up with one of the main points of individualism of attempting to maximize profits while staying within the laws. In this instance, FTX was attempting to create the most profit it could and just ended up failing. As far as we know, no laws were violated therefore FTX played by the rules of individualism and just unfortunately went under. When looking at the venture capitalist firms and how they interact with the ideas of individualism it can be looked at in two separate ways. On one hand an argument can, be made that the firms were trying to stay ahead of technology and become an early investor of a brand-new market and did not know how to research an investment like this. In this way the firm was trying to make the most profit and no laws were broken, therefore they followed the ethics of individualism. On the other hand, it could be said that one of the major jobs of an investment firm is to know every aspect of where their money is invested. They were not looking to make the most profit but were just gambling on the perceived golden boy of the crypto world. As of now, FTX only halfway follows the ideas of individualism by failing to maximize profits and the investment firms that invested without investigating the company that they invested in, did not follow the ideas of individualism due to their oversight not only not maximizing profit but actually minimizing it. The massive investments by the Venture Capital market inadvertently represented to the average investor that this was a “solid” investment based on the regular principles usually adhered to by them.

UTILITARIANISM

Looking at FTX and all its doings, it is quite clear that this business was not run under the ethical guidelines of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is the middle ground between egoism, where you are only looking out for your own happiness and altruism, where you only look out for others happiness. When a company is operated under the guidelines of utilitarianism, the company is not only looking out for themselves but also for everyone involved. FTX showed, with their less than desirable management of themselves and their customers’ investments that they were only looking out for themselves. When Mr. Bankmen did not allow anyone else to help make decisions on his company’s board, he embodied an egoism ethical standpoint and was only looking out for his own interests. The way Mr. Bankmen conducted himself outside of his business also shows that he was only looking out for his own happiness when he used his image as a crypto golden boy to convince investment firms to blindly toss money at his company without proper research. Mr. Bankmen does not fit into utilitarianism clearly and he was known to only be looking out for his own happiness not the happiness of his users or investors. His willingness to lie and swindle people to complete his own agenda of making the most profit for himself proves this. His ethics fit an egotist model due to the fact he was only concerned in what happened to him and not how any of his own actions affected anyone else. Venture capital firms that heavily invested should have been able to see that the CEO of the company they had invested in only cared about his own net worth and happiness and did not care how he increased it.

KANTIANISM

                        Kantianism is an interesting way to approach a business ethical dilemma. Kantianism is based around acting rationally, helping, and allowing people to make their own decisions, respecting people’s decisions and everyone’s individual needs. Finally, to be motivated to do the right thing because it is right. Mr. Bankmen and FTX, under the light of acting rationally did not act in a rational manner, when Mr. Bankmen refused to allow outside help of people that have more experience that could have helped him avoid running his business into bankruptcy. During the operation of FTX people were allowed to make their own decisions if they wanted to invest or if they did not, but Mr. Bankmen did not help them by withholding invaluable information on how FTX was being run and how FTX sister company Alameda held five billion dollars’ worth of FTX own coin. This information would have most certainly changed how investors would have made their decisions, therefore FTX did not allow investors to make their own decisions but coerced them into a decision by withholding essential information about themselves. The only point where a case could be made in FTXs favor, is that they respected people’s decisions and needs. Investing always has an inherent risk involved in it so when a person invests their money in any investment, they also must accept all the risks involved in it as well. In this way, FTX respected everyone’s decisions of taking a risk in this situation. It just did not pan out in a favorable fashion. If you look at the motivations of FTX it is crystal, clear that they were not motivated by the right thing but were motivated to just make the most profit for themselves no matter the amount of people that would be burned by their business plan. They were not motivated to help their investor’s or to improve the new emerging market space, which is crypto, therefore they were not motivated to do the right thing because it is right. Mr. Bankmen did not use Kantianism ethical guidelines to help run his company.

