Showing posts with label DoorDash. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DoorDash. Show all posts

Saturday, December 11, 2021

DoorDash’s Pricey Fees For Restaurants During Pandemic (2020-2021)

DoorDash’s Pricey Fees For Restaurants During Pandemic (2020-2021)


CASE CONTROVERSY

    DoorDash is a billion-dollar powerhouse company for being one of the top competing third-party intermediaries in the U.S. Their private service is all done online and on their app for cellphone users. This service being independent contractors, non-employees, also known as civilians, delivering orders from local restaurants to people who ordered through the DoorDash database. DoorDash’s bottom line is delivering foods from restaurants that maybe don’t have delivery as an option, to the people who ordered through them. This can only be done by a restaurant partnering with DoorDash in a co-opt business venture allowing their food order systems to be connected, so it's no surprise that they’re currently in over 4000 cities and during the pandemic their orders went up over 200%. This service can be accessed by anyone who has smartphone and it can be used to order food from partnered food spots or be a way of part-time income as DoorDash depends on civilians to fill those roles with one of their virtues of just getting a little extra money on the side as their hours are entirely up to the Dasher or driver whenever they please. The process seems easy, DoorDash enters into partnerships with restaurants and DoorDash gets a commission on all the sales they generate for that local restaurant. Then customers order on the DoorDash app, and receive their meal from their favorite food joint and all the while, they don't even have to leave the house. Like all things that are too good to be true, this company’s actual bottom line is offering businesses a lifeline, a partnership that would only hopefully produce more profit from delivery orders but in actuality, DoorDash’s commission is costing the business at a rate that is concerning.  Ultimately the real one on top is DoorDash because the restaurants are operating under the safety net that their partnership will automatically improve their sales but this isn’t always the case.

Food delivery service from DoorDash 

    The numbers are, 37% of restaurant operators say that third-party apps/websites hurt their on-premise dinner sales, 27% said third-party apps/websites were denting their on-premise lunch sales, 79% of the operators who use these apps/websites said there is profit to be made but the vast majority said the services were only ‘slightly profitable’, and 21% said that they were ‘not at all profitable.’ DoorDash and other delivery services give restaurants another means of income but at a hefty cost. DoorDash takes a cut from the restaurant’s profit, which hurts their bottom line. On top of that, some restaurants can’t keep up with the orders or afford the profit cut. DoorDash can take as much as 15% to 20% per order from partnered restaurants. For instance, Boom Wanvisa, managing director of Farmhouse Kitchen and Daughter Thai Kitchen in the San Francisco Bay Area and Portland, said that when a customer ordered the food through DoorDash delivery service, her restaurant had to pay 20% in commission; if the customers chose to pick the order up by themselves, the charging fee was 12%. Another example is the Adda Indian Canteen of Roni Mazumdar, who had to fork over 24% of the sale to DoorDash (Bloomberg).

The Pricey Fees of DoorDash per order

     It may benefit the restaurant more to order directly from them when possible. Ordering for pickup ensures all the profits go directly to the restaurant and its team. There are cases too of restaurants using DoorDash and other delivery apps running into a wide array of problems, one being some restaurants have received orders when they aren’t using the service. Other issues include specific experiences that illustrate employees or delivery drivers having to waste their own time sometimes with canceled orders and getting slighted on tips since there is no check. DoorDash isn’t blind to the fact that they were experiencing a profit explosion during the pandemic when restaurant dining, churches, and workplaces were shut down. They knowingly enter these partnerships with the bottom line being that their investment will benefit their company and ultimately choke out the restaurants.

    The rise of complaints from restaurateurs eventually attracted the attention of the state and local governments. They noticed the business growth and power expansion of DoorDash and other delivery companies, who gradually became the key part of society, along with the pricey fees set up for restaurant owners and customers, had negatively impacted the market. Hence, many city governments such as San Francisco and New York enacted the commission caps that DoorDash could charge the restaurant as the highest as 15% and 23%, respectively (WSJ). Consequently, DoorDash had to face 32 commission caps from several city governments in August 2020, and at the end of the year, the number of caps increased to 73. They also conducted many investigations about DoorDash's business activities. In September 2020, three members of Congress asked the Federal Trade Commission for an investigation due to the concern about DoorDash business (NBC News). The Chicago investigation revealed that many restaurant owners reported finding their restaurant's menu and advertisement on the DoorDash app without their consent. Although DoorDash had removed it from their platform after the calling, the owners said that this experience still upset them since this incident could harm their reputation to customers. On August 27, 2021, Chicago sued DoorDash for deceiving customers and unfair practices toward restaurants (CNBC).

Timeline of the case 

STAKEHOLDERS

    In this case, the stakeholders include DoorDash company, the restaurateurs that allied with its app, the customers who used its service, and the regulators. The pandemic was perfect timing for DoorDash to grow its business and earn more profits. It was proven by the company's $32 million in profit in the first quarter of 2020. However, due to the competition with other two major delivery companies, UberEats, and Grubhub, in the food delivery market through marketing, DoorDash was still in debt. Therefore, instead of maintaining a good relationship with the restaurants and customers, DoorDash decided to exploit them by charging high fees (10% to 30%) and adding an additional fee. This led to the enactment of the caps from city governments later, which reduced the company's order volume and ended up with the loss of $355 million in the third and fourth quarters of 2020. Moreover, DoorDash also had to face a lawsuit from the city government, which accused it of deceiving customers and unfair practices toward restaurants. The restaurant side, such as Boom Wanvisa and Roni Mazumdar, who was supposed to be supported by Doordash to survive and thrive through this period like what it said in the mission statement, struggled to cover the pricey fees from DoorDash. Although DoorDash helped them maintain their restaurant business when the Stay-at-Home order was enacted throughout the country, they barely survived with these high commissions and expensive service fees and generated almost no financial profit. They fell into a disadvantage when the choice was limited to either depending on delivery service from the third party or closing the business. It was tough to find independent drivers willing to work with the local restaurants since most of them had already joined delivery platforms like DoorDash. Also, the restaurateurs were not able to deliver all the orders in the wide range. Furthermore, DoorDash also used unfair business practices by advertising and selling their menu without their consent or arbitrarily adding their restaurant into the DashPass service to charge a higher rate. Consequently, the pricey fees that DoorDash applied to the restaurants forced them to raise their menu price, which led to the effect on the customer side, another stakeholder. The customers now had to pay a higher price for the same order they had before the outbreak of pandemics, such as the $14 avocado toast now increased to $19.40 in the Grand Lake Kitchen example. The price per order that the customer needed to pay kept rising after the regulators enacted the commission and service fees caps in many cities that restricted the cost DoorDash could charge the restaurant. DoorDash charged the customers an additional Regulatory Response Fee per order to make up for these losses from the caps. The regulators from several city governments such as Denver, New York, and Chicago, decided to get involved after noticing the unacceptable commissions and service fees rate that DoorDash set up. They restrict it by establishing the fees caps and doing many investigating about DoorDash. However, after passing the caps, some city governments also got sued by the company.

