Controversy
Because of the increased number of lithium-ion batteries being produced,
there is a soon approaching shortage of the main element used to make them,
Cobalt. Apple is trying to cut out the middle man and buy Cobalt straight from
the mines themselves and 60% of the world’s supply of Cobalt comes from the
Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). The supply chain for Cobalt is very
secretive in the sense of where the material comes from. Once the material is
mined it is put into burlap bag with no label on them. The bags are then sold
to Chinese or Japanese companies and are shipped out of DRC very quickly with
very little documentation. The mines are known for terrible human rights
violations and child labor. Children as young as four years old work to harvest
the material and are paid eight pence, or 11 cents, a day and normally work for
12 hours a day. In 2016, the DRC revised their labor laws and raised the
minimum age of workers to 18 years old, but because of the lack of trained
personnel and resources has hindered the government’s effort to stop the use of
child labor.
Stakeholders
In
this controversy, there are two main parties of stakeholders involved. The
first would be the stockholders of Apple. They invest their money in Apple so
that that can get a return on said investment. If Apple’s value decreases
because they are using child mined materials in their electronic devices, the
stockholders will not be happy. The second groups of stakeholders are the children
working in the mine. If there were less of a demand for Cobalt to build these
batteries, there would be no need for children to work in these mines to
harvest as much Cobalt as they can.
Individualism
Individualism theory by Milton Friedman says that “The only goal of
business is to profit, so the obligation that the business person has to
maximize profit for the owner or the stockholders”. As long as an action makes
a company’s stockholders a profit and stays within basic laws, an individualist
would see it as ethical. For this case, an individualist would say it is
unethical because child labor is illegal in the DRC. Even though buying Cobalt
from mines that use child labor would be cheaper that buying Cobalt from larger
companies it is breaking laws and therefore impermissible.
Kantianism
The main principle that
Kantians believe in is the formula of humanity, which states that you should
not treat people as a mere means to an end and is focused around acting in good
will while still allowing people to make rational decisions. The children in
the mines are treated horribly and are forced to work in heat, rain, and other
harsh weather conditions. Also, if the supervisors feel like they are not
working hard enough, the children are threatened with beatings. The adults in
the mines that are in charge are not acting out of good will. They are taking
advantage of children that are too young to be working and are also exposing
them to harmful chemicals that come off of the material when it is mined. For all
of the reasons above, a Kantian would see this case as unethical.
Utilitarianism
A Utilitarian
says that happiness or pleasure is the only things of intrinsic value and
because of this they would say this case is unethical. The children working to
produce the materials to make the batteries are nowhere close to happy. They are
treated like they are disposable by the adults who run the mines. Also, they
are paid so little, they are not able to purchase food on a daily basis and go
hungry for days until they can afford to buy food. If a child is working a 12
hour day and still cannot manage to pay for a meal, I highly doubt they are
happy.
Virtue Theory
Virtue
Theorists have four points that they consider when deciding what is ethical or
unethical, and they are courage, honesty, temperance, and justice. Based off of
those points, they would see this case as unethical. Apple was not being
courageous in this case. Although they did release a statement saying that they
were putting guidelines in place to stop the use of child labor products, they
did it to fix their mistake. They were
not being honest because even though they say they lead the industry in supply
chain standards, there is no possible way that they can know if their Cobalt is
coming from DRC or not because there is no documentation on Cobalt when it
leaves the mines in the DRC. Apple was not practicing temperance because the
expectation that materials coming from these types of countries are not mined
by children is unreasonable. Finally, Apple was not practicing justice because
they were not buying this material for a fair price and these materials are
collected through unfair practices.
References
CBS News. “CBS News Finds Children Mining Cobalt for
Batteries in the Congo.” CBS News, CBS Interactive, 5 Mar. 2018, www.cbsnews.com/news/cobalt-children-mining-democratic-republic-congo-cbs-news-investigation/.
Cuthbertson, Anthony. “Apple Faces Child Labor
Scrutiny as It Looks to Take Charge of Cobalt Mines.” Newsweek, 26 Feb. 2018,
www.newsweek.com/apple-faces-child-labor-scrutiny-it-looks-take-charge-cobalt-mines-815981.
Farchy, Jack, and Mark Gurman. “Apple in Talks to
Buy Cobalt Directly From Miners.”Bloomberg.com, Bloomberg, 21 Feb. 2018,
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-02-21/apple-is-said-to-negotiate-buying-cobalt-direct-from-miners.
News, Sky. “Meet Dorsen, 8, Who Mines Cobalt to Make
Your Smartphone Work.” Sky News, 28 Feb. 2017,
news.sky.com/story/meet-dorsen-8-who-mines-cobalt-to-make-your-smartphone-work-10784120.
Dillet, Romain. “Apple Could Be Buying Cobalt from
Mining Companies Directly.” TechCrunch, TechCrunch, 21 Feb. 2018,
techcrunch.com/2018/02/21/apple-could-be-buying-cobalt-from-mining-companies-directly/
No comments:
Post a Comment