VIRTUE THEORY

                       Some people would describe FTX as generally distrustful and dishonest. Learning and moral leadership are not terms that are used to describe FTX. It is quite the opposite. If you want to look at FTX as a trustworthy company, you must do your proper research on who runs the company and that is Mr. Bankmen. This individual was also the CEO of another investment company. This company also held five billion dollars of the crypto coin FTT. FTT is FTXs own crypto currency made for their exchange in most circumstances this would not be a problem but both companies shared a CEO. This was seen as an extremely shady way to do business and was done to boost the perceived numbers of their own coin. When looking to see if this is an honest company, you must look at how they managed users and how they secured investments for themselves. FTX was well known for partnering with many super star athletes such as Shaquille O'Neal, Trevor Lawrence, David Ortiz, and Tom Brady and even running a Super Bowl ad. The ads that FTX released to the public openly stated how easy and safe their platform is. The ads were not honest to their customers about all the risks involved in investing but made it sound like there was no risk and that anyone could do it with no research on what they were doing. Hearing investors stories that heard Mr. Banksmen’s pitch to invest in his company all share the same few traits. The pitch was often described as not a pitch but a take it or leave it offer to the investment firms and Mr. Bankmen felt strongly against having outside help when making decisions about the company. FTX was extremely dishonest and used the inexperience of the investment firms in the crypto currency market to pull the wool over their eyes and take them for a ride. They had no say in it. Mr. Bankmen was notorious for refusing to allow investors a spot at the table to voice the ideas and concerns. He would not learn from people that had more experience, which could have made the company better, but he remained stuck in his ways and would not accept the help offered. The moral leadership of Mr. Bankmen is not present at any of his companies that he ran. He did not care about anything but how to increase his personal net worth.

JUSTIFICATIED ETHICS EVALUATION

            When you are running an investment firm whether that is in regular stock and securities or forging a path into a new and unclaimed market of crypto currency, the goal should be the same and it is to provide a trustful experience. FTX and Mr. Bankmen failed to provide anything that is even remotely related to the word trust. From the start Mr. Bankmen used extremely aggressive and questionable business tactics. Mr. Bankmen was a predator to all his customers with his promise of a safe exchange platform, but he was unable to provide this. He was unable provide this due to his perceived expertise and not allowing investors to have a say on the decisions with the company and provide insight from there past experiences. The incident that kicked off oversight and poor management was that Mr. Bankmen caused the failure of the company. It was even stated in a tweet that “poor internal labeling” was the cause to all the leveraging and liquidity problems that tore apart the company. If Mr. Bankmen allowed his investors, that have had countless years of experience to help him, I believe that he would have a trustful strong company that is opening a new market and giving everyone the ability to invest with it. If you were to look at it from Mr. Bankmen’s perspective, it might seem a little different. He could have viewed this situation as no one has experience running a company in a crypto currency company and his aggressive business practices could just be him fully believing that he is trying spread the new world changing innovation. In the end Mr. Bankmen and FTX did not follow any ethical guidelines and were only looking out for themselves. It did not matter who they destroyed in the rise to the top. 

CONCLUSION

The way business was conducted for everyone involved in FTX was an unfortunate display of what happens when business is done in complete disregard of any ethical thought. Mr. Bankmen’s desperate crawl to the top not only destroyed his dream of a safe and easy crypto currency exchange but also installed a new distrust for the whole market of crypto currency. It also made venture capitalist firms extremely weary of supporting any of these companies in the future. This will stunt the growth of this new market and limit new innovations in this field. In the end, the way FTX treated their customers and investor’s put a negative view on their whole industry and it all could have been avoided if any ethical thought were used.

 

REFERENCES 

Griffith, Erin, and David Yaffe-Bellany. "Investors Who Put $2 Billion Into FTX Face Scrutiny, Too." The Collapse of FTX, The New York Times, 11 Nov. 2022, www.nytimes.com/2022/11/11/technology/ftx-investors-venture-capital.html.

REIFF, NATHAN. "The Collapse of FTX: What Went Wrong with the Crypto Exchange?" , edited by VIKKI VELASQUEZ, Investopedia, 18 Nov. 2022, www.investopedia.com/what-went-wrong-with-ftx-6828447#:~:text=Cryptocurrency%20exchange%20FTX%20collapsed%20in%20early%20November%202022,portions%20of%20the%20company%20but%20quickly%20backed%.