DoorDash's Pricey Fees during the Pandemic

INDIVIDUALISM

    Individualism's view of this situation overall would say that it is unethical and impermissible, which is hurting the company. The theory behind individualism is to maximize profits for the stockholders within the law. DoorDash was doing all these unethical doings against the law because they wanted to maximize the profits for their stockholders. But at the same time, tarnishing their reputation with their customers and drivers. Which is bad for business and will reflect on mass profits. There will be a harder time finding drivers since now drivers want to go join the competition and get a better pay. They’re going to be losing customers as customers will see them as cheaters and liars. No one wants to pay extra for things that are cheap. They’re going to be paying lawsuits, which is going to bring money out of their pockets. When you have millions of people who are investing in your company. At the end of the day, you want to win for them. DoorDash went exactly against that when they decided to do these unethical doings.

    The DoorDash lawsuit was classified as a class-action lawsuit, which permits one or more plaintiffs to file and prosecute a lawsuit on behalf of a larger group which in this case was the drivers. DoorDash agreed to a 100-million-dollar settlement for Massachusetts and California drivers. Door dash shares recently soared as the company bought a brand-new food delivery startup, Wolt Enterprises, for 8 billion. So even with all the controversies, they remain the top dog in the food delivery system.


UTILITARIANISM

    A utilitarian view of this situation overall would say it is unethical and impermissible. The theory behind Utilitarianism is to Maximize happiness for yourself and others in both the long term and short term. Happiness is defined as pleasure and is the only thing of intrinsic value. The reason that this situation would be viewed as impermissible is because it does not benefit the majority of the people. In fact, the majority of people in this situation are upset, which would be the opposite of the goals of utilitarianism. That’s because when DoorDash steals tip money, it only benefits the company. The majority of people (customers and drivers) will be unhappy. The only way this controversy could be seen as permissible is if it was being viewed strictly from the point of view of the company. That’s because everyone within the company will be happy that revenue is increasing. Therefore, a utilitarian would see that the majority is happy and say it is a permissible action. When the controversy is viewed from a larger overall perspective, it is clear that the majority of people are not happy and it’s impermissible. The drivers are unhappy throughout the entire controversy because they’re losing out on money that they believe they deserve. The customers are unhappy with the controversy as well because their money is not being given to the people it was intended for. The handling of the controversy by CEO Tony Xu would also be viewed as unethical. Tony Xu claimed he had a new payment model that would be implemented yet many drivers say the model was unchanged and the complaints never stopped. Therefore Xu’s actions lead to the majority of people in the situation being unhappy and would be viewed as impermissible by a utilitarian.


KANTIANISM

    Kantianism has four basic principles. The first principle is to act rationally, which means acting consistently and not considering yourself exempt from the rule. Secondly, allow and help people to make rational decisions. The next principle is respecting all autonomous beings, and the last one is motivated by good will, which is the only thing that is truly under our control (Salazar, 5). To determine if the action is permissible or impermissible, Kantian uses the formulas of the Categorical Imperative. "An imperative is a command or duty; categorical means that it is without exception" (DesJardins, 38). When we analyze the DoorDash case under Kantianism's view, we see that the actions of Doordash are strongly impermissible.

    First, let's analyze it under the Formula of Universal Law. The Formula of Universal Law focuses on Kantianism's first principle that does not consider yourself exempt from the rule. "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law" (Salazar, 7). Under the Formula of Universal Law, we first need to create a Maxim-for-Action statement, which tells people what you are going to do to achieve what purpose, and then universalize this statement to see if it can answer the question "Is it possible for everyone to do it?". If the answer is yes, then it means the action is consistent and permissible. In this case, DoorDash said it charged a higher rate of commissions and service fees to cover the expensive operating cost and maintain its business during the pandemic. If we use this as a Maxim-for-Action statement and universalize it to "Everyone charged a higher rate of commissions and service fees to cover the expensive operating cost and maintain their business during the pandemic," I believe that this is an impossible thing to do universally. Let's say if every business starts to increase the fees they charge the others, the customers and partners will gradually not be able to buy the product from the market or pay the fees from the contract since they will run out of money. Without the cash inflow to the company, the owners do not have enough money to maintain the business. When there are no business activities, there is no operating cost to cover. Therefore, this maxim statement is contradictory and inconsistent, which also means impermissible.

    Secondly, if the actions of DoorDash are analyzed under the Formula of Humanity, I believe the result is still the same as the Formula of Universal Law, which is impermissible. This formula focuses on the third principle, which is respecting all autonomous beings. "Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means" (Salazar, 9). According to this formula, humanity is the rational power of each individual and the only thing that is valuable in itself because rationality allows people to make decisions for themselves, to evaluate what is right and wrong, and determine their own person (Salazar, 9). Rationality cannot be possessed by others; therefore, we must respect others' rationality and treat them as an end, never as a mere means, including yourself. However, DoorDash took away the rational power of its customers and the restaurant partners in the case. It took advantage of the pandemic when people had to rely on its delivery service to exploit people. DoorDash knew that restaurants and customers had limited choices during the pandemic, so it set a high rate of commissions and service fees to make more profit for its company. This means DoorDash used other people as a means to achieve its own purpose, rather than an end, which is valuable in-itself. Another action of DoorDash showed that the company did not respect the rationality of others that it advertised and sold the food on the menu of some restaurants without the owners' consent. The company also arbitrarily added restaurants to the premium service DashPass, which would charge a higher rate of commissions and service fees than the regular membership. DoorDash never sent any message or letter about this to the restaurant owners, and they always had to figure it out by themselves. The company even deceived customers by placing a misleading name on a new fee after regulators enacted the caps. DoorDash did not respect people's ability to make rational decisions about things and also did not allow them to do it. Therefore, those actions could not be considered permissible and ethical actions.


VIRTUE THEORY

    Virtue theory’s bottom line is to achieve fulfillment or completeness and to become all that you can as a human being reaching full potential. People must incorporate strong values and virtues that can define them in their mannerisms and characteristics of life choices. Determining what are things purposes, exercising rationality in order to perform well whether it’s by yourself or with others. The more able one is to flourish with society the easier it is to feel complete and achieve fulfillment. Business goals are flattened if character traits and virtues are not up to the trends and likings of society. The monopolistic capital culture in today's world has made ethical thinking a brush over concept in the business world because their end goal is always consistent in making money. DoorDash isn’t just in the hot seat for falsely entering business partnerships under the preconceived notion of automatic benefit, but also their failure to exercise temperance, courage, honesty, and justice. Without fulfilling these requirements, DoorDash is labeled as a cash grab company only in pursuit of their own goals and by any means. They are cowards in their deception to hardworking and struggling restaurants who are desperate for more traffic that their new partnership will help the place get out of debt and into better days, but we know that isn’t the case. In the honesty department, they have none, DoorDash is supposed to be a partner but is actually costing its partners money that they don’t have. This trend is continuous and they fail to improve margins for restaurants or even improve pay for drivers, they continue to practice their methods which evaporates their temperance hope. Justice wise and making sure everything is morally right they failed to acknowledge drivers as independent contractors and were forced to give out over 3.5 million dollars. Basic legislation is completely undermined because they’re motivated by money. DoorDash is completely unethical in their operations with other restaurants, they take more than they give but disguise their agreement as a way to drive more traffic to their app and less to the businesses who actually make the food.

