Controversy
Disney is world known
company that produce entertainment for the families all over the globe. But
been such a huge and influencing company it is hard not to be in a spotlight of
controversies. One of the latest controversy that Disney was accused is whitewashing.
Whitewashing is when someone who is looked at as leaving behind or neglecting
their culture and assimilating to a white, western culture (Urban dictionary).
Simply speaking, it is when movie productions take white actors to play
characters that originally were black, Asian etc. Disney was starting to get in the webs of the controversy in 2017, when they announced the cast for the live-action movie adaptation of original cartoon "Aladdin" (1992) that will come out in 2019. Company was accused in whitewashing when it was revealed that main female part is going to be played by Naomi Scott, who is originally British-Indian and not Arab, as Princess Jasmine originally is. What putted more firewood into the fire is that after this, it's been revealed that "Aladdin" (2019) will introduce a totally new character - Prince Anders played by Billy Magnussen, American actor.
Tilda Swinton & Ancient One (Comics ver.) |
It is also worth mentioning a similar incident happened a few years ago, when Tilda Swinton got a part in Marvel Studio's "Doctor Strange" (2016), which is ironically a part of Disney corporation. She played Ancient One, who is originally Asian male. At that time, people also were not happy by that decision.
Stakeholders
As Disney is billions worth company that is on market
for 95 years (since 1923), it gained trust and money from the stakeholders and
they need to keep them happy. As customers/ audiences are the main and mostly
only who brings money to the company and now they are unsatisfied they won't
bring money to the company and Disney will lose stakeholders trust as the price
of the stocks are going to lose value as well.
Individualism
Naomi Scott & Billy Magnussen
|
As Friedman's theory of individualism is basically
that the only obligation that the company has is to maximize
profit and satisfy stockholders. Disney wanted to hire actor's that are
familiar to the audiences and attract them to watch movie. They ignored the
original to maximize the profit.
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism is
basically maximizing stakeholders' happiness. Utilitarians would see this case
as unethical as they didn't maximize happiness of stakeholders as company will
lose profit by selling less movie tickets, toys etc.
Kantianism
Aladdin Teaser Poster |
Immanuel Kant came up
with Kantian business ethics, which follows four basic principles: act
rationally, allow and help people to make rational decisions, respect people
and be motivated by good will. From Kantianist point of view this case leans
more towards as unethical. People have been fans for many years and now when
they can see the live-action adaptation of the classic cartoon with Arabic
background, they will see non-Arabic or close to it actors playing those
characters. Also, by giving parts to non-Arabic /Eastern countries' actors the
roles they don't promote those actors and don't give them opportunity to show
what they are capable of.
Virtue Theory
Virtue Theory focuses on the act itself and why it is unethical. It
contains four characteristics: courage, honesty, justice and temperance. In
this case Disney didn't have enough courage to hire Arabic /Eastern countries'
actors, which also connects with justice. They didn't show honesty in why they
hired Arabic /Eastern countries' actors. If Disney would give the opportunity
to the actors from Eastern countries to play parts in the movie this unethical
case wouldn't take a place.
References:
Entertainment (2018, January 08). Aladdin: Disney defends 'making up'
white actors to 'blend in' during crowd scenes - BBC Newsbeat. Retrieved March
03, 2018, from
http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/42601893/aladdin-disney-defends-making-up-white-actors-to-blend-in-during-crowd-scenes
Shepherd, J. (2018,
January 07). Disney accused of 'browning up' white actors for various Asian
roles in Aladdin. Retrieved March 03, 2018, from
https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/disney-aladdin-brown-up-cast-will-smith-extra-long-a8146361.html
Evans, M. M. (2018,
January 10). Disney slammed over makeup trick in new Aladdin. Retrieved March
03, 2018, from
http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/movies/disneys-use-of-dark-makeup-on-aladdin-set-causes-more-whitewashing-backlash/news-story/7ee148cfd7808b8f6d01e2d93548fb3e
Flint, H. (2017, September 07). Here's why putting a white character in
Aladdin is offensive. Retrieved March 03, 2018, from
http://metro.co.uk/2017/09/07/aladdin-putting-a-white-character-in-disneys-live-action-remake-is-offensive-6909516/
Oppenheim,
M. (2017, September 06). Disney accused of whitewashing after creating role for
white actor out of thin air. Retrieved March 03, 2018, from
https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/disney-aladdin-white-actor-billy-magnussen-whitewashing-racism-backlash-response-a7933201.html
Good work Edik I see some improvement from the first draft. Keep working
ReplyDelete