 

Taranto, Steven, and Isabel Gonzalez. "FTX collapse: Tom Brady, Stephen Curry, Shohei Ohtani among sports figures named in class-action lawsuit." , CBSSPORTS, 16 Nov. 2022, www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/ftx-collapse-tom-brady-stephen-curry-shohei-ohtani-among-sports-figures-named-in-class-action-lawsuit/#:~:text=Those%20three%20are%20part%20of%20a%20group%20of,who%2.

Peterson-Withorn, Chase. "Exclusive: These FTX Investors Stand To Lose The Most From The Crypto Exchange’s Implosion." The fall of FTX, Forbes, 10 Nov. 2022, www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2022/11/10/exclusive-these-investors-stand-to-lose-the-most-from-ftxs-implosion/?sh=1c04ca326700.

ROBERTS, JEFF J. "SBF in criminal jeopardy: How and when he could face justice." , Fortune Crypto, fortune.com/crypto/2022/11/18/sbf-in-criminal-jeopardy-how-and-when-he-could-face-justice/.

 

O'Halloran, Suzanne O'Halloran. "FTX bankruptcy unique, losses hard to determine: Ken Feinberg." , Fox Business, 28 Nov. 2022, www.foxbusiness.com/markets/ftx-bankruptcy-unique-losses-hard-to-determine-ken-feinberg.

 

 

 

Monday, November 30, 2020

ButcherBox Bad Reviews reveal Customer Service Nightmares (2018-Present)




ETHICS CASE CONTROVERSY

ButcherBox is an online subscription-based meat delivery service that offers consumers high quality meats without having to have a local butcher shop. The company was founded in 2015 in Boston, Ma by Mike Salguero and Mike Filbey. Since then, the company has grown to over 160 employees and have generated an estimated revenue of $43.5M per year (Growjo). 
In the early stages of their company through today, the founders have intentionally limited the stakeholders in their company as much as possible. ButcherBox founder and CEO, Mike Salguero, states that, “Even before the success of our Kickstarter campaign, we wanted… farmers, the supply chain, employees, and ButcherBox members to be the only stakeholders to whom we answer. Because of that belief, we haven’t raised money from outside investors” (Salguero 1). As a result, there is the highest level of dependence on their sales revenue from their customers in order to survive. Being a very relatively new company, they are looking to attract customers who have likely never heard of their name who have little prior knowledge of their reputation. A 2017 survey on consumer behavior revealed that, “93% of consumers say that online reviews have an impact on their purchase decisions” (Fullerton, 1). This means that consumers will not want to blindly choose to join their service. Potential consumers then must determine their trust almost entirely on online reviews. For ButcherBox, online reviews can either make or break their company. 
In the early years of operation for ButcherBox, their service was a growing success and the reviews reflected as such. This allowed their operation to expand as well. Over the past year, their reviews have become much more mixed. The nature of these reviews has been very suspicious and may be an indication that their “honest reviews” may not be exactly what they seem. On the popular review site, Influenster, ButcherBox has a seemingly unalarming average star rating of just over 3.5/5 stars. I looked closer into how this average was distributed and reading into the responses of consumers in addition to if these reviews come from people who are recognized by the site to be experts with a high number of reviews. It became clear that the reviews are significantly favoring either one star reviews or five star reviews. This is a common occurrence because it is often the passionate consumers that take the time to leave reviews, their passion leaning to passionately good or passionately bad. The site allows viewers to see the total number of reviews the particular person has left on their site. When looking through good and bad reviews, what is extremely unordinary is the distribution of responses from experienced reviewers (as acknowledged by the site) and those who have ButcherBox as their only review. The site distinguishes reviewers based on their amount of reviews posted throughout their time on the site. This is to give their viewers more trust in particularly experienced reviewers’ judgement. Those who are reviewing for their first time can be seen as the most likely ‘honest reviews’ because it wouldn’t make sense for a company to pay or incentivize for good ratings from reviewers with no experience or credibility. 
Of all 80 of ButcherBox’s one star reviews left on this site, 75 of them are from first time reviewers and only 3 come from “experts”. On the opposite side, of all 162 five star reviews, only 6 were from first time reviewers and 46 come from “experts”. It is alarming that only 3% of the highest reviews (5 star ratings) come from the reviewers who have no likelihood of having any incentives, but yet 94% of the worst reviews (1 star ratings) come from reviewers with no likelihood of having any incentives. This indicates that the common consumers, those who’s reviews have no extra influence to potential customers, make up almost all of ButcherBox’s bad reviews and represent the most honest experience. If all of the reviews were honest, based solely on the consumer experience, and not influenced by the company at all, it would make sense that the people with the most influence have the same response as those with the least influence, but this is not the case. There are over 15 times more “Foodie Experts” who left 5 stars than 1 star (Influenster). 