    Virtue theory isn’t just based around getting a good or likable outcome, but acting in such a way that is morally good and the way a person should be. Doordash should be paying drivers a much higher rate due to the personal labor involved and having a history of network crashing, drivers not being paid, and other violations of hiring. The bosses should be conversing about the possible ways they can still operate doing financially profitable things but they must be permissible in that they are inherently good and they should be good because their duty is to provide quality service while performing the duties of being a good employer as well. Bosses should want to lead by example because they are leaders by the structural design of position hierarchy and in turn should hold the highest of responsibilities and furthermore an elitely positive perspective for their employees to admire and mirror, which results in better productivity. Doordash’s deliberate negligence to provide a more established work contract with its drivers, as well as their failure to inform their partner restaurants without deviation, the specific benefits each company gains during the deal and if beneficial at all. Restaurants deserve to be told that the venture they think will help drive more traffic to their store and boost their revenue but in the end of it all this agreement will actually end up costing them money putting these restaurants in a loss. The ethical thinking to this company and their current business arrangements is solely on gaining the most by any means possible with no regard for external consequences.


ACTION PLAN

    For the step by step plan, first and foremost, Doordash needs to clearly state business deals between partner restaurants, which means fees, upfront costs, and other expenses that may arise from the partnership, what will the restaurants get out of being partners with them. Their service is built on voluntary private employees delivering food and that’s a fulfilled order. They should have a system so that delivery drivers should be given the chance to see exactly how much they are going to make from a delivery. Another area of improvement that would seem effective thing they can do DoorDash can reduce the marketing costs, they can be more profitable if they go back on the advertising and promotional aspects so that they can then have more fair deals with other businesses but still turnout a profit, DoorDash is a very renowned company mostly because it’s in a private delivery service market that isn’t very saturated.

    DoorDash said in its mission statement: "At DoorDash, we’re working to empower local communities and in turn, creating new ways for people to earn, work, and thrive." For a company to work more efficiently and effectively, a clear and meaningful mission statement is important. It is not only guiding the employees to do work and understand the goal of their jobs but also showing the customers and partners the promise and value that DoorDash can bring to them in the long term. The current mission statement of DoorDash is not a bad statement; however, this is not clear and good enough. Therefore, we suggest DoorDash's new mission statement, which is built based on its original one: “To empower local restaurants to be able to reach and serve customers regardless of their demographics and commitment in terms of respect, fairness, and honesty for everyone.” We believe this new statement still sticks with the original values and goals of the company but also provides the company with a clearer path for DoorDash to achieve its mission ethically. This mission statement differs from the original statement, which includes that all customers should be served regardless of their demographics. This shows the guarantee that the availability of good food can reach all the communities that it’s a part of and not only select areas. Besides that, DoorDash also ensures that they will do this mission based on respect, fairness, and honesty, which can benefit everyone and prevent wrongdoing from happening again in the future.

    Core values:
  • Trustworthy - To build a strong and long-lasting relationship, DoorDash needs to gain the trust of its partners and customers. In the business world, positive relationships with partners and customers are one of the important things that can help one business to be able to grow and prosper in the long run. Therefore, the company has to guarantee its trustworthy value to others which can keep people stay with them.
  • Respect - A good and ethical business is one that respects the decisions of others. When the restaurateurs have respect from DoorDash, they will have the feeling that they are a part of the great business and want to cooperate and stick with it more, which can bring benefits to both sides. Also, by respecting people, DoorDash shows that it treasures customer value, which helps it gain more new customers and build loyalty in old ones.
  • Fairness - In order for the company to flourish and be sustainable in the long run, DoorDash needs to ensure fairness in its business practices toward people, including its partners and customers. The company's action has to align with this value since it can encourage and enhance respect and trust between DoorDash and others.

    After establishing a new mission statement and having a set of core values, DoorDash needs to make sure that it can successfully implement and follow them. Therefore, new systems and policies are required in the company to prevent the problem from happening again in the future. Firstly, DoorDash needs to state clearly how much fee and commission it will charge the restaurants and for what reason when they agree to join DoorDash's service on the contract. If necessary, a third party may be involved in the contract to ensure fairness between restaurants regardless of the size or location. Secondly, DoorDash can train a professional team that works directly with the partners, who will listen to the problems from the other side, consult and guide new partners that currently join the service, and deal with the controversy during the business in time. Besides that, DoorDash can also hire skillful managers to manage the company's finances and create reasonable spending plans to avoid the loss that leads to an increase in service fees.

    Doordash is a marketing leader in the food delivery industry as a private external third party. Their modus operandi is finding the cheapest route to profitability and that included skimming drivers and cloaking their business proposals as all profitable when they already understood the preconceived assumption which was that they’d make way more than their partnership restaurants would. The framework of approach to partnering should be remodeled, in that Doordash must not shield any information that the restaurants ought to know prior to signing an agreement. There is however the idea that altering their current practices to something new and most likely less valuable, but that isn’t the case. Doordash can still make a substantial profit if they’re open to new concepts of working. Doordash can grow their delivery business into a flourishing new restaurant of its own, building the franchise, establishing a physical store for consumers to have a closer relationship with the brand instead of the quick exchange DoorDash has with their target market over the phone. Opening a location that is an actual kitchen of its own will create a long-lasting role in whichever metropolitan city is chosen, which will greatly benefit the company because people love new gags. Another avenue DoorDash can take is, pursuing more major sponsoring deals for sports teams or other sport-themed restaurants. Buffalo Wild Wings or Bdubs as its most commonly known, is a very popular chain of restaurants who doesn't deliver but has decked our locations with flat screens of sporting events and games and excellent food. a vast majority of people would rather watch the game from the comfort of their own home. If Doordash was listed as a sponsor of BWW, on commercials, or even if we have a little signage next to theirs, then consumers would order from BWW using the DoorDash service because they know they can access BWW food without having to go out. This would make Doordash synonymous with BWW and associating popular brands and crossovers are almost always profitable. This will also help with Doordashes ethical thinking, because a partnership with BWW will have to be mutually agreeable and open, so Doordash has to learn how to cooperate correctly with outside businesses or partners. This practice of cooperation and good faith in partnership will rub off into their employing techniques, hopefully improving the system in which drivers work and giving more promotional chances and the ability to work for them for good pay. Happy employees will improve productivity resulting in an improvement in their public reputation thus improving their franchise building efforts.


Sean Lanzillo, Tram Lu, Jake Chiasson, Lesly Theodore


References

ConsumerGravity.com, 2021, “Is DoorDash Bad For Restaurants in 2021?”  

    Is DoorDash Bad For Restaurants in 2021? (consumergravity.com)

Dwyer, Ben. CardFellow Credit Card Processing Blog. April 6, 2020, “Is the DoorDash Delivery App a Good Choice for Your 

    Restaurant?” https://www.cardfellow.com/blog/doordash-for-restaurants/

Farivar, Cyrus. March 28, 2021. “DoorDash pushes back against fee delivery commissions with new charges." NBC News. 

    https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/doordash-pushes-back-against-fee-delivery-commissions-new-charges-n1262088

Feiner, Lauren. August 27, 2021. “Chicago sues DoorDash, Grubhub for allegedly deceiving customers.”  CNBC. 

    https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/27/chicago-sues-doordash-grubhub-for-allegedly-deceiving-customers.html

Huet, Ellen. December 8, 2020. “DoorDash, Chasing $3 Billion IPO, Is a Powerful Ally and Foe to Restaurants.” Bloomberg.   

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-12-08/dash-ipo-doordash-is-a-power ful-ally-and-foe-to-restaurants

Rader, Doyle, Forbes, June 21, 2020, How DoorDash's Partnership With The Dallas Mavericks Is Supporting Local Restaurants, 

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/doylerader/2020/03/29/doordash-dallas-mavericks-partnership-coronavirus-response-support-local-restaurants/?sh=19bf3ea225ab

Russell, Nicole. May 17, 2021, “Are DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub hurting restaurants? Chef Andrew Gruel says yes,” MSN.com 

    https://www.msn.com/en-us/travel/tips/are-doordash-uber-eats-and-grubhub-hurting-restaurants-chef-andrew-gruel-says-yes/ar-BB1gP0HF

WallStreetZen. November 13, 2021, “NYSE: DASH DoorDash Inc Statistics & Facts.” DoorDash Statistics-DoorDash Facts, Stats, Trends & Data (2021) | WallStreetZen

DesJardins, Joseph. An Introduction to Business Ethics. New York City: The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc, 2014.

Salazar, Heather. Kantian Business Ethics. n.d.



Friday, December 10, 2021

Doordash: Customers are Being Overcharged on Orders (2020 - 2021)

Doordash: Customers are Being Overcharged on Orders (2020 - 2021)

Price Differences when using DoorDash

Case Controversy

    DoorDash is one of the pioneers among a new and fast-growing breed of delivery apps with an increasing popularity especially over the past year. When the covid-19 pandemic hit the United States in the early months of 2020 many restaurants closed and the few that remained open could not allow sitting in as a dining option for safety reasons. Since this happened more and more people began relying on food delivery services like Doordash, Grubhub, Uber Eats, and Postmates. As of March 2020 Doordash has been reported to have a market share of 42% in the meal delivery industry (Farviar). However, the source of the company's financial success has been at the stake of its customers. Many Doordash customers have reported that they are being charged ridiculous fees on orders without their knowledge. 

    Doordash hides tax and extra service costs into the bill. The typical item costs nearly 49% more when brought through a food delivery app, not always including tip or delivery fees (Chen). Delivery fees alone are an additional 20%to 30% charge on an order (Farviar). For example, at Subway two six-inch turkey breast sandwiches costs $12.58 plus a sales tax of $0.63 totaling  $13.21 for the entire order. However, when ordered through Doordash the two six-inch turkey breast sandwiches cost $14.78 plus a delivery fee of $1.99, a service fee of 1.20 and a sales tax of $1.29 totalling $19.26. That is a 46% markup on the original price (Chen). But this is not a specific occurrence with chain restaurants. MakiMaki, a Japanese restaurant charges customers $12.95 for a particular item. The same item purchased through Doordash costs $14.80 (Stamm).
As a delivery service Doordash takes 13% to 40% of revenue from each order, while the average restaurant’s profit ranges from 3% to 9% of revenue (Dolmetsch). In order to try to ease the impact of fees customers have to pay, several cities have pushed back against Doordash by capping commissions at 15 % of the total cost of orders. By December of 2020 73 caps were put in place nationwide and 5 more by March of 2021. In response to the caps on commissions Doordash established a regulatory response fee. This additional fee is a fixed charge of $1 to $3 on top of existing delivery fees, service fees and sometimes small order fees (Forman).
On August 27th, 2021 the city of Chicago announced it was filing a consumer protection lawsuit against DoorDash and its competitor, GrubHub. Chicago policy makers, sued Doordash over their deitiful pricing and unnecessary charges on customer orders in July 2021. Regulators looking into the many hidden fees on Doordash recipes have also discovered a “Chicago fee”.  This was a fee imposed by Doordash disguised as a fee from the city of Chicago to appear unrelated to their service fees. DoorDash has denied all of these claims, however, a hearing for this case is scheduled for December 27th, 2021. Spokesmen for the company have since then relabeled these charges as more regulatory response fees (Rana).
 

Timeline of events

Stakeholders

    The stakeholders in this case that are the key decision makers are the people in charge at doordash, including CEO Tony Xu. These are the people that decide what percent markup there is on the original price of a food item, the additional delivery, service and other fees that are not clearly stated when customers order using this app. The stakeholders affected were the shareholders and customers. Tony Xu and shareholders are affected as the profits of DoorDash belong to them and as such, any impact on them directly impacts the amount of money a shareholder makes from owning DoorDash, in addition, the public image and quarterly reports of DoorDash have a significant impact on the value of their investment in DoorDash. Millions of doordash customers that have been overcharged even if they haven’t realized it yet and the hundred of thousands of restaurants that are robbed of revenues and have been forced to use doordash to stay in business after the pandemic caused so many to close doors. Customers that have recognized that they are being overcharged are less likely to purchase food through Doordash again as it would be cheaper to pick up food from restaurants directly, doing away with the additional fees on top of delivery charges. The future customers of doordash are also at stake. Existing customers are likely to give Doordash a poor recommendation based on previous experience.