The high quantity of low reviews from everyday people draws scepticism about full length articles written about the service over the same timeline. Within public sites that contain a large number of reviews by normal customers, again referencing Influenster for example, nearly 25% of the hundreds of reviews gave ButcherBox the lowest possible score. Yet, through the multiple highly regarded full length articles, there is no mention of any issues experienced by such a large quantity of normal customers. These professional reviews only contain the highest recommendations and no complaints. It makes it clear that the professional bloggers would not have identified any problems if there were any because they were being paid to review this way. If this were not the case, professional reviews/articles would be a reflection of the average responses, which were not perfect by any means.
ButcherBox, being a new, relatively unknown company with virtually no capital being generated from outside investment, as stated by the CEO, has to operate off of their sales from subscriptions alone. Those subscriptions are dependent on their reviews on popular sites such as Influenster. One unhappy customer review describes this experience in saying, “I really just thought that the customer service was the worst experience that I have ever had as a consumer”, and another stating simply, “Terrible experience- Lack of customer service and care” (Influenster, 1). Increasing quantities of bad reviews would be enough to severely diminish the company’s income as a result of potential new consumers being deterred by these reviews. ButcherBox then may have needed to balance this out by paying expert reviewers to leave positive ratings for their company as it would help to keep a good enough average star rating and have far more influence than those who have no review experience to encourage new customers to join. The tactic of paying for good reviews has become a very large market for many companies as they are able to do so without getting caught. Like most companies, ButcherBox has not been caught for this despite their online reviews indicating this.





STAKEHOLDERS


The stakeholders involved in this controversy are the users of ButcherBox who are at risk of wasting their money on a service that is unsatisfactory for what they expected to be paying for as a result of reading dishonest reviews prior to their purchase. The owner of the company, Mike Salguero and the company itself have their money and sales revenue at stake and have this as their primary motivation to tamper with reviews in such a way. The potential customers who look at online reviews to help them make their purchasing decisions have stake in this controversy because potential customers are likely researching whether or not it is worth their hard earned money and they are influenced by such reviews. The food bloggers that write articles about the service have their reputations at stake if they describe an inaccurate representation of the experience. The final stakeholders in this controversy would be the butchers who source the meat to this service. These local butchers have their reputation at stake if they are associated with an unsatisfactory service provided by ButcherBox.


INDIVIDUALISM 


The act of paying for positive reviews is unethical in terms of Milton Friedman’s concept of individualism. This ethical theory states, “that responsibility is to conduct the business in accordance with their desires, which generally will be to make as much money as possible while conforming to the basic rules of the society, both those embodied in law and those embodied in ethical custom” (Friedman, 1). By this principle, a decision made by a business to increase profits is ethical and it is the responsibility of the executives to make such decisions, assuming that they abide by the law of the land.
 In the case of ButcherBox, paying for positive reviews would not be considered ethical by Friedman’s views because this action, although a strategy intended to benefit profit, does not obey the law of the land as it goes against federal laws and those embodied in ethical custom. In the case of federal legislation, “Under 15 U.S. Code § 45, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has the power to stop and penalize parties ‘using unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce.’ This makes it a crime to break official rules imposed by the FTC. And the FTC forbids the use of fake testimonials” (Stemler, 1). 
In the case of ‘laws’ from the perspective of ethical customs, the action of paying for good reviews is unethical as it is dishonest and can essentially trick people into spending their money on a service that they otherwise may have decided was not worth the financial cost. The act of paying for reviews could also be argued as unethical from the perspective of improving profit as well because it would not increase long term profit because customers would join because of good reviews, be disappointed with the service, and cancel the order and likely leave another bad review. It would be more profitable long term if ButcherBox used whatever money may have been contributed to these reviews and instead put it towards their customer service. This would then be an improvement in customer experience, improve customer retention, and likely result in good honest reviews.


UTILITARIANISM 


From a utilitarian perspective, ButcherBox executives are acting unethical. Utilitarianism wants business actions aimed at maximizing happiness for in the long run for all conscious human beings affected by that business action (Salazar 19). The act of paying for good reviews does not maximize happiness for any party involved. For the customers who subscribe to the service, they will not be happy with the customer service or overall experience as it would not meet their expectations based on the dishonest reviews that they read. Since the act of paying for reviews is not yet proven in this case because it is very easy to get away with this, even when considering all reviews to be honest, customers are showing that they are being led to believe the quality and service is much higher than when they join. New customers are unhappy and subscriptions are cancelled.
For the ButcherBox executives, it may initially seem as if paying for good reviews would improve happiness for them, but it would not be the ethical utilitarian solution because it would not maximize happiness. The amount of happiness that they gain from the paid review is not going to equal the happiness that they would feel if they knew the reviews were truthful and genuine. They would then know that they are doing a great job and that customers who subscribe based on those reviews will not be let down because they would have an accurate idea of the quality of service. Paying for reviews also puts the company at risk of being caught which would certainly have a negative impact on their sales and subsequent happiness. Whether there is a future scandal exposed from these reviews or not still means that there is a higher expectation going into the experience than what is received. Since the misleading reviews contribute to customer unhappiness, the butcher shops that source the products used by ButcherBox would be unhappy because the quality of their meats may be completely overlooked by the customer and their products would only be associated with a service that created a negative customer experience for them. This would look bad for their reputation as a result, even though their products may be very high quality. 
In addition to the consequences of paid reviews, the consequences of the poor service and care would go against utilitarian views. Customers would be unhappy with the disregard for customer service and would then also be unhappy with the difference between what they read online and what the actual experience was like. For the company, their poor customer service could be considered to make them happy because they likely don’t want to suffer the financial expense of hiring more customer service staff or reimbursing customers to their satisfaction. Despite this, the financial burden of improving service quality would be an investment that maximizes their long term happiness as it would improve business and reviews over time and likely result in a higher number of new customers and profit. 


KANTIANISM 


Although the case of ButcherBox would also not be ethical through the Kantian perspective, Kantianism differs from utilitarianism in terms of decision making. Utilitarianism makes decisions based on consequences while Kantianism bases decisions on goodwill (Salazar 21). This theory focuses on the intention and motivation behind the action rather than the result of the action. 
In the case of ButcherBox the act of paying for reviews would have the intention of being deceitful to the customers/potential customers who read the fake reviews in order to convince them to pay for the service. This would have been a deliberate attempt to profit off of a lie at the expense of the unsuspecting customer. This would be the opposite of actions based on goodwill. This comes across as them trying to cover up their own incompetence rather than actually addressing the issues that may be causing the customers to have such a negative experience with their product. This is an attempt to gain profit short term as the good reviews and articles may help them gain new customers, but these new customers would have higher expectations than what they are going to experience because their expectations were based on dishonest accounts of the company. These new customers would then not return to the service going forward and likely would express their dissatisfaction in the form of an honest bad review. This would ultimately do more harm than good for the company. The correlation to kantianism from this comes from the business’s intention to be dishonest and gain a positive reputation the cheap way rather than providing that level of quality. This would mean that they did so without considering the impact on their customers and the company as a whole that is not going to benefit in the long term. That motivation would deem this unethical from a kantian perspective.