Individualism

    An Individualist view of the DoorDash conflict reveals that DoorDash’s actions are at the very least morally questionable and would become morally wrong if Chicago’s lawsuit finds DoorDash to be in violation of the law. Under Individualism, businesses should maximize their profits while staying within the bounds of the law. While this is easily viewed from a short-term perspective the long-term perspective is also included as important according to Individualism. This long-term perspective is what makes DoorDash’s actions morally questionable.
    Individualism places almost no responsibility in the hands of the shareholders and considers them exterior to the moral decisions made by employees of the company. Under individualism, the employees carry most of the responsibility, and as such most make decisions that maximize profits, or else the theory considers them to be stealing from their shareholders. From this perspective and considering the fact that DoorDash has stated that they believe they have not done anything illegal, it can be reasonably believed that the employees believed themselves to be acting as morally as possible. The only fact that calls this into question is that of long-term profits, has taking these actions harmed DoorDash’s ability to make money in the future? Government involvement throughout the DoorDash cases shows that the company may have hurt its future revenue by inciting the government to pass new legislation which would be immoral to violate. DoorDash’s reputation is also harmed by the negative press, damage to relationships with restaurants, and by the high prices as many consumers may now regard the service as too expensive. The long-term harm to the company makes this morally questionable, however, if it is determined that the company committed acts there were illegal, the situation becomes morally wrong.
    Individualism’s view on this case will not become clear until a court makes a decision on their legality. However, due to negative long-term effects, the actions of DoorDash are at best morally questionable and quite possibly morally wrong.

Utilitarianism

    When observed through an ethical lens, the one that most highlights the impermissible acts of the company is utilitarianism. This theory heavily relies on the fact that happiness is the only value, it is okay to do something immoral if it benefits more people. Utilitarianism decides if something is good for society or bad for society, and it does not leave a grey area. It can also be defined as: the ‘right’ action is the action that benefits the most people in society or a business, even if that action is not morally right.  
    Utilitarianism proves the actions of Door Dash as impermissible because not only is it bad for society, but Door Dash was also taking advantage of people during COVID-19 when money was tight for a lot of families. Meanwhile, Door Dash was pocketing the money of innocent people and making the community unhealthy and unhappy. Utilitarianism is the best theory to analyze this case because it highlights how many people were treated poorly because of the scandal. When analyzing through a utilitarian lens, it is apparent that many people were taken advantage of and harmed because they were being charged more than what they should have been paying for products. Utilitarianism is the best lens to examine the case.  
    The actions of the stakeholders were impermissible because they were fully aware of the unethical treatment of the customers. They were aware that they were stealing money from them, they knew it was wrong, but continued to do so. It is not morally right and is not making most customers happy because they are being charged extra for products priced far lower than what they are paying.
The actions of the DoorDash drivers are permissible because they had to keep their jobs and were not 100 percent aware of the fact that the company was being dishonest with the public. Even if they did know some of the details, they still were doing what they thought was best for the residents of Chicago; they delivered their food and worked their jobs.
    The city of Chicago’s actions were morally required. However, it is not permissible because they needed to use taxpayer money to combat the company. This is because the city was aware of the injustices happening to the Chicagoans and how they were being taken advantage of and being overcharged. It was morally required for the city to take action against DoorDash to defend the people.


Kantianism

    Kantianism is an ethical theory that requires everyone to act rationally, help others make rational decisions, respect people's autonomy and individual needs, and be motivated by good will. Kantianism follows the categorical imperative which is the supreme law of a reason. It enables us to determine if our actions are rational or irrational. Irrational actions are impermissible therefore wrong and immoral. Rational actions, on the other hand, are permissible, allowed as they are morally correct. Kant states “Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means”. This is the formula of humanity under the categorical imperative which means to never treat humans as mere means, always as an end.
To determine if an action is permissible or impermissible Kantianism utilizes the formula of universal law. The first step is to formulate a maxim-for-action. In this instance of Doordash it is overcharging customers to increase commission on orders. The second step is to universalize the maxim. If Doordash is able to charge unnecessary fees to customers then all companies can add unnecessary charges for profit. The following step is to check for contradictions and charging additional unclear fees to customer orders in order to increase profit is deceitful. Therefore these actions are impermissible because Doordash is being deceitful. They tack on additional fees and overcharge product prices without customer knowledge. When doordash was called out for these fees a cap was placed on the amount of commissions doordash can take from orders and doordash lied and added an additional fee labeled as something else “regulatory response fee” to gain more profits. Doordash was also motivated by self interest. The company was not honest with their customers to gain a greater profit and Kant claims that it is only morally acceptable to be motivated by good will. For these reasons Kant would not believe that the actions of doordash are morally correct.

Virtue Theory

    Virtue Theory is a theory that was created by Aristotle that focuses on rationality and whether a person is virtuous or not. Virtue Theory uses four cardinal virtues in determining if someone is virtuous. These four cardinal virtues are courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. According to Aristotle, rationality is what differentiates the characteristics of people. In order to live a virtuous life, people need to act rationally. He also states that you need to act rational to function well and therefore, people who function well live virtuous lives (Salazar, pg23).  
    From the point of view of Virtue Theory, DoorDash hasn’t displayed the 4 cardinal virtues, Courage, Temperance, Honesty, and Justice. They are not courageous in the sense that they are not standing up for the right ideas and actions within their business. Taking a risk like upcharging customers by large percentages is not right. When coming under fire with lawsuits, they didn’t display honesty by not commenting on the multiple hidden fees and higher pricings and instead dodged the questioning. The temperance, or realistic expectations and desires, of DoorDash was not displayed either. Even though they may have seen this as maximizing profit, it wasn’t realistic to expect consumers to not notice the inflation of meal cost on their platform. The final virtue, Justice, was never present with DoorDash. Their practices were unfair and are not a product of hard work and good ideas.



Action Plan
New York City "Dasher" in december.

    Since the start of the covid-19 pandemic within the U.S. in early 2020, Doordash has been found to overcharge their customers by adding and hiding fees. Doordash did this to gain more profit on each order and got away with it because people did not have many other choices for food delivery services. In this process, however, Doordash was stealing from their customers. In order to become a more ethical company and maintain business Doordash needs to start removing all markups on original prices, the price on the restaurant menu should be the price the restaurant charges for the items. At this point in the ordering process the fees that are paid to Doordash should be fixed and laid out clearly. Driver compensation should be completely separate and DoorDash should not be entitled to any of the amount paid in that section. When purchasing through Doordash there should also be a clear location that allows the customer to tip the driver and restaurant separately, once again DoorDash should not be entitled to anything paid in this section. This makes it clear to the customer where their money is exactly going. The most crucial thing Doordash needs to do is clearly state each fee on the receipt. All charges should be laid out before the customer makes their purchase.
    Having a new mission statement could be helpful in guiding Doordash to becoming a more ethical company. For example, Doordash could have a mission statement that the company strives to give customers a more convenient and honest way to enjoy their favorite meals while living a busy life. To maintain this mission statement Doordash should keep some core values in mind. These values could be service, trust, reputation, and safety. DoorDash's core business is a service and as such must be a leading core value to compete in such a market. Customers should feel they received the best service possible, an experience that leaves them with the food they desired and without any frustrations. Trust is an important factor in DoorDash’s business, restaurants, drivers, and customers must all trust that DoorDash has fairly handled the exchange and is not cheating any of the parties involved. Eroding this trust could have disastrous consequences for DoorDash’s business as all of these parties are required for their operation. A solid reputation is essential to DoorDash as it is what allows them to draw in more customers, drivers, and restaurants that are vital to the operation and growth of their marketplace. As a core part of DoorDash’s business involves having customers and drivers meet for the exchange, DoorDash must ensure this is done safely and dangerous individuals are not able to exploit their platform or risk damage to their business.
    In order to maintain these values and ensure that the company does not start to practice unethical habits again there are some procedures that should be followed. It would be beneficial and productive for management to review the new conditions with employees and regularly inform of updates. The best thing that Doordash can do to prevent what has happened from occurring again is to regularly monitor how much customers are being charged on orders and analyze if it is realistic to pay that price. If any changes need to be made to the fees then these need to be clearly stated for customers to see that they do not feel robbed again. Since Doordash has tained their relationship with previous customers as a result of their unethical actions it is important for the company to have a new marketing strategy. This strategy specifically needs to be targeted towards customers that have been wronged by Doordash in the past. This marketing should focus greatly on the changes that Doordash is implementing which will reinforce the new mission statement. This new plan of action, if carried out correctly, will allow Doordash itself to stick to their own values to ensure that any existing and future customers receive the quality of service they hope to bring. Doordashes' new mission statement stresses the importance that the company strives to give customers more convenient and honest service. These things conform to the core values of service, trust, and reputation in a positive way. Ensuring that DoorDash is doing the right things will promote these core values and in turn, bring more customers and profits. This plan should push past customers to feel more comfortable using Doordash, in turn increasing the number of people that use the service. Although there are less fees, if Doordash can restore its relationship with the customers they have pushed away they can increase overall productivity. 

The cost of using doordash, the price the customer paid vs coast charged by restaraunt.

Jared Crawford, Ryley Gianni, Bella Arias, and Ethan Simard

References

Chen, Brian X. “Up to 91% More Expensive: How Delivery Apps Eat up Your Budget.” The New York Times. The New York Times, February 26, 2020. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/26/technology/personaltech/ubereats-doordash-postmates-grubhub-review.html.

Dolmetsch, Chris. “Lawsuit Alleges Grubhub, Uber Eats Are Driving up Meal Cost.” Time. Time, April 14, 2020. https://time.com/5820429/grubhub-uber-eats-doordash-lawsuit/.

Farviar, Cyrus. “DoorDash Pushes Back against Fee Delivery Commissions with New Charges.” NBCNews.com. NBCUniversal News Group, March 28, 2021. https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/doordash-pushes-back-against-fee-delivery-commissions-new-charges-n1262088.

Forman, Laura. “Food-Delivery Regulation Is a Drama Worth Watching.” The Wall Street Journal. Dow Jones & Company, March 4, 2021. https://www.wsj.com/articles/food-delivery-regulation-is-a-drama-worth-watching-11614859201.

Rana, Preetika, and Heather Haddon. “DoorDash and Grubhub's Tussles with Regulators Heat up Following Pandemic Sales Boost.” The Wall Street Journal. Dow Jones & Company, September 11, 2021. https://www.wsj.com/articles/doordash-and-grubhubs-tussles-with-regulators-heat-up-following-pandemic-sales-boost-11631352780.

Salazar, Heather. “The Business Ethics Case Manual: The Authoritative Step-by-Step Guide to Understanding and Improving the Ethics of Any Business.”


Stamm, Stephanie, Preetika Rana, and Heather Haddon. “Why Doordash and Uber Eats Delivery Is Costing You More.” The Wall Street Journal. Dow Jones & Company, May 8, 2021. https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-doordash-and-uber-eats-delivery-is-costing-you-more-11620466200.

DoorDash: Lawsuit from the City of Chicago due to divisive tipping policy (May 2019)

 

DoorDash: Lawsuit from the City of Chicago due to divisive tipping policy (May 2019)




Case Controversy

    As of September 2021, DoorDash is the largest food delivery service in the United States, delivering 57% of the United States’ food delivery orders in September.  However, prior to July of 2019 DoorDash had been using a deceptive tactic in terms of their tipping policy to pay less out of pocket to their drivers.  This policy was not only taking away tip money from drivers but was also making it so that DoorDash had to pay less base salary per delivery and would profit even more off of each order.  Since November of 2019, they have changed this policy to allow tips to be on top of the base salary, rather than a direct part of it. 

DoorDash Drivers knock on CEO's door to protest wages
DoorDash Drivers knock on CEO's door to protest wages
            In February of 2019, DoorDash began to receive the initial complaints over the tipping policy on a mass scale.  This led to an investigation into the policy, as well as a boycott by employees and tech workers.  The investigation also included other food delivery services such as Amazon Flex and Instacart, who were both accused of this same tipping deception, and Instacart would be the first to change its policy on February 6th of 2019.  However, in February of 2019, Amazon Flex and DoorDash had still not changed their policy to follow suit with Instacart and stood by their decision to not do so.  This is due in part to a private market, as DoorDash is allowed to handle its own policies unless there is governmental intervention.  This allows DoorDash to stick with its initial tipping policy rather than changing it immediately. 

            This would lead to DoorDash changing its tipping policy over the course of July to November of 2019.  Rather than subsidizing tips into base payment, they would follow the traditional method of tips being on top of base salary.  The new tipping policy ensured that “Dashers wouldn't earn less as a result of customers not tipping, DoorDash increased the amount it chipped in per delivery. The company now pays $2 to $10 per delivery out of its own pocket to cover the minimum payment.”  (Fortune.com) After this change, there were multiple lawsuits regarding the previous tipping policy, and paying the drivers for tipping money that was subsidized up to that point.

Attorney General Karl Racine
            The first lawsuit would come in November 2019 from the city of Washington D.C. and Attorney General Karl Racine.  This lawsuit would be filed under the charge that DoorDash misled consumers in Washington D.C. about how tips were being paid to the drivers.  This lawsuit would be settled a year later in November of 2020, in favor of Karl Racine and the city of Washington D.C.  The settlement would be $1.5 million to DoorDashers in a relief format, then $750,000 to Washington D.C. and $250,000 to local charities.  This totals up to $2.5 million, as well as Karl Racine requiring DoorDash to change their tipping policy to make sure all workers got their base pay amount even with tips.  While this tipping policy was already being implemented as of the prior year, the lawsuit began the same month they changed the policy so this was to ensure the policy would be used fully.   

Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot
            Then the City of Chicago, Illinois, and mayor Lori Lightfoot would sue DoorDash in August of 2021.  This lawsuit was filed under the pretenses that DoorDash, among other food delivery services, was, “using unfair and deceptive tactics to take advantage of restaurants and consumers who were struggling to stay afloat.” (Lori Lightfoot) This lawsuit is based on multiple issues, one of which being DoorDash charging higher prices for items compared to the restaurant with the new tipping and payment policies.  They were also accused of delivering food without the prior authorization of the restaurants, which is believed to cause customer unhappiness with the restaurant rather than DoorDash even though it may not be their fault.  As of November 2021, this lawsuit is still being investigated and is on trial until a conclusion comes to fruition. 

Stakeholders

    The stakeholders involved with the DoorDash case would be the DoorDash as a Company, Employees of DoorDash, Previous Consumers of DoorDash, Future Customers with DoorDash, Future Shareholders, and the General Public.  The delayed actions of DoorDash to change their policy will affect how their employees and the general public view them in the future.  Prior to the change of policy, it was reported that 80% of DoorDash workers prefer the old pre-2019 model over the pre-2017 model, the pre-2017 model being nearly identical to the new one.  A statement from DoorDash also says that “Since we implemented our pay model in 2017, Dasher satisfaction has increased while average delivery times have fallen.” (DoorDash Spokesperson)  These two factors will heavily affect how stakeholders view this situation, as the change back to the earliest policy goes against what the majority of employees want.  The future customers of DoorDash are affected by this as they now have to read through the new policies, and likely will have higher prices to even out the amount of money lost by DoorDash without tip subsidization.  In terms of future shareholders, they have to consider these policies as well, and since DoorDash was very delayed in changing these policies until they were forced to, how will they handle events such as these in the future.  The general public is affected as DoorDash currently holds 57% of the online food delivery service orders, and this impacts a large number of people around the United States.  How these stakeholders are affected and the ties to Utilitarianism with this are explained in the next section.

Individualism

            Individualism as it pertains to DoorDash, Friedman’s individualism where “the only goal of business is to profit, so the only obligation that the business person has is to maximize profit for the owner or the stockholder within the law of the land.” Applying this to DoorDash we can see how the company was using the extra tips to cover the losses they are taking on the mandated tip rate. This is unethical, the employee is entitled to at least know they are losing out on the tip and make a choice if they would want to continue to work for DoorDash instead of thinking they are getting fair treatment. The customer is also entitled to know that if a tip is required then where directly is the money going. To mislead someone so drastically by advertising you are tipping the driver when it's really you’re covering the losses the company has placed on themselves clearly falls into the impermissible category. Regarding Machan’s Individualism “the only direct goal of business is to profit, and the primary obligation of the business person is to maximize profit within the law but: the direct goal of profiting may need to be met by indirect goals and not aimed at profiting, business people may have other goals and those goals may at times be prioritized over the goals of profit-maximizing.”

            The impacts the DoorDash lawsuits by the business should worry about the profits yes, but also worry about employees and customers, it may come as a loss but are you a company of enough morals to look at these potential losses and say it’s better for us to lose the tip money or lose the customers and employees. To an extent, DoorDash should be concerned with the profit and the return they are receiving. The company had every opportunity to come clean and say they made a mistake and grew too big to continue this guarantee. Instead, they decided to try and cover it secretly. They gambled and lost. Was it more important to cover a deal they offered to employees or the respect and moral integrity of the company? With these impermissible acts, they are facing a more drastic loss, the customer.

Utilitarianism

    A utilitarian would view this situation as the least ethically beneficial, including how DoorDash handled it and the situation itself.  The primary goal of utilitarianism is happiness for the majority of all parties involved.  To specifically quote the ethical rule of utilitarianism, “Business actions should aim to maximize the happiness in the long run for all conscious beings that are affected by the business action.” (Salazar 19) Salazar (19) also notes that “The basic method is to analyze the costs and benefits of a particular course of action.”  In the case of DoorDash, the happiness of all groups was not maximized, but rather the opposite, which includes the following groups:

DoorDash Company: DoorDash in ultimately every sense lost in this scenario, due to the many different factors involved in this situation.  They had to give up over $100 million in lawsuits during this course of time, had to change their policy on tipping subsidization which makes them less money, and lost future customers and employees due to their lack of change until they were required to do so.  The slow initiative of DoorDash to pay their workers more, which is still ongoing as of November 2021, will harm them in the long term financially and in terms of future employment opportunities.

Employees of DoorDash: While the tipping policy was reversed so that now tips are not included in base pay, this will likely negatively impact the employees long term.  The settlement by DoorDash to give money back to the employees only gave roughly $130 to each member, which is much more than the tipping amount that was subsidized (DoorDash Class Settlement)  This also negatively impacts DoorDash employees in the future, as the prior 2017-2019 policy was preferred by 80% of employees, so this does not maximize their happiness.

Customers of DoorDash: The previous customers of DoorDash will not have maximized happiness with this situation, as their tips were not given to the drivers in the normal sense.  The customers would be tipping to show appreciation to the driver for them bringing their food, not to subsidize their base pay and pay off their salary.  Then in terms of future customers, they would have to deal with potential price heightening from DoorDash, which has already been reported by the Chicago lawsuit, to cover for the tipping money they are not subsidizing. 

Future Shareholders: Future shareholders would have trouble trusting the company first off, due to their delayed fixing of company policies regarding tipping.  This also applies to the currently pending lawsuit against DoorDash for their policies, and the potential loss of employees and customers gradually over time.  The future of the company, especially with the new policy that the majority

Kantianism

            Kantianism is based on making and respecting ethical, rational decisions. Ethics is a sense of what is right and remaining loyal to those who work from you and purchase from you. This also means that the person themselves is not above the law or being ethical. Kantianism is in a sense “practice what you preach” what you would preach is making smart and ethical choices based on facts and reasons while helping others to do the same.

            Kantianism was not followed when comparing it to the DoorDash tipping policy. The first thing that shows that it does not follow the theory is the ethics part of the theory. Keeping a tip that was promised to someone when you are a billion-dollar company I would argue is extremely unethical. As already stated, these delivery drivers usually do not make a lot of money delivering orders to the customers, so those tips are highly important to them and their livelihood. Another reason why Kantianism would find this impermissible is that DoorDash is not letting its customers make a rational choice when it comes to tipping. Kantianism is big on helping others make rational choices with all the right information available to them. If DoorDash is giving their customer, the right to tip their delivery driver on the app the customer is under the impression that the driver is the one receiving the tip they are giving. This was obviously not correct and was misguiding the customer to tip DoorDash themselves and not the person handling their order. This is not letting the customer make a rational choice since they do not have accurate information on where the tip would be going. Overall, The DoorDash tipping controversy will be deemed unethical by Kantianism.

Virtue Theory

            A Virtue Theorist would look at the way DoorDash handled this situation as ethical. In the views of Virtue Theory, for a business to be ethical they must focus more on the process of getting the goal rather than strictly caring about achieving the goal. With the old tipping model, DoorDash would be considered very unethical according to those 4 virtues.