VIRTUE THEORY 

The virtue theory is another way to determine the ethical nature of an event based on the character of the parties involved. Virtue theory evaluates the actions based on how it reflects who they are. ButcherBox has failed to demonstrate the virtues of honesty, justice, and intelligence. Beyond this, their actions reflect the vices of greed and selfishness. 
When looking at the virtue of honesty, ButcherBox goes against this with the deceitful reviews of their service. This action is something that ButcherBox has not faced consequences or backlash for as they have yet to be accused of this. While the reviews draw great suspicion of this, even if it is not the case, ButcherBox is still being dishonest because they are willingly providing customers with service that is not a reflection of how they perceive themselves and are being perceived by bloggers and expert reviewers. The reviews bring in new customers so they get their profit, but they do not care to provide the quality of service that the customer was led to expect. 
This case demonstrates ButcherBox’s failure to satisfy the virtue of justice. The company benefits from reviews that are not a representation of the service that they are willing to provide. This gives the public the perception that they are much more considerate than they have proven themselves to be through the honest reviews of bad service. The virtue of justice would be met had they acknowledged how they are regarded in these reviews and blogs and demonstrated an equal level of service that accurately represents how they are being portrayed. Instead, they are benefiting from the positive articles that when compared to the reality of the reviews from everyday people it is clear that they are undeserving of their praise and the profit it generates. There would be justice for the customer if the service reflected the high praise from the articles or if the articles represented the poor quality of the service. 
The ButcherBox case does not reflect the virtue of intelligence as they are setting themselves up to suffer in the long term. If they were intelligent, the profits generated from the subscriptions would go further into maximizing the quality of customer service. This would create a better overall consumer experience and honest positive reviews would result. These reviews would encourage new members to join where they would be met with that same level of satisfactory service thus creating a cycle of positive customer experiences that encourages the growth of the brand. Instead, they neglect to put the necessary attention towards their customer service which would save money, but severely hurt future income. All of these actions demonstrate the vices of greed and selfishness because they would rather save their earnings than improve their service and the experience of their paying customers who are let down as a result. The customers are left to feel as though they had been lied to as the company just takes their money.


JUSTIFICATION ETHICS EVALUATION 


I don't see ButcherBox to be ethical in the way that they do business. The perspective of utilitarianism, kantianism, and virtues theory demonstrate this conclusion and from three different angles, the services provided by ButcherBox are unethical. Even though the suspicion of illegally paying for dishonest reviews has yet to be identified by a court or the justice system, Their poor service is showing that they are profit motivated at the expense of the customers and a willing lack of maximizing happiness as a result. The kantian perspective sees their incompitent service as a reflection of their intent to screw over the customer because it saves them money and would deem them unethical. The short and long term unhappiness for the customers, company, and suppliers that would come as a consequence of their actions makes the utilitarian view deem them unethical as well. Individualism states that their only obligation is to maximize profit, but yet they only do this in the short term by banking on overly generous reviews whether they prove to be paid for or not. By failing to sufficiently meet such expectations due to their neglect for customer service, they create their own problem of bad reviews and reputation which turns current customers away due to unhappiness, and potential customers away who read the reviews.