            With the Courage Virtue, it is important to find the middle ground between rashness and cowardice. DoorDash took a risk by not giving out the maximum amount of money to their workers. DoorDash was seeking to maximize their profits which a company should be striving to do so but by taking money out of their worker's pockets is not a good middle ground to settle in. The new tipping policy gave DoorDash room to grow in the Courage Virtue by finding a good middle ground of a larger tip will not decrease the base pay paid by DoorDash.

            When it comes to the Honesty Virtue it is key to be transparent with the public about the treatment of employees, customers, business partners in all aspects of the business. By unknowingly using tips to pay some of the base pay, this allows DoorDash to pay out less money to workers in return making them more money. The only issue is DoorDash wasn’t telling people that’s how it worked, they were working in silence. This is the biggest change DoorDash had when it came to the new policy. The settlement forcing DoorDash to be completely transparent with their workers and consumers allows them to put them back on the ethical side of the Honesty Virtue.

            The Temperance Virtue is to have reasonable desires and expectations. I think in this case DoorDash has reasonable desires when it comes to them seeking to maximize the money made for the company but their expectations of taking tips away from drivers would never fit into any business model. The Temperance Virtue is the only virtue DoorDash really didn’t change after the settlement because their desires and expectations had nothing wrong with them.

            The Justice virtue is hard work, quality products, good ideas, and fair practices. The employees of DoorDash were very hard workers and produces quality products but the practices done on the end of the company were unfair. Taking tips away from people is the same as taking money out of their pocket. Knowingly doing this to your employees is wrong. After the settlement, DoorDash had improved the Justice Virtue to become much more ethical than before. The new tipping policy shows good new practices compared to their old bad ones.

Action Plan

            The current issue displayed by DoorDash, in this case, is that they are being extremely unethical towards their employees and customers in a multitude of ways.  Firstly, the subsidization of tips to pay for their employees base wages, without notifying them that this is what they were doing.  This also impacts their customers, as the tips they are giving are intended to go to the driver directly for exemplary service, not just to pay their base salary.  To truly acknowledge this issue, DoorDash needs to be able to admit that they were using deceptive payment methods to their drivers, which they still have not done.  The choice to take accountability for what they did will show that DoorDash is aware of what they did and will give them the image they hope to have in that they have responsibility for their actions.  Next, they would need to pay reparations to those employees affected by this, and they should receive the sum amount of tips taken and used towards their base pay.  This would be the most surefire way to show the company has evolved and would prove that they care about the employees over profit. 

            The next step would be a rebrand of the company, firstly starting with their mission statement.  Their mission statement currently says, “We're working to empower local communities and in turn, creating new ways for people to earn, work, and thrive. We believe in delivering goods by connecting people and possibility.”  (DoorDash).  There are a few ways this mission statement can be improved after the case, one of which is adding a section regarding deceptive tactics.  A new example of such would be, “We’re working to empower local communities and in turn, creating new ways for people to earn, work, and thrive.  We believe in delivering goods by connecting people and possibility, while also using fair and honest values to do so.”  This new mission statement is not a far cry from the initial, however, it shows they are focusing on the addition of fair and honest methods to help their company thrive. 

            The new core values for them to follow are commitment, honesty, fairness, respect, and accountability.  To improve upon the company, DoorDash will have to be committed to finding a way to improve the company standards and help their employees thrive, not just the company.  They will need to be honest, and make sure employees clearly understand how they are being paid, and customers understand where their tip money goes.  They will need to change their policy on this payment method to further benefit the employees for their hard work, and make sure tips are directly being used for their initial intent.  Fairness to employees is a huge issue and can be addressed the same way, as the employees are not being treated fairly compared to other delivery services due to this case.  Respect and accountability finally, which come from DoorDash admitting to their deceptive tactics and building a new future to improve the lives of all people involved.  If they can go above and beyond by not just improving the company, but also the employees’ and customers’ experiences, then they can truly move forward from this case.

            To prevent this from happening again, they should focus on fully implementing the new tipping utilization so that it is never used for base wages again.  They should focus on creating new rules within the company to prevent any more deceptive tactics from forming, and whichever employees can stick to this and come up with a way of doing so can receive promotion.  Training would also be beneficial as it would allow employees of DoorDash itself to understand how to be open and clear with the drivers and customers while still being helpful. 

            All of this will help promote profit and productivity, as it is enticing customers to tip so DoorDash will still be paying the base amount but there will likely be more orders.  With this, more drivers will apply to the company and take more orders, making the company profit, and increasing their outreach.  This conforms to the mission statement and core values as it is honest and being respectful of those who work for the company, and is fair to all employees across their network, which also ensures good ethics. 

Authors: Jeremy Trottier, Brian Wiener, Owen Stanton, Ryan Suprin, Grace Trembley

 

References
-Dickey, Megan Rose. “DoorDash Tipping Practices Prompts Lawsuit from DC Attorney General.” TechCrunch, TechCrunch, 19 Nov. 2019, https://techcrunch.com/2019/11/19/doordash-tipping-practices-prompts-lawsuit-from-dc-attorney-general/

-EntreCourier, Author. “Doordash Taxes Made Easy: A Complete Guide for Dashers.” EntreCourier, 4 Oct. 2021, https://entrecourier.com/delivery/delivery-contractor-taxes/how-taxes-work/doordash-taxes/

-Rapier, Graham. “DoorDash Uses a Shady Tactic That Stiffs Workers out of Some Tips and Customers Are Furious.” Business Insider, Business Insider, 22 July 2019, https://www.businessinsider.com/doordash-delivery-tipping-practices-under-fire-cash-2019-7

-Tran, Sheila. “The Ethical Delivery Dilemma.” SF Weekly, 9 Apr. 2021, https://www.sfweekly.com/dining/ethical-delivery-app-dilemma-food/

-Canales, Katie. “DoorDash Is Paying $2.5 Million to Settle a Lawsuit That Accused the Food Delivery Company of Stealing Drivers' Tips.” Business Insider. Business Insider, November 25, 2020. https://www.businessinsider.com/doordash-25-million-settlement-lawsuit-tipping-model-2020

-Ghaffary, Shirin. “Pressure Is Mounting on Food Delivery App Doordash to Change Its Controversial Tipping Policy.” Vox. Vox, March 8, 2019. https://www.vox.com/2019/3/8/18253378/doordash-tipping-food-delivery-gig-economy-worker-rights

-Kelso, Alicia. “DoorDash Settles Lawsuit over Old Tipping Model for $2.5M.” Restaurant Dive, November 25, 2020. https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/doordash-settles-lawsuit-over-old-tipping-model-for-25m/589702/

-Kerr, Dara. “DoorDash Settles Lawsuit for $2.5m over 'Deceptive' Tipping Practices.” CNET. CNET, November 25, 2020. https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/doordash-settles-lawsuit-for-2-5m-over-deceptive-tipping-practices/