COMPANY ACTION PLAN


ButcherBox has the opportunity to take action and refocus their priorities to better ethically operate. They are at risk of digging a further hole for themselves. The action plan to address the issues begins with a prioritization of customer service. This will require them to focus a much larger amount of funds towards this part of their operation. The company, at this point, likely does not feel as though they have the extra funds from sales to put towards customer service in the way that would be necessary to eliminate a vast majority of the bad customer experiences that it creates. The improvement to their customer service will result in an increase in positive reviews coming from regular people who have satisfactory experiences with their communication with the company. It is poor customer service that is most likely to provoke people to leave a bad review because it is oftentimes very frustrating as it makes customers feel as if they are not valued. The positive reviews that will result from this will be a big factor in getting an increasing number of new members that likely all looked for validation in customer reviews prior to their purchase. The new increase in subscriptions means an increase in revenue that can be used to maintain higher funding for this department so there aren't future issues. As a result, putting the extra funds into customer service will be an investment that could allow them to be more ethical. The new funds generated by this action will pay for the higher customer service funding to continue and build upon itself. 
In order to begin this process, ButcherBox will require more capital to put towards this without taking away from another important aspect of the business. To do this, ButcherBox should look to outside investors to provide the capital in return for stake in the company. This is a common factor in almost all entrepreneurial ventures, but is something that CEO, Mike Salguero, has intentionally avoided since the start of the business. This means that those within the company have 100% ownership. I believe that in order to be profitable in the future, the company will need to be able to put far more funds towards customer service than they are able to at this moment. If Salguero is willing to sell a small portion of ownership for a large sum of new capital in order to begin this action plan, the benefits that the company will see to their business as a result will make his now smaller stake in his company worth far more than what 100% would be worth without significant change.
How does this action and result affect the ethics of ButcherBox? The increase in funding towards customer service changes the company’s character. They would be showing that they are willing to spend their income for the purpose of maximizing happiness for consumers. This will maximize profit for the company and in return maximize happiness for the company as well. As the happy customers then translate their experiences into positive reviews, new customers are influenced to join with the expectations set by the good reviews. The new action by the company will allow them to actually meet the expectations set by the reviews which only repeats that process as the new customers share their experiences online. This is how happiness can be maximized for future customers as well. 
This action can be beneficial for all stakeholders as the company will do this with the motivation to increase future profit rather than save current funds. This action will be within the confines of federal and common ethical law which would satisfy the ethical view of Friedman’s theory on individualism. The plan will have a consequence of an increase in happiness for all stakeholders which would satisfy a utilitarian perspective. That will be done with the motivation of bettering the success of the company and increasing the quality of customer experience and consideration. This would be a demonstration of how they would be acting on goodwill and improved character, thus satisfying the ethical views of kantianism. Finally, it will satisfy the virtues that they currently lack, as it will be an honest and intelligent action that demonstrates justice for themselves, their customers, and their suppliers. Their reviews and service will be an accurate representation of one another and will both set and satisfy consumer expectations. This will also shift their focus towards a better experience for those who decide to subscribe to their service. As a result, ButcherBox can eliminate the vices of greed and selfishness within their operation as they will begin to value their customers above their own success and in turn both can create maximum happiness for all.

REFERENCES 


Crawford, Elizabeth. “5 Tips for a Successful Kickstarter Campaign from Grass Fed Meat 
Delivery Startup Butcher Box.” Foodnavigator.com, William Reed Business Media Ltd., 1 Oct. 2015, www.foodnavigator.com/Article/2015/10/01/5-tips-for-a-successful-Kickstarter-campaign-from-Butcher-Box.  

Friedman, Milton. “A Friedman Doctrine‐- The Social Responsibility Of Business Is to Increase 
Its Profits.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 13 Sept. 1970, www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctrine-the-social-responsibility-of-business-is-to.html. 

Fullerton, Laurie. “Online Reviews Impact Purchasing Decisions for over 93% of Consumers, 
Report Suggests.” The Drum, The Drum, 27 Mar. 2017, www.thedrum.com/news/2017/03/27/online-reviews-impact-purchasing-decisions-over-93-consumers-report-suggests. 

Growjo. ButcherBox Competitors, Revenue and Alternatives, 
https://growjo.com/company/ButcherBox.   

Salazar, Heather. The Business Ethics Case Manual. N.d.

Salguero, Mike. “Mike Salguero, Author at ButcherBox.” ButcherBox, 24 Jan. 2018, 
www.butcherbox.com/author/mikes/. 

Stemler, Sam. “Are Paid or Fake Testimonials Illegal?” Boast, 18 Feb. 2020, 
https://boast.io/paid-fake-testimonials-illegal/. 

Twitter, Twitter, https://twitter.com/butcherbox. 

Vavala, Lauren. “July 2019 ButcherBox Review.” Delicious Little Bites, 8 July 2019, 
https://deliciouslittlebites.com/july-2019-butcher-